FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS INTEGRATION AND COMPENSATION

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS INTEGRATION AND COMPENSATION"

Transcription

1 FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS INTEGRATION AND COMPENSATION Stefan Kratzmeir*, IFAB Institute for applied fire safety research, Rostock, Germany Max Lakkonen, FOGTEC Fire Protection, Cologne, Germany ABSTRACT After several years of discussion and enamours efforts in research and development Fixed Fire Fighting Systems (FFFS) in Tunnel, particularly based on water mist technology, are an accepted measure to increase the level of safety in road tunnels. Most systems that are already in operation or in construction, e.g. A86 West, M30 in Madrid or the Virgolo Tunnel on the Brenner Highway, are increasing the level of safety as these tunnels are presenting a high risk potential. However, tunnel owners and operator are confronted with the problem of exorbitantly rising costs for tunnel safety. Therefore the aim for any further innovations should be either to increase the today s accepted level of safety with no extra costs or to reach the level of safety by reduced costs compared when using measures that are prescriptive. Former research work has shown that most likely by implementing FFFS based on water mist technology other safety measures can be compensated partly. This might be the case e.g. for ventilations systems, passive fire protection or emergency exits. Depending on the specific project, this may lead to a significant decrease of costs for the total safety system of the tunnel. After the success of the SOLIT research project, which was funded by the German government during and the even more extensive project SOLIT² will focus on the integration of FFFS into holistic tunnel safety systems as well as the compensation of other safety measures. A major part of the project will be the development of a method to plan and evaluate compensatory measures in a modular way. This will include a basic risk analysis as well as the cost benefit analysis for the state of the art solution as well as the innovative solution. Furthermore a method how to proof the effectiveness as well as the same level of safety is under development to be finally approved by a consultant. Based on an example of a upgrading of a tunnel ventilation system, the paper will give a brief overview about the process and methods developed by the partners of the SOLIT² project of planning and evaluating the implementation of a FFFS to partly compensate the power of a tunnel ventilation system. The aim should be to reach a state of the art level of safety by decreasing the costs for the refurbishment and improvement works. Fixed Fire Suppression Systems; Compensation; Integration 323

2 Fourth International Symposium on Tunnel Safety and Security, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, March 17-19, 2010 STATE OF THE ART OF FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS Figure 1: Spray test with water mist system [1] During the last years several tunnels throughout Europe where equipped with fixed fire fighting systems (FFFS) mainly based on water mist technology. Also today in few tunnels, e.g. the New Tyne Crossing in Newcastle, such systems are in the installation process. Within Europe more than 35 km of tunnel are equipped with FFFS but these systems can be seen in most cases as ad-on safety measure. They were installed to increase the level of safety but were not required according to rules or standards. Refering to the opinion of many experts the benefits of these systems are obvious. According to the work of several research projects, e.g. UPTUN or SOLIT, the main aims of these systems are [2]: Protect the tunnel structure and minimize the damages on the tunnel Hampering fire spread to adjacent objects, e.g. other trucks Facilitate the work of the rescue services Improvement of the self rescue conditions for people inside the tunnel The layout basis for all systems are full scale fire tests with severe truck fire loads as it were used during the SOLIT research project or e.g. for the Roertunnel. General recommendations for the system layout and minimum technical requirements can be found in the UPTUN guidance R251 [3] as well as in the latest version of the NFPA 502 [4]. Also PIARC recently published some recommendations for FFFS in tunnels. PROMISING RESULTS POTENTIAL FOR COMPENSATION The focus of the research projects in the past was to study the effectiveness of water mist systems in tunnel fires regarding the fire suppression and cooling effect. However during analyzing the data received from the full scale fire test it turned out that there are promising results giving already clear hints to partly compensate some other safety elements by using FFFS. This will be further explained in the following examples [5]: Ventilation In particular during the SOLIT fire tests using class B fire load up to 40 MW with a strong smoke potential it turned out that the effectiveness of the longitudinal as well as semi-transversal ventilation system was increased during the activation of the water mist system. In the fire tests with a longitudinal ventilation of approx. 1,5 m/s a strong back layering effect was observed during the pre-burn time. Shortly after activation of the water mist system the area upstream of the fire was completely free of smoke without changing the ventilation regime. Similar observations were also made during tests with a semi-transversal ventilation system. 324

3 Fig. 2: Smoke in the upstream area: Above during pre-burn time; below after activation of the FFFS Temperatures: The main fire fighting effect of water mist systems is the cooling effect. Due to the huge reaction surface in relation to the volume of the droplet a significant reduction of the temperature can be observed during activation of the FFFS. Even in a worst case the area of high temperatures can be limited to only few metres directly above the fire. During a free burning fire usually temperatures of 1200 C or even more can be expected in this area at the ceiling. After activation of the water mist system, the temperatures are immediately reduced to below 400 C in some tests and even below 50 C in distance of 10 m from the fire as it can be seen in Fig. 3. Figure 3: Temperatures along the tunnel during a fire test. FFFS activated after 4 min. Due to the lower temperatures the heat impact on the tunnel structure and infrastructure is significantly less. Therefore a reduction of the damages can be expected. Gas concentrations: Due to the limitation of the fire size and the fire suppression effect of the FFFS also gas concentrations are also reduced compared to an open fire. Therefore the effects on people are also reduced. The following table shows gas concentrations measured in fire tests with truck fire loads in comparison with fixed limit values from the literature and free burning fires. 325

4 Min./Max. concentration at breathing height Vol% during a fire test Fixed Limit Value for 30 min. exposure Vol% Free burning Fire (150 MW) Vol% O 2 19,41 15 CO 2 1, CO 0,22 0,14 0,16 0,4 3,0 By applying fractional effective dose models (FED) to the planning process of the overall safety concept, the time available for the self-recue of people can be estimated. COMPENSATION OF STANDARD SAFTEY ELEMENTS In general the term compensation in the field of safety engineering can be defined as achieving the same level of safety by other measures or methods than described in rules or standards. Prescriptive rules and guidelines were often used in the past and usually are now defining the accepted level of safety in the tunnel. Particularly for extensive projects standard measures may lead to a high complexity or high costs. Furthermore if the safety level should be increased, e.g. due to new knowledge or for better social acceptance, the costs are usually increasing disproportionately. Therefore the trend to a performance based design of safety systems is obvious. The aim the will be, as shown in Figure 4 that the safety level can be increased with the same costs or that same level of safety can be kept by reducing the costs. Safety level Increasing Safety Level same costs Todays accepted safety measures (prescriptive) Increasing Safety Level higher costs Same Safety Level less costs Costs of the safety system Figure 4: Correlation between the safety level and the costs of a safety system (schematic) The general chance from a prescriptive way of planning complex tunnel systems to a holistic approach opens the possibility to individually design the tunnel safety system. Based on a risk analysis the safety system can be build up with from a tool box of measures e.g. containing passive fire protection, ventilation systems, self-recue concepts, active fire suppressions system and the rescue services. Even 326

5 the EU tunnel directive gives the chance to use innovative measures as long as it can be proven that the same level of safety as defined in the standard will be achieved. Of course for performing a holistic approach in designing an overall tunnel safety concept the effectiveness of all measures and the potential of compensation must be checked. In particular for FFFS this information is only available in a qualitative way but there is still a lack of quantitative and reliable data. In a second step an overall cost analysis must be performed. This is not only including the cost for implementing any system but also the life-cycle-costs of the system. In a third step questions regarding reliability of the systems should be examined and systems should be compared to each other. Up to now, even for systems that are well know since years, hardly any data is available for this task up to know. It can be summarized that test results already showed a great potential in reducing costs or increasing the level of safety by partly compensating today s used standard safety measures with FFFS. But still some data is needed for FFFS as well as for other systems. PROSPECTS AND FUTURE WORK Its was clearly identified by in the expert world that future research work must be carried out to create a reliable base for integration of FFFS into the tunnel safety system and compensation of other safety measures. The German government just recently launched the new research project SOLIT² (further information: A consortium including FOGTEC, STUVA, BUNG, University of Bochum and TÜV Süd will deeply investigate the possibilities of including FFFS into the risk analysis process and therefore compare the effects of FFFS and other safety measures in a holistic process. To verify the models and methods developed within the project an extensive fire test program will be carried out during Furthermore the focus will be set on life cycle cost models for FFFS and in comparison with other safety measures. This will be a helpful tool to decide the most cost effective combination of safety measures seen over the whole life time of the systems and the tunnel. After finalizing the project works the results will be published as an engineering guidance to assist consultants, tunnel owners, operators and authorities that are dealing with tunnel safety. Up to now, there are no fixed rules and methods how compensation of safety measures in tunnels should be determined. But it can be assumed that this will be change within a very short period of time and also organisations as PIARC or NFPA 502 will include these topics in their procedures and recommendations. REFERENCES 1. FOGTEC Fire Protection, Cologne 2. Kratzmeir, S. and Starke H., SOLIT Safety of Life in Tunnels: Forschungsbericht, Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft und Technologie, Not public 3. UPTUN Guidance R251: Engineering Guidance for Water Based Fire Fighting Systems for the. Protection of Tunnels and Subsurface Facilities National Fire Protection Association: NFPA 502 Standard for Road Tunnels, Bridges, and Other Limited Access Highways. Issue Kratzmeir S. Substitution Promising results, challenge for the future ITA-COSUF / IMWA workshop Fire Suppression in Tunnels: Munich 327

COMPENSATORY EFFECTY OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS

COMPENSATORY EFFECTY OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS - 259 - COMPENSATORY EFFECTY OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS Kratzmeir S. 1, Rothe R. 1 Peters B. 2, 1 IFAB Institute for applied fire safety research, Rostock 2 Fogtec Fire Protection, Cologne

More information

SOLIT PROJECT: WATER MIST FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS AS PART OF THE TUNNEL SAFETY SYSTEM

SOLIT PROJECT: WATER MIST FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS AS PART OF THE TUNNEL SAFETY SYSTEM - 157 - SOLIT PROJECT: WATER MIST FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS AS PART OF THE TUNNEL SAFETY SYSTEM Kratzmeir S. FOGTEC Fire Protection, Research & Development, Germany Keywords: Fire Protection, Fire suppression,

More information

COMPENSATORY EFFECTS OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS. Stefan Kratzmeir Managing Director.

COMPENSATORY EFFECTS OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS. Stefan Kratzmeir Managing Director. COMPENSATORY EFFECTS OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS Stefan Kratzmeir Managing Director www.ifab-fire.com FFFS in Tunnels State of the Art FFFS in Tunnels are an accepted measure to increase

More information

IMPROVING VENTILATION AND PASSIVE PROTECTION WITH FFFS

IMPROVING VENTILATION AND PASSIVE PROTECTION WITH FFFS - 195 - IMPROVING VENTILATION AND PASSIVE PROTECTION WITH FFFS Rajko Rothe; IFAB, Berlin, Germany Max Lakkonen and Dirk Sprakel, FOGTEC Fire Protection, Cologne, Germany ABSTRACT This paper discusses the

More information

Optimisation of ventilation systems costs by using fixed fire fighting systems (FFFS) in tunnels

Optimisation of ventilation systems costs by using fixed fire fighting systems (FFFS) in tunnels Optimisation of ventilation systems costs by using fixed fire fighting systems (FFFS) in tunnels Rajko Rothe IFAB Institute for applied fire safety research, Berlin, Germany Max Lakkonen, Tobias Hoffmann

More information

FIRESEAT

FIRESEAT PROTECTION OF TUNNELS WITH WATER MIST SYSTEMS Stefan Kratzmeir IFAB ABSTRACT Water Mist Systems are more and more used for the protection of tunnels. The development started with the European research

More information

FINDINGS FROM FIRE TESTS IN TUNNEL CONSTRUCTIONS WITH VENTILATION SYSTEMS AND FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS

FINDINGS FROM FIRE TESTS IN TUNNEL CONSTRUCTIONS WITH VENTILATION SYSTEMS AND FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS - 203 - FINDINGS FROM FIRE TESTS IN TUNNEL CONSTRUCTIONS WITH VENTILATION SYSTEMS AND FIXED FIRE SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS Hofer R., IBS Institute for Technical Fire Protection and Safety Research, Linz / Austria

More information

Innovative Solutions for Active Fire Protection in Road/Rail Tunnels and Underground Facilities

Innovative Solutions for Active Fire Protection in Road/Rail Tunnels and Underground Facilities Innovative Solutions for Active Fire Protection in Road/Rail Tunnels and Underground Facilities Roger A. Dirksmeier, FOGTEC Fire Protection, Germany Fire Protection Conference Tel Aviv, 4 th of April 2016

More information

Fixed Fire Fighting Systems for Road and Rail Tunnels

Fixed Fire Fighting Systems for Road and Rail Tunnels 40 Brandschutz Fire Safety Tunnel 1/2012 1 Activation of FFFS in the commissioning test of M30 tunnels in Madrid, Spain [8] Fixed Fire Fighting Systems for Road and Rail Tunnels Today, fixed fire fighting

More information

Impact of quick incident detection on safety in terms of ventilation response

Impact of quick incident detection on safety in terms of ventilation response Impact of quick incident detection on safety in terms of ventilation response P. J. Sturm 1) ; C. Forster 2) ; B. Kohl 2) ; M. Bacher 1) 1) Institute for Internal Combustion Engines and Thermodynamics

More information

Jonathan Redding Area Sales Manager FOGTEC Fire Protection Cologne, Germany

Jonathan Redding Area Sales Manager FOGTEC Fire Protection Cologne, Germany Making rail systems more efficient by using on-board Fire Protection Systems Jonathan Redding Area Sales Manager FOGTEC Fire Protection Cologne, Germany Key Presentation Take-Aways Holistic approach to

More information

Impact of Tunnel Ventilation on Tunnel Fixed Fire Suppression System

Impact of Tunnel Ventilation on Tunnel Fixed Fire Suppression System Impact of Tunnel Ventilation on Tunnel Fixed Fire Suppression System Igor Maevski, PhD, PE Jacobs Engineering, ASHRAE Member Raymond C. Klein, PE Jacobs Engineering, ASHRAE Member ABSTRACT Recently there

More information

High-pressure water mist systems and fire testing. Max Lakkonen IFAB Institute for Applied Fire Safety Research

High-pressure water mist systems and fire testing. Max Lakkonen IFAB Institute for Applied Fire Safety Research High-pressure water mist systems and fire testing Max Lakkonen IFAB Institute for Applied Fire Safety Research Content of presentation IFAB Company Application fields Services High-pressure water mist

More information

Increasing Fire Safety of Cologne Main Station by High Pressure Water Mist

Increasing Fire Safety of Cologne Main Station by High Pressure Water Mist Increasing Fire Safety of Cologne Main Station by High Pressure Water Mist Dipl.-Ing. Rüdiger Kopp FOGTEC Fire Protection ruediger.kopp@fogtec.com 1 Background of this Presentation In recent years the

More information

FOGTEC Rail Systems. Rolling Stock Applications. Fire Protection Solutions from one source. Experts in Fire Protection

FOGTEC Rail Systems. Rolling Stock Applications. Fire Protection Solutions from one source. Experts in Fire Protection Fire Protection Solutions from one source FOGTEC Rail Systems Rolling Stock Applications Modern Trends of Fire Protection in Rolling Stock 2014 designed for rail Warsaw, 25 1 Smart Concepts using innovative

More information

An experimental study of the impact of tunnel suppression on tunnel ventilation

An experimental study of the impact of tunnel suppression on tunnel ventilation An experimental study of the impact of tunnel suppression on tunnel ventilation Yoon J. Ko and George Hadjisophocleous Civil and Environmental Engineering, Carleton University 1125 Colonel By Drive, Ottawa,

More information

SOLIT Safety of Life in Tunnels

SOLIT Safety of Life in Tunnels SOLIT Safety of Life in Tunnels Engineering Guidance for a Comprehensive Evaluation of Tunnels with Fixed Fire Fighting Systems using the example of water based Fixed Fire Fighting Systems Scientific Final

More information

FOGTEC Rail Systems. Rolling Stock Applications. Fire Protection Solutions from one source. Leading in Fire Protection

FOGTEC Rail Systems. Rolling Stock Applications. Fire Protection Solutions from one source. Leading in Fire Protection Fire Protection Solutions from one source FOGTEC Rail Systems Rolling Stock Applications The Smarter Way of Fire Fighting 1 TUNNEL FIRE PROTECTION Tel Aviv, 4th April 2016 Michele Barbagli Area Sales Manager

More information

The first tunnel fire. Benefits of fire

The first tunnel fire. Benefits of fire Benefits of fire suppression Quantifying the effects of suppression on energy release. This article by Fathi Tarada, managing director of fire safety, risk management, ventilation and CFD consultant Mosen

More information

Sprinklers Modeling for Tunnel Road Fire Fighting

Sprinklers Modeling for Tunnel Road Fire Fighting Sprinklers Modeling for Tunnel Road Fire Fighting P. Ciambelli, M.G. Meo, P. Russo, S. Vaccaro Department of Chemical and Food Engineering, University of Salerno - ITALY 1. INTRODUCTION Loss of lives and

More information

Specialists in Tunnel Fire Protection

Specialists in Tunnel Fire Protection Specialists in Tunnel Fire Protection 00-M-0003-A Underground transport facilities are sensitive links in the economic chain that carry thousands of people and tons of goods every day and they are increasingly

More information

Fire Protection and Safety in Tunnels Conference Opening Remarks. Dr Fathi Tarada Secretary, PIARC Tunnel Operations Committee

Fire Protection and Safety in Tunnels Conference Opening Remarks. Dr Fathi Tarada Secretary, PIARC Tunnel Operations Committee Fire Protection and Safety in Tunnels Conference Opening Remarks Dr Fathi Tarada Secretary, PIARC Tunnel Operations Committee Agenda Background to the conference Key themes Recent tunnel fires Major infrastructure

More information

2 nd European Forum of Road Tunnel Safety Officers

2 nd European Forum of Road Tunnel Safety Officers 2 nd European Forum of Road Tunnel Safety Officers Brussels, 18 January 2012 How to define a continuous process to improve safety? Bernt Freiholtz How to define a continuous process to improve safety?

More information

Automated Fire Detection and Suppression in a Retrofitted Tunnel Using Fiber-Optic Linear Heat Detection

Automated Fire Detection and Suppression in a Retrofitted Tunnel Using Fiber-Optic Linear Heat Detection Automated Fire Detection and Suppression in a Retrofitted Tunnel Using Fiber-Optic Linear Heat Detection Julio Toko, Martin Fromme, Bernd Horbach and Wieland Hill LIOS Technology GmbH, Cologne, Germany

More information

Approved products and systems for water mist systems and VdS 3188 for planning and installation

Approved products and systems for water mist systems and VdS 3188 for planning and installation Approved products and systems for water mist systems and VdS 3188 for planning and installation Stefan Kratzmeir, VdS Schadenverhütung VdS, 2017 Content Who is VdS? Integrated concept for reliable and

More information

STUDY FOR SAFETY AT A RELATIVELY SHORT TUNNEL WHEN A TUNNEL FIRE OCCURRED

STUDY FOR SAFETY AT A RELATIVELY SHORT TUNNEL WHEN A TUNNEL FIRE OCCURRED - 133 - STUDY FOR SAFETY AT A RELATIVELY SHORT TUNNEL WHEN A TUNNEL FIRE OCCURRED Y. Mikame 1,2, N. Kawabata 1, M. Seike 1, M. Hasegawa 1 1 Kanazawa University, Japan 2 Metropolitan Expressway Company

More information

and Sprinkler System in Resalat Tunnel of Tehran

and Sprinkler System in Resalat Tunnel of Tehran CFD Simulation of Water Mist and Sprinkler System in Resalat Tunnel of Tehran Motivation Resalat tunnel is the first road tunnel in Tehran one of most crowded tunnels of Tehran my every day route, home

More information

CHOOSING A FIRE VENTILATION STRATEGY FOR AN UNDERGROUND METRO STATION

CHOOSING A FIRE VENTILATION STRATEGY FOR AN UNDERGROUND METRO STATION - 165 - CHOOSING A FIRE VENTILATION STRATEGY FOR AN UNDERGROUND METRO STATION Wojciech Węgrzyński, Grzegorz Krajewski, Paweł Sulik Fire Research Department, Building Research Institute (ITB), Poland ABSTRACT

More information

VENTILATION AND SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS IN ROAD TUNNELS: SOME ISSUES REGARDING THEIR APPROPRIATE USE IN A FIRE EMERGENCY

VENTILATION AND SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS IN ROAD TUNNELS: SOME ISSUES REGARDING THEIR APPROPRIATE USE IN A FIRE EMERGENCY VENTILATION AND SUPPRESSION SYSTEMS IN ROAD TUNNELS: SOME ISSUES REGARDING THEIR APPROPRIATE USE IN A FIRE EMERGENCY Ricky Carvel, Guillermo Rein & José L. Torero BRE Centre for Fire Safety Engineering,

More information

EUROPEAN BUREAU. EuroTAP European Tunnel Assessment Programme

EUROPEAN BUREAU. EuroTAP European Tunnel Assessment Programme EUROPEAN BUREAU EuroTAP European Tunnel Assessment Programme Piedicastello Brennero History: 1999: 20 tunnels tested 2000: 25 tunnels tested 2001: 16 tunnels tested 2002: 31 tunnels tested 2003: 25 tunnels

More information

Recent European and national German regulations for. measures

Recent European and national German regulations for. measures Fire safety concepts and risk analysis in rolling stock Recent European and national German regulations for railway vehicles and the acceptance of compensation measures IFAB 4 Different Business Units

More information

designed for rail 5000 Series

designed for rail 5000 Series designed for rail 5000 Series 5000 Series The only complete SIL system 20 years of experience in the field. More than 15.000 systems supplied worldwide. A team devoted to rolling stock projects with specialized

More information

TUNPROTEC. Active Tunnel Fire Protection

TUNPROTEC. Active Tunnel Fire Protection VID FIre KIll TUNPROTEC Active Tunnel Fire Protection 9 An Active Tunnel Fire General The tunnel structures are very valuable. Infrastructure tunnels, such as train tunnels and road tunnels represent very

More information

The European project UpTun improving the level of fire safety in existing tunnels

The European project UpTun improving the level of fire safety in existing tunnels Safety and Security Engineering 519 The European project UpTun improving the level of fire safety in existing tunnels H. Hejny Dr. Horst Hejny Consulting, UpTun Exploitation Manager Abstract The European

More information

Road tunnel safety rules in Italy: the tunnel country

Road tunnel safety rules in Italy: the tunnel country Safety and Security Engineering II 317 Road tunnel safety rules in Italy: the tunnel country M. Guarascio, M. Lombardi, G. Rossi & G. Sciarra Safety Engineering Sapienza, Rome University, Italy Abstract

More information

WATER MIST FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS FOR INDUSTRIAL CABLE TUNNELS AND TURBINE HALLS

WATER MIST FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS FOR INDUSTRIAL CABLE TUNNELS AND TURBINE HALLS WATER MIST FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS FOR INDUSTRIAL CABLE TUNNELS AND TURBINE HALLS Jukka Vaari 1, Amit Lior 2 1 2 VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland, Espoo, Finland Marioff Corporation Oy, Vantaa,

More information

Visit. International Exhibition for Fire & Security

Visit. International Exhibition for Fire & Security Visit IEML Greater Noida Delhi NCR International Exhibition for Fire & Security Secure not just the living. But life itself. www.fsie.in The event that will change the way we look at Fire & Security solutions

More information

The European project UpTun: results of four years of research to improve the level of fire safety in existing tunnels

The European project UpTun: results of four years of research to improve the level of fire safety in existing tunnels Safety and Security Engineering II 191 The European project UpTun: results of four years of research to improve the level of fire safety in existing tunnels H. Hejny Dr. Horst Hejny Consulting, Germany

More information

Hot Issues in Fire Engineering 12 March 2013

Hot Issues in Fire Engineering 12 March 2013 Hot Issues in Fire Engineering 12 March 2013 An Update on Design Fires of Vehicular Tunnels W.K. Chow Fellow, Hong Kong Academy of Engineering Sciences Research Centre for Fire Engineering, Department

More information

Quantitative risk assessment for a fire suppression system in the New Tyne Crossing. Dr Fathi Tarada

Quantitative risk assessment for a fire suppression system in the New Tyne Crossing. Dr Fathi Tarada Quantitative risk assessment for a fire suppression system in the New Tyne Crossing Dr Fathi Tarada Contents The brief Feasibility study Risk assessment Cost-benefit analysis Primary assumptions Risk parameters

More information

BUILDING INDUSTRY TUNNEL RAIL TUNNEL FIRE FIGHTING WITH HIGH PRESSURE WATER MIST

BUILDING INDUSTRY TUNNEL RAIL TUNNEL FIRE FIGHTING WITH HIGH PRESSURE WATER MIST BUILDING INDUSTRY TUNNEL RAIL TUNNEL FIRE FIGHTING WITH HIGH PRESSURE WATER MIST FIRE FIGHTING IS RESPONSIBILITY Fire monitoring Fire detection Fire suppression We are a leading international supplier

More information

THE IMPACT OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS ON TUNNEL SAFETY THE BURNLEY INCIDENT IN A CURRENT THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVE

THE IMPACT OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS ON TUNNEL SAFETY THE BURNLEY INCIDENT IN A CURRENT THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVE THE IMPACT OF FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS ON TUNNEL SAFETY THE BURNLEY INCIDENT IN A CURRENT THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVE ABSTRACT Arnold Dix Scientist and Lawyer Associate Professor, University of Western

More information

Proven Fire Fighting Efficiency for Large Transformers with High Pressure Water Mist

Proven Fire Fighting Efficiency for Large Transformers with High Pressure Water Mist Proven Fire Fighting Efficiency for Large Transformers with High Pressure Water Mist Dipl.-Ing. Rüdiger Kopp FOGTEC Fire Protection ruediger.kopp@fogtec.com 1 Water Mist for Transformer Fire Protection

More information

SAFE CABLING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS UNDER FIRE

SAFE CABLING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS UNDER FIRE - 249 - SAFE CABLING SYSTEMS IN TUNNELS UNDER FIRE Urs Welte Amstein + Walthert AG, Switzerland ABSTRACT The paper aims at a detailed analysis of the current know-how in the construction of tunnel cabling

More information

Recent BRANZFIRE enhancements and validation

Recent BRANZFIRE enhancements and validation Recent BRANZFIRE enhancements and validation Michael Spearpoint University of Canterbury Summary BRANZFIRE is a multi-compartment fire zone model that has been under development since 1996 predominately

More information

How to Use Fire Risk Assessment Tools to Evaluate Performance Based Designs

How to Use Fire Risk Assessment Tools to Evaluate Performance Based Designs How to Use Fire Risk Assessment Tools to Evaluate Performance Based Designs 1 ABSTRACT Noureddine Benichou and Ahmed H. Kashef * Institute for Research in Construction National Research Council of Canada

More information

Tokyo-wan Aqualine - Experience of Traffic and Safety

Tokyo-wan Aqualine - Experience of Traffic and Safety Hisashi Iwata, Chief Engineer, Maintenance and Traffic Operation Department, Japan Highway Public Corporation, Japan Yoshikazu Ota, Chiyoda Engineering Consultants Co., Ltd., Japan 1. General planning

More information

PHASED CONSTRUCTION AND SAFETY IN MALA KAPELA TUNNEL

PHASED CONSTRUCTION AND SAFETY IN MALA KAPELA TUNNEL - 119 - ABSTRACT: PHASED CONSTRUCTION AND SAFETY IN MALA KAPELA TUNNEL Darko Šaric Civil Engineering Institute of Croatia Croatia, 10.000 Zagreb, J. Rakuše 1 e-mail: dsaric@zg.igh.hr Goran Legac Croatian

More information

Measurement of Safety Integrity of E/E/PES according to IEC61508

Measurement of Safety Integrity of E/E/PES according to IEC61508 Measurement of Safety Integrity of E/E/PES according to IEC61508 Mr. Chen Zhenkang TUV Rheinland Singapore 18. May. 2018 Singapore World Metrology Day 2018 1 Agenda 1. TÜV Rheinland: a Certification Body

More information

CFD STUDY OF FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS IN TUNNEL FIRES

CFD STUDY OF FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEMS IN TUNNEL FIRES UDC 614.84 : 628.854 : 52-17 DOI: 10.7562/SE2011.1.01.03 Original article www.safety.ni.ac.rs DARKO ZIGAR 1 DESIMIR JOVANOVIĆ 2 MARTINA ZDRAVKOVIĆ 3 1-4 University of Niš, Faculty of Occupational Safety

More information

Effectiveness of sprinklers in residential premises:

Effectiveness of sprinklers in residential premises: Effectiveness of sprinklers in residential premises: Section 7: Other considerations and Recommendations for further work Project report number 204505 Dr Corinne Williams and Dr Jeremy Fraser-Mitchell

More information

9 Standards, Regulations and Authorities

9 Standards, Regulations and Authorities 9 9.1 Summary...283 9.2 Basics...284 9.3 Standards and how to Secure Adherence to Standards...285 9.3.1 Types of Standards...285 9.3.2 Hierarchy of Standards...285 9.3.3 Proof...286 9.3.4 Overview of the

More information

PERFORMANCE OF A MODEL IN-LINE VORTEX SEPARATOR. Keng-Choon Lee Geothermal Institute, The University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, Auckland, New

PERFORMANCE OF A MODEL IN-LINE VORTEX SEPARATOR. Keng-Choon Lee Geothermal Institute, The University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, Auckland, New PERFORMANCE OF A MODEL IN-LINE VORTEX SEPARATOR Keng-Choon Lee Geothermal Institute, The University of Auckland, Private Bag 92019, Auckland, New Key words: Separator, condensate removal, two-phase flow

More information

Fire Protection for Printing Machines with High Pressure Water Mist

Fire Protection for Printing Machines with High Pressure Water Mist Fire Protection for Printing Machines with High Pressure Water Mist Dipl.-Ing. Rüdiger Kopp FOGTEC Fire Protection ruediger.kopp@fogtec.com 1 Case Study PRINOVIS Printing Company - PRINOVIS is Europe s

More information

CHANCES AND LIMITS OF THE TIME-EQUIVALENCE-METHOD IN STRUCTURAL FIRE DESIGN

CHANCES AND LIMITS OF THE TIME-EQUIVALENCE-METHOD IN STRUCTURAL FIRE DESIGN CHANCES AND LIMITS OF THE TIME-EQUIVALENCE-METHOD IN STRUCTURAL FIRE DESIGN ABSTRACT P. Schaumann and S. Hothan University of Hannover, Institute for Steel Construction Appelstraße 9a, D-3167 Hannover,

More information

TECHNICAL TRADE-OFFS USING FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS

TECHNICAL TRADE-OFFS USING FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS - 12 - TECHNICAL TRADE-OFFS USING FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS H. Ingason and Y.Z. Li, SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden ABSTRACT The increasing use of fixed fire-fighting system (FFFS) in tunnels

More information

COST-EFFECTIVE FIRE-SAFETY RETROFITS FOR CANADIAN GOVERNMENT OFFICE BUILDINGS

COST-EFFECTIVE FIRE-SAFETY RETROFITS FOR CANADIAN GOVERNMENT OFFICE BUILDINGS , Volume 1, Number 3, p.123-128, 1999 COST-EFFECTIVE FIRE-SAFETY RETROFITS FOR CANADIAN GOVERNMENT OFFICE BUILDINGS D. Yung and G.V. Hadjisophocleous Fire Risk Management Program, Institute for Research

More information

Fire protection documentation. CFPA-E Guideline No 13:2015 F

Fire protection documentation. CFPA-E Guideline No 13:2015 F Fire protection documentation CFPA-E Guideline No 13:2015 F FOREWORD The European fire protection associations have decided to produce common guidelines in order to achieve similar interpretation in the

More information

Fire Safety Concept Hotel Jumeirah

Fire Safety Concept Hotel Jumeirah Fire Safety Concept Hotel Jumeirah Dr.-Ing. Christoph Klinzmann hhpberlin Ingenieure für Brandschutz Department performance-based methods Office Hamburg Part 1 Fire safety concept Palais Quartier and Jumeirah

More information

to make people listen worldwide EN54 Voice Alarm & Network Speaker Made in Germany

to make people listen worldwide EN54 Voice Alarm & Network Speaker Made in Germany to make people listen worldwide EN54 Voice Alarm & Network Speaker Made in Germany 10 reasons to choose ic audio 01 German manufacturer and worldwide supplier of 100V audio products with headquarters in

More information

DECOMMISSIONING OF THE REACTOR VESSEL OF THE COMPACT SODIUM COOLED NUCLEAR REACTOR FACILITY (KNK)

DECOMMISSIONING OF THE REACTOR VESSEL OF THE COMPACT SODIUM COOLED NUCLEAR REACTOR FACILITY (KNK) DECOMMISSIONING OF THE REACTOR VESSEL OF THE COMPACT SODIUM COOLED NUCLEAR REACTOR FACILITY (KNK) J. Benkert, F. Willman Westinghouse Electric Germany GmbH Mannheim / D K. Brockmann, I. Hillebrand Research

More information

Interaction of Water Extinguishing Systems and Smoke and Heat Exhaust Ventilation Systems (SHEVS)

Interaction of Water Extinguishing Systems and Smoke and Heat Exhaust Ventilation Systems (SHEVS) Fire Protection Leaflet Interaction of Water Extinguishing Systems and Smoke and Heat Exhaust Ventilation Systems (SHEVS) 0 General Regulations and recommendations missing from this leaflet do not entitle

More information

Specialists in Tunnel Fire Protection

Specialists in Tunnel Fire Protection Specialists in Tunnel Fire Protection Specialists in Tunnel Fire Detection 3 Underground transport facilities are sensitive links in the economic chain that carry thousands of people and tons of goods

More information

The Mont Blanc tunnel project. Eric CESMAT, Sylvain DESANGHERE

The Mont Blanc tunnel project. Eric CESMAT, Sylvain DESANGHERE The Mont Blanc tunnel project Eric CESMAT, Sylvain DESANGHERE 24/09/2009 International water mist conference 2009 Fires in tunnel Car fire > 4 to 8 MW Van fire > 15 MW HGV fire > 30 MW Big HGV fire > 100

More information

NON-FLAMMABLE WALL COVERING SYSTEM FOR INNOVATIVE FIRE PROTECTION

NON-FLAMMABLE WALL COVERING SYSTEM FOR INNOVATIVE FIRE PROTECTION SYSTEX X ACTIVE FIREPROTECT NON-FLAMMABLE WALL COVERING SYSTEM FOR INNOVATIVE FIRE PROTECTION THE INNOVATIVE GLASS FABRIC FOR WALLS AND CEILINGS 2 SPREADS LIKE WILDFIRE EVERY SECOND COUNTS Of course, we

More information

Procedure for the Approval of New Fire Detection and Alarm Technologies

Procedure for the Approval of New Fire Detection and Alarm Technologies VdS Guidelines for Automatic Fire Detection and Fire Alarm Systems VdS 3469en Procedure for the Approval of New Fire Detection and Alarm Technologies VdS 3469en : 2016-01 (01) Publisher and publishing

More information

RETOS Y TENDENCIAS DESARROLLO DE INFRAESTRUCTURA EN AUSTRIA. Leonardo Rosas Sánchez Bogotá Agosto 9 de 2018

RETOS Y TENDENCIAS DESARROLLO DE INFRAESTRUCTURA EN AUSTRIA. Leonardo Rosas Sánchez Bogotá Agosto 9 de 2018 RETOS Y TENDENCIAS DESARROLLO DE INFRAESTRUCTURA EN AUSTRIA Leonardo Rosas Sánchez Bogotá Agosto 9 de 2018 Table of content 1. Safety standards for road and railway tunnels 2. Upgrading the Alrberg Tunnel

More information

High challenge warehouse case study Summary

High challenge warehouse case study Summary High challenge warehouse case study Summary February 19, 2010 Richard Gallagher Michael Gollner Zurich Services Corporation Objectives Review the results of the high challenge warehouse workshop Recognize

More information

Guideline No 11:2005. European guideline. Recommended Numbers of Fire Protection Trained Staff

Guideline No 11:2005. European guideline. Recommended Numbers of Fire Protection Trained Staff European guideline Recommended Numbers of Fire Protection Trained Staff EFSAC Endorsed CFPA-E -Guidelines Foreword The European fire protection associations have decided to produce common guidelines in

More information

Tunnel Fire Dynamics

Tunnel Fire Dynamics Tunnel Fire Dynamics Haukur Ingason Ying Zhen Li Anders Lönnermark Tunnel Fire Dynamics 1 3 Haukur Ingason Fire Research SP Technical Research Institute of Sweden Borås Sweden Anders Lönnermark Fire Research

More information

Active or Passive? FIRE SAFETY

Active or Passive? FIRE SAFETY FIRE SAFETY Active or Passive? Could the combination of passive and active fire protection measures lead to better value solutions for road tunnels? Kristina Smith reports. Top right: PassiveTec fire protection

More information

Fixed fire protection solutions

Fixed fire protection solutions Risk Engineering Fixed fire protection solutions At a glance Fixed fire protection can reduce the severity of fire events and positively impact Risk Engineering Assessments. To provide an effective solution

More information

INNOVATION GATEWAY. Challenge Selection Round 2, Innovator Briefs Building heating systems

INNOVATION GATEWAY. Challenge Selection Round 2, Innovator Briefs Building heating systems INNOVATION GATEWAY Challenge Selection Round 2, 2018 Innovator Briefs Building heating systems Commercial in confidence do not distribute outside your organisation 1 Contents INNOVATION CATEGORY... 3 BUILDING

More information

ITALIAN STANDARD UNI 11565

ITALIAN STANDARD UNI 11565 ITALIAN STANDARD UNI 11565 Consequences on Designing, Testing and Maintaining of Fire Protection Systems in Italy Dr. Markus Mueller WAGNER Bayern GmbH railsystems@wagner.de Agenda 1. Introduction About

More information

Fire and smoke management in a uni-directional road tunnel for a congested traffic condition

Fire and smoke management in a uni-directional road tunnel for a congested traffic condition Fire and smoke management in a uni-directional road tunnel for a congested traffic condition Y Liu, J Munro Parsons Brinckerhoff Australia B Dandie Thiess Pty Ltd., Australia ABSTRACT Emergency smoke ventilation

More information

Tunnels, Risks & Design Mitigation

Tunnels, Risks & Design Mitigation Safe roads, Reliable journeys, Informed travellers Tunnels, Risks & Design Mitigation Eamonn Colgan HA Senior Project Manager & John Celentano Mouchel Ltd, Tunnel Technical Director Introduction Eamonn

More information

SMOKE MANAGEMENT AND EGRESS ANALYSIS OF A SPORTS ARENA USING THE PERFORMANCE-BASED DESIGN

SMOKE MANAGEMENT AND EGRESS ANALYSIS OF A SPORTS ARENA USING THE PERFORMANCE-BASED DESIGN , Volume 4, Number 2, p.73-83, 2003 SMOKE MANAGEMENT AND EGRESS ANALYSIS OF A SPORTS ARENA USING THE PERFORMANCE-BASED DESIGN K.H. Yang and C.S. Yang Mechanical Engineering Department, National Sun Yat-Sen

More information

The Use of Public Address System to Improve Tunnel Safety - Current Practices. Lim Hock Tay

The Use of Public Address System to Improve Tunnel Safety - Current Practices. Lim Hock Tay The Use of Public Address System to Improve Tunnel Safety - Current Practices Lim Hock Tay Content 1 Introduction 2 3 Overview of Survey Responses Discussion 4 Conclusion PIARC International Conference

More information

Full-scale Experiment of Longitudinal Ventilation Smoke Control System and Central Smoke Exhaust System in City Underwater Tunnel

Full-scale Experiment of Longitudinal Ventilation Smoke Control System and Central Smoke Exhaust System in City Underwater Tunnel Available online at www.sciencedirect.com Procedia Engineering 52 ( 2013 ) 330 335 Full-scale Experiment of Longitudinal Ventilation Smoke Control System and Central Smoke Exhaust System in City Underwater

More information

A Study into the Standardization of Using Fire Detectors in Rail Vehicles for China

A Study into the Standardization of Using Fire Detectors in Rail Vehicles for China Available online at www.sciencedirect.com Procedia Engineering 52 ( 2013 ) 240 244 A Study into the Standardization of Using Fire Detectors in Rail Vehicles for China LIU Xiao-lu *, WANG Wen-qing Shenyang

More information

OFDR-Temperature Sensing using Existing Fiber-Optic Communication Cables An Application for Automatic Fire Detection?

OFDR-Temperature Sensing using Existing Fiber-Optic Communication Cables An Application for Automatic Fire Detection? OFDR-Temperature Sensing using Existing Fiber-Optic Communication Cables An Application for Automatic Fire Detection? Markus Brüne, Annika Gomell, Andreas Pflitsch Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Bochum, Germany

More information

International Seminar on Long Tunnels - October 17-19, 2012 CHILE Santiago World Road Association (PIARC )

International Seminar on Long Tunnels - October 17-19, 2012 CHILE Santiago World Road Association (PIARC ) TUNNEL MANAGEMENT IN QUEBEC (CANADA) Maintenance, Operation and Safety Management of urban Road Tunnels in Canada INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR ON LONG TUNNELS Chile, Santiago (October 17-19, 2012) Alexandre Debs,

More information

RESEARCH ON THE MAIN CRITERIA OF DECISION-MAKING FACTORS THAT AFFECT CONSUMERS' PURCHASE OF RESIDENTIAL FIRE ALARMS

RESEARCH ON THE MAIN CRITERIA OF DECISION-MAKING FACTORS THAT AFFECT CONSUMERS' PURCHASE OF RESIDENTIAL FIRE ALARMS www.arpapress.com/volumes/vol35issue1/ijrras_35_1_03.pdf RESEARCH ON THE MAIN CRITERIA OF DECISION-MAKING FACTORS THAT AFFECT CONSUMERS' PURCHASE OF RESIDENTIAL FIRE ALARMS Chih-Yao Lo 1,Hung-Teng Chang

More information

Fire protection of emergency electrical devices: effect on the level of risk a case study of a rail tunnel

Fire protection of emergency electrical devices: effect on the level of risk a case study of a rail tunnel Safety and Security Engineering VI 73 Fire protection of emergency electrical devices: effect on the level of risk a case study of a rail tunnel M. Lombardi & G. Rossi Dipartimento di Ingegneria Chimica

More information

Gerd Koffmane, Henrik Hoff, AP Sensing GmbH, Böblingen

Gerd Koffmane, Henrik Hoff, AP Sensing GmbH, Böblingen Linear Heat Series Under Test: Extensive fire tests prove Distributed Temperature Sensing (DTS) enables fast and reliable control of fire protection systems in road and rail tunnels Gerd Koffmane, Henrik

More information

Preface by Dr. Andrea Koch-Kraft

Preface by Dr. Andrea Koch-Kraft Preface by Dr. Andrea Koch-Kraft More than a decade ago, the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research set up the research priority Future Megacities Research for the sustainable development of

More information

2015 Functional Safety Training & Workshops

2015 Functional Safety Training & Workshops HAZAN RISK SIS SIF - IEC 61508/61511 - SIL PFD SFF CCF 2015 Functional Safety Training & Workshops Select the right course for your organisation from our extensive choice of Functional Safety related training

More information

Heat pump supplemental heating system for motor vehicles

Heat pump supplemental heating system for motor vehicles 1 Heat pump supplemental heating system for motor vehicles D Antonijevic and R Heckt Visteon Automotive Systems, Visteon Deutschland GmbH, Kerpen, Germany Abstract: The paper deals with the importance

More information

TUNNEL TEST DARTFORD TUNNEL. Foreword. September 2004

TUNNEL TEST DARTFORD TUNNEL. Foreword. September 2004 September 2004 TUNNEL TEST 2004 - DARTFORD TUNNEL Foreword Despite improvements since the Dartford Tunnel was last inspected in 2002, in the league table of 28 tunnels inspected this year, Dartford was

More information

Ethanol Tank Fire Fighting

Ethanol Tank Fire Fighting Ethanol Tank Fire Fighting Goal of ETANKFIRE project Ensure proper investments in fire protection of ethanol storage plants Determine the large scale fire behaviour of ethanol fuels Provide input to computer

More information

The Swedish National Board of Housing, Building and Planning s general recommendations on the analytical design of a building s fire protection, BBRAD

The Swedish National Board of Housing, Building and Planning s general recommendations on the analytical design of a building s fire protection, BBRAD The Swedish National Board of Housing, Building and Planning s general recommendations on the analytical design of a building s fire protection, BBRAD BFS 2011:27 with amendments up to BFS 2013:12 The

More information

Managing technical risks

Managing technical risks Aon Global Risk Consulting Managing technical risks Choosing the right protection for your investments. Our offer at a glance Introduction...3 Fire Protection...5 Fire protection advice and planning Design

More information

The Possibilities of Applying Mobile Ventilators In the Process of Indoor Fire-fighting

The Possibilities of Applying Mobile Ventilators In the Process of Indoor Fire-fighting ZRÍNYI MIKLÓS NATIONAL DEFENCE UNIVERSITY Council of Doctors GÉZA ZÓLYOMI fireman lieutenant colonel The Possibilities of Applying Mobile Ventilators In the Process of Indoor Fire-fighting Short author

More information

Effects of Smoke on Evacuation Martin Lopušniak 1, a

Effects of Smoke on Evacuation Martin Lopušniak 1, a Advanced Materials Research Online: 2014-02-27 ISSN: 1662-8985, Vol. 899, pp 539-542 doi:10.4028/www.scientific.net/amr.899.539 2014 Trans Tech Publications, Switzerland Effects of Smoke on Evacuation

More information

SCHULTE & ASSOCIATES Building Code Consultants 880D Forest Avenue Evanston, IL /

SCHULTE & ASSOCIATES Building Code Consultants 880D Forest Avenue Evanston, IL / SCHULTE & ASSOCIATES Building Code Consultants 880D Forest Avenue Evanston, IL 60202 fpeschulte@aol.com 504/220-7475 A CRITIQUE OF HUGHES ASSOCIATES, INC. PAPER TITLED: Analysis of the Performance of Ganged

More information

FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN ROAD TUNNELS: CURRENT PRACTICES AND RECOMMENDATIONS

FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN ROAD TUNNELS: CURRENT PRACTICES AND RECOMMENDATIONS www.piarc.org 2016R03EN FIXED FIRE FIGHTING SYSTEMS IN ROAD TUNNELS: CURRENT PRACTICES AND RECOMMENDATIONS Technical Committee C.3.3 Road Tunnel Operations of the World Road Association STATEMENTS The

More information

Survey of the Burning Behaviour of the Refrigerant HFO-1234yf Brief Report

Survey of the Burning Behaviour of the Refrigerant HFO-1234yf Brief Report D M T G m b H & C o. K G B u i l d i n g S a f e t y Expert Body for Fire Protection Tremoniastraße 13 44137 Dortmund GERMANY Phone +49 231-5333-0 Fax +49 231-5333-299 Emaill: gs@dmt.de http://www.dmt.de

More information

SCALE MODEL STUDIES ON SMOKE MOVEMENT IN INCLINED TUNNEL WITH LONGITUDINAL VENTILATION AND SMOKE BARRIERS

SCALE MODEL STUDIES ON SMOKE MOVEMENT IN INCLINED TUNNEL WITH LONGITUDINAL VENTILATION AND SMOKE BARRIERS , Volume 11, Number 2, p.21-26, 212 SCALE MODEL STUDIES ON SMOKE MOVEMENT IN INCLINED TUNNEL WITH LONGITUDINAL VENTILATION AND SMOKE BARRIERS C.Y. Tso and W.K. Chow Research Centre for Fire Engineering,

More information

ASSESSING FIRE SAFETY PROVISIONS FOR SATISFYING GREEN OR SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN CRITERIA: PRELIMINARY SUGGESTIONS

ASSESSING FIRE SAFETY PROVISIONS FOR SATISFYING GREEN OR SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN CRITERIA: PRELIMINARY SUGGESTIONS , Volume 4, Number 3, p.141-146, 2003 ASSESSING FIRE SAFETY PROVISIONS FOR SATISFYING GREEN OR SUSTAINABLE BUILDING DESIGN CRITERIA: PRELIMINARY SUGGESTIONS C.L. Chow and W.K. Chow Department of Building

More information

FOGTEC Rail Systems. Rolling Stock Applications. Fire Protection Solutions from one source. Leading in Fire Protection. designed for rail 1

FOGTEC Rail Systems. Rolling Stock Applications. Fire Protection Solutions from one source. Leading in Fire Protection. designed for rail 1 Fire Protection Solutions from one source FOGTEC Rail Systems Rolling Stock Applications designed for rail 1 Trends and Developments in Fire Experts in Water Mist Protection for Rolling stock a global

More information