10 Historic Heritage. Introduction

Transcription

1 10 This Chapter primarily implements Objective 2.7 (set out in Chapter 2). Objective 2.1 Tāngata Whenua is also relevant to resource management issues for. Introduction Historic heritage comprises the natural and physical resources that contribute to an understanding and appreciation of New Zealand s history and cultures, deriving from archaeological, architectural, cultural, historic, scientific and technological qualities. The has a rich historic heritage and includes places and areas which are significant in the settlement, development and growth of Kapiti. Historic heritage is important to the way the s communities are shaped economically, aesthetically and culturally. As a finite resource, historic heritage contributes to the well-being of the community by providing opportunities for cultural awareness, local character and identify, a sense of place and economic development. Furthermore, historic heritage contributes to the character and landscape (in particular cultural landscape) values of the s places. Reference should therefore also be made to the landscape section of the Natural Environment Chapter. The values of tāngata whenua are particularly important to defining the historic heritage of the. Māori cultural heritage - as represented in the places and spaces that are of significance to whānau, hapū and iwi - cannot be separated from Māori environmental values generally. The people and the environment are not mutually exclusive groups in indigenous knowledge systems. In this sense, values such as rangatiratanga, kaitiakitanga, tikanga Māori, mauri, tapu and noa are inextricably connected to historic heritage. Waahi tapu has important historic heritage and living cultural value to tāngata whenua. Waahi tapu sit within a larger cultural landscape and convey important understandings of the environment and Māori cultural identity: whether they are areas instilled with tapu, tell a story of settlement or migration, or are acknowledged as places of tribal success or defeat. The identification of these heritage values rests with iwi, hapū, whānau and marae in accordance with their kaitiaki responsibilities. The RMA identifies the protection of historic heritage from inappropriate subdivision, use and development as a matter of national importance under section 6(f). In addition, section 6(e) identifies the relationship of Māori and their culture and traditions with their ancestral lands, water, sites, waahi tapu, and other taonga. These requirements facilitate the achievement of the overall purpose of the RMA to promote sustainable management of natural and physical resources. The New Zealand Coastal Policy Statement (NZCPS) recognises that historic heritage in the coastal environment is extensive but not fully known, and is vulnerable to loss or damage from inappropriate subdivision, use, and development. The NZCPS provides a strong direction on managing the coastal environment in a way that protects historic heritage. The Wellington Regional Policy Statement (RPS) objectives and policies build on the RMA and NZCPS requirements and place emphasis on identifying and protecting historic heritage. Appeals Version March [10-1] -

2 Policies Policy 10.1 Identify Historic heritage that contributes to an understanding and appreciation of the 's history and culture will be identified in the Schedule of Historic Heritage and on the Plan Maps. The Schedule will include the following categories: a) places, including buildings, structures, sites; b) areas; c) notable trees; and d) waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Māori. Policy 10.2 Criteria for Identifying The following criteria will be used to identify significant historic heritage to be listed in the Schedule of. For inclusion in the schedule at least one of the following must be significant: a) the values relating to the history of a feature and how it demonstrates: i. important themes in history or patterns of development; ii. important event or events in local, regional or national history; iii. the life or works of an individual, group or organisation that has made a significant contribution to the, region or nation; or iv. everyday experiences from the past that contribute to our understanding of the culture and life of the, region or nation. b) the values relating to the physical evidence of a feature including the: i. potential for archaeological investigation to contribute new or important information about the human history of the, region or nation; ii. style, design, form, scale, materials, ornamentation, period, craftsmanship or other architectural values; iii. evidence of the history of technological development, innovation or important methods of construction or design; iv. extent of modification; v. age of the feature; or vi. association with other natural or cultural features in the landscape or townscape, and/or contribution to the heritage values of a wider townscape or landscape setting, and/or whether or not it is a landmark. c) the values relating to the meanings that a feature has for a particular community or communities, including: i. strong or special associations with a particular cultural group or community for spiritual, political, social, religious, cultural, national, symbolic or commemorative reasons; or ii. high public esteem for its historic heritage values, or its contribution to the sense of identity of a community, to the extent Appeals Version March [10-2] -

3 that if it was damaged or destroyed it would cause a sense of loss. d) the spiritual, cultural or historical values associated with places, knowledge, histories and ngā taonga tuku iho sacred or important to tāngata whenua (Māori); e) the contribution of the surroundings, setting or context of the place to an appreciation and understanding of its character, history and development; f) the extent to which the feature is unique or rare within the or region; g) the extent to which the feature is a good representative example of its type or era; and h) the potential for public education. In relation to d), ngā taonga tuku iho is an embracing concept and can be described as treasures that whānau, hapū and iwi have inherited from tūpuna (ancestors) and covers the interconnected realms of te taha taiao (the natural and physical environment), te taha tinana (the human world), te taha wairua (the spiritual world) and te taha hinengaro (the intellectual world). Policy 10.3 Additional Listings for the Schedule of The following historic heritage within the shall be listed in the Schedule of : a) items listed as Category 1 on the New Zealand Heritage List Rārangi Kōrero; b) places subject to a Heritage Order under the RMA; c) historic heritage protected by a consent notice issued under section 221 of the RMA; and d) historic heritage items specifically identified in the Regional Policy Statement or Regional Plans. In addition to the criteria set out in Policy 10.2, when listing items in the Schedule of, regard shall be given to items listed as Category 2 on the New Zealand Heritage List Rārangi Kōrero. Policy 10.4 Protection of Subdivision, development and land use affecting the s historic heritage will be managed in a way that protects historic heritage values from adverse effects. Policy 10.5 Use, Repair and Maintenance of Repair and maintenance of scheduled historic heritage is appropriate to maintain the continuity of use, or provide for new uses where the repair or maintenance: a) is necessary to ensure liveability and utility is retained; b) retains historic heritage values; and Appeals Version March [10-3] -

4 c) will secure the long term viability and retention of the place. Policy 10.6 Additions, Alterations, Relocation, Demolition, Partial Demolition and Destruction of Features A. Demolition, partial demolition, or destruction will be avoided for historic heritage, excluding notable trees, which meets both of the following: a) it is a Category 1 or 2 item on the New Zealand Heritage List Rārangi Kōrero; and b) it is a scheduled historic building or structure, scheduled historic site, scheduled historic area, or waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori. B. Relocation will be avoided for historic heritage which meets both of the following: a) it is a Category 1 item on the New Zealand Heritage List Rārangi Kōrero; and b) it is a scheduled historic building or structure, scheduled historic site, scheduled historic area, or waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori. C. The appropriateness of relocation, demolition, partial demolition, or destruction of any scheduled historic building or structure, scheduled historic site, or scheduled historic area, which is not covered by (A) and (B) above, will be considered using the assessment criteria in this policy. D. Alterations and additions to scheduled historic buildings are appropriate to maintain the continuity of use, or provide for new uses where the alteration or additions: a) are necessary to ensure liveability and utility is retained; b) retain historic heritage values; and c) will secure the long term viability and retention of the place. E. In any assessment of resource consent applications relating to the activities in A, B, C and D above, the following matters will be considered: a) the degree to which historic heritage values will be irreversibly lost, damaged, destroyed or enhanced and whether the relationships between distinct elements of the historic heritage and its surroundings (if relevant) will be maintained; b) the opportunities to remedy or mitigate any proposed or previous damage to historic heritage values; c) the importance attributed to the historic heritage feature by the wider community; d) whether the activity will lead to cumulative adverse effects on historic heritage; e) the degree to which public interpretation of historic heritage is enhanced by the proposed activities, in accordance with relevant cultural protocols and without effects on the tangible or intangible historic heritage values; f) the immediate risk to public safety or any other historic heritage if activity/works are not undertaken, such as the risk to life in the case of earthquake; Appeals Version March [10-4] -

5 g) registration and the reasons for registration on the New Zealand Heritage List Rārangi Kōrero (if applicable); h) policies of any conservation plan and heritage inventory relating to the historic heritage; i) whether the item is a danger to public safety and repair is not the best practicable option. In determining that repair is not the best practicable option, regard will be given to: i. the economics of a range of reasonably practicable options; and ii. ensuring that every reasonable alternative has been considered to minimise the effect on historic heritage values. F. Consideration will also be given to: a) recommendations made by Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga and any suitably qualified expert in heritage identification and management; b) for waahi tapu sites or sites of significance to Maori, the outcome of consultation with the relevant iwi authority; and c) the conservation principles set out in the International Council on Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS) New Zealand Charter Policy 10.7 Subdivision Involving Historic heritage will be protected from inappropriate subdivision. Where any subdivision is proposed on sites containing historic heritage features, specific consideration will be given to the following matters: a) whether the subdivision will create a lot pattern that maintains or reinforces the integrity of the historic heritage and the character of the surrounding area; b) whether the subdivision will create lot or lots of a size and dimension that can accommodate new development that will complement the historic heritage site; c) whether new buildings can be sited and set back so that they do not overshadow, dominate, encroach on or otherwise impact on the setting of the historic heritage; d) whether the subdivision would positively contribute to, or detract from, historic heritage values; e) whether the subdivision will have an adverse effect on the ongoing and coherent management and maintenance of the historic heritage and its surroundings; and f) whether a consent notice or other legal mechanism is required to protect the historic heritage values. Policy 10.8 Waahi Tapu Waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Māori and their surroundings will be protected from inappropriate subdivision, development, land disturbance or change in land use, which may affect the physical features and non-physical values of the place or area. The Council will work in partnership with the relevant iwi authority for the Appeals Version March [10-5] -

6 ongoing and long term management and protection of waahi tapu. Relevant iwi authorities will be consulted on all resource consent applications affecting waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori identified in the Schedule of. Policy 10.9 Unidentified A precautionary approach will be taken to protecting unidentified historic heritage. Where no archaeological authority is in place and previously unidentified historic heritage is discovered, then work will be immediately stopped until the significance is assessed and adverse effects can be appropriately avoided or mitigated. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, as set out in Schedule 10.2, will be followed in all development. The Council will maintain publicly available information to highlight areas where there is a higher risk of unidentified historic heritage being encountered. Policy Identification of Notable Trees In addition to the criteria set out in Policy 10.2, trees will be considered for inclusion as a notable tree in the Schedule of if they: a) achieve a Standard Tree Evaluation Method (STEM) score of 140 or greater (see Schedule 10.3); or b) are listed on the New Zealand Notable Trees Trust s New Zealand Tree Register. Policy Notable Trees Assessment Criteria A. The following criteria will be considered when assessing the effects of trimming, modification or removal of notable trees: a) the necessity for carrying out the works; b) whether the tree is dead, or has a serious contagious disease or damage which has caused a decline in its health; c) whether the tree has become a danger to the public or interferes with public utilities or drainage systems, watercourses or streams; d) compliance with any statutory or legal obligation; e) whether the tree can be successfully relocated (and is likely to survive) within the surroundings; f) whether the proposal can be altered to preserve the tree while still meeting the stated aims of the applicant; and g) whether the proposed activity is likely to damage the tree or endanger its health. B. Consideration will also be given to: a) the outcome of consultation with the relevant iwi authority and affected parties; b) the outcome of consultation with the Department of Conservation, QEII National Trust, and the New Zealand Notable Trees Trust where Appeals Version March [10-6] -

7 appropriate; c) any evidence of a recognised and qualified arborist where appropriate; and d) any evidence and recommendations made by Heritage New Zealand and any other professionally recognised party in heritage conservation issues. Policy Voluntary and Non-regulatory Methods The protection of historic heritage will be facilitated and encouraged by the use of voluntary and non-regulatory methods to support regulatory methods. Appeals Version March [10-7] -

8 Rules and Standards The following rules and standards apply -wide. These rules and standards should be read in conjunction with the Plan Maps and the Schedule of (Schedule 10.1) to determine if an application involves historic heritage. Introduction: Applicability of Rules in Tables 10A.1 10A.5 The rules in Tables 10A.1 to 10A.5 shall apply to all land use and activities in all Zones unless otherwise specified. There are other rules within the Plan that may also apply to sites and activities. Section 1.1 in Chapter 1 sets out how to use the Plan and identify other rules that may also apply to a site or activity. Notes: Works in close proximity to any electricity line can be dangerous and should be undertaken in accordance with appropriate guidelines. To discuss any tree trimming works near any electricity line, especially works within the National Grid Corridor; contact the relevant network utility operator. Comment [SH1]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd seeks to add an exemption from the rules as they apply to the Ngarara Zone and WTS0318 Taewapirau and WTS0318A Taewapirau waahi tupuna Table 10A.1 Permitted Activities The following activities are permitted activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding permitted activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and permitted activity standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Permitted Activities 1. Any activity on a property with a historic heritage feature not specified as a controlled, restricted discretionary, discretionary or non-complying activity in the rules in Tables 10A.1-10A Repair and maintenance of a scheduled historic building or structure. Standards 1. The activity complies with all permitted activity standards in Table 10A.1 Permitted Activities Note: see Rule 9A.1.2 for separation of buildings and structures from water body standards, and Tables 11B.1-11B.5 in relation to water and stormwater rules for all development. 1. The work must not involve alterations, additions, relocation, partial demolition or demolition. 2. Any redecoration work must be limited to the renewal, restoration or new application of surface finishes, decorative elements, minor fittings and fixtures and floor coverings which does not destroy, compromise, damage or impair the historic heritage. Appeals Version March [10-8] -

9 Table 10A.1 Permitted Activities The following activities are permitted activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding permitted activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and permitted activity standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Permitted Activities Standards 3. The work must not involve painting of any previously unpainted surface or rendering of previously unplastered wall surfaces. 3. Repair and maintenance of a scheduled historic site or scheduled historic area. 4. Trimming of notable trees identified in Schedule Any maintenance and upgrading of paved roads, modified berms and paths must not involve land disturbance which extends beyond the area or depth previously disturbed. 2. Any fencing does not involve any scheduled historic site land disturbance that extends beyond the area or depth previously disturbed. 1. Any trimming must be undertaken only: a) to achieve compliance with the requirements of the Electricity (Hazards from Trees) Regulations 2003 or its successor; or b) if it is compromising the safety and integrity of or obstructing an existing access leg, right of way or driveway; and c) by an arborist who has attained the New Zealand Qualifications Authority National Certificate in Arboriculture Level 4 or equivalent qualification. 2. All trimming must be undertaken in accordance with the New Zealand Arboricultural Association Incorporated Best Practice Guideline Amenity Tree Pruning Version 3 dated April The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Tahi: a) land disturbance; and b) fencing. 1. Heritage site land disturbance must be for: a) the fencing the perimeter of the area; or b) human burials within WTS216A Raukohatu Urupā, WTS578C Wainui Urupā or the part of WTS183A Pukehou 4C6 Urupā which is located on PUKEHOU 4C6 BLK IX WAITOHU SD - CEMETERY ATI KAPU RES. 2. Fencing must be along the perimeter of the waahi tapu or property. 3. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 6. The following activities in an 1. The maximum extent of land disturbance must not exceed 10m 3 per calandar year. Comment [ET2]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct Comment [MM3]: 14 - Heritage New Zealand Comment [ET4]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct Appeals Version March [10-9] -

10 Table 10A.1 Permitted Activities The following activities are permitted activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding permitted activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and permitted activity standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Permitted Activities area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Rua: a) land disturbance; b) alterations and additions to existing buildings; c) fencing; d) new buildings ancillary to lawfully established uses in the waahi tapu; and e) relocation of existing buildings. 7. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Toru: a) land disturbance; b) additions and alterations to existing buildings; c) fencing; and d) relocation of lawfully established buildings. 8. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Wha: Standards 2. Alterations and additions to buildings must not include basements or in-ground swimming pools. 3. Fencing must be along the perimeter of the waahi tapu or along the property boundary. 4. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 1. The total volume of land disturbance must not exceed 10m 3 per calendar year. 2. Additions and alterations to buildings must not include basements or in-ground swimming pools. 3. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 1. Additions and alterations to buildings must not include basements or in-ground swimming pools. 2. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. Comment [MM5]: 14 - Heritage New Zealand. Appeals Version March [10-10] -

11 Table 10A.1 Permitted Activities The following activities are permitted activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding permitted activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and permitted activity standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Permitted Activities a) land disturbance; b) new buildings associated with lawfully established buildings and uses; c) alterations to lawfully establishedbuildings; and d) relocation of lawfully established buildings. 9. For the following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori - Wāhanga Rima: a) land disturbance; b) additions and alterations to lawfully established buildings; c) fencing; and d) relocation of lawfully established buildings within the waahi tapu. Standards 1. Notice of proposed land disturbance must be provided to Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga at least 10 working days prior to work commencing. 2. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 3. Land disturbance in the Rural Zone that does not disturb more than 100m³ within a 5 year period, excluding land disturbance associated with the maintenance of a network utility. 4. Land disturbance in the river corridor zone must not disturb more than 10m³ within a 10 year period, excluding land disturbance associated with stormwater control or the maintenance of a watercourse or network utility. Appeals Version March [10-11] -

12 Table 10A.2 Controlled Activities The following activities are controlled activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding controlled activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Controlled Activities Standards Matters over which Council reserves control 1. Alterations for earthquake strengthening of a scheduled historic building or structure with a Heritage New Zealand Category 1 or 2 classification identified in the Schedule of. 1. Strengthening work must not be visible on any exterior façade or feature. 2. The work carried out must be consistent with the original in terms of quality, materials and detailing. Any replacement materials must be of the original or similar material, colour, texture, form and design as the original it replaces. 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on visual, character and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed building or structures. 4. Effects on context and surroundings. 5. The matters within Policy The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 2. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Toru: a) new buildings. 1. Buildings must be ancillary to lawfully established buildings. 2. The total volume of heritage site land disturbance must not exceed 10m³ per calendar year. 3. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed buildings. 4. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. Comment [MM6]: 14 - Heritage New Zealand - seeks this be made restricted discretionary. 3. The modification of any notable tree(s) that is not a permitted activity under Rule 10A The modification of a notable tree must be limited to: a) modification of vegetation that is damaged, dead or dying or has sustained storm damage or is fatally diseased such that: i. the vegetation is no longer independently viable or presents a 1. The extent and method of vegetation removal. 2. The location and timing of planting of any plant species to compensate for the loss of vegetation. 3. Any remedial work necessary to restore the site after the modification activity is complete. Appeals Version March [10-12] -

13 Table 10A.2 Controlled Activities The following activities are controlled activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding controlled activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Controlled Activities Standards Matters over which Council reserves control risk of serious harm to people or 4. Public safety. property or risks damaging surrounding protected vegetation; and 5. Measures to avoid, remedy or mitigate effects on tāngata whenua values. ii. an arborist who has attained the New Zealand Qualifications Authority National Certificate in Arboriculture Level 4 or equivalent qualification has certified in writing that Condition (i) above is met; or 2. Felling or removal of any tree, in relation to an existing network utility, that is necessary to reduce risk to that existing network utility. 4. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori- Wāhanga Rima: a) new buildings. 1. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 2. All permitted activity standards under the rules in Tables 7A.1 and 9A Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Layout, design and location of proposed buildings or structures. Appeals Version March [10-13] -

14 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity Standards Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion 1. Any activity affecting a historic heritage feature, which does not comply with one or more of the permitted or controlled activity standards, unless otherwise specified. 1. Consideration of the effects of the standard not met. 2. Effects on historic heritage values. 3. Measures to avoid, remedy or mitigate adverse effects. 4. Cumulative effects. 2. Subdivision of any land or property containing a scheduled historic building or structure, a scheduled historic site, a notable tree, or a scheduled historic area, waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori except as provided for in Rules 10A.3.9 and 10A The historic heritage feature must be contained within one lot or where the feature is contained within more than one lot the number of lots containing the feature will not be increased. 1. Imposition of financial contributions in accordance with Chapter 12 of the Plan. 2. Degree of compliance with Council s Subdivision and Development Principles and Requirements, 2012 (or structure plan or guideline). 3. Effects on historic heritage values. 4. Layout of the subdivision. 5. Effect on context and surroundings. Comment [ET7]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct 6. Effects on landscape and amenity values. 7. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. 3. Alterations or additions to 1. Effects on historic heritage values. Comment [ET8]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct Appeals Version March [10-14] -

15 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity scheduled historic building or structure, scheduled historic site, or scheduled historic area, including: a) construction of new buildings or structures; b) work that does not meet the definition of repair and maintenance; c) internal and external alterations and additions to a scheduled historic building; and d) earthquake strengthening activities that do not comply with one or more controlled activity standards in Rule 10A Trimming of notable trees which do not comply with Rule 10A.1.4 or the standards in Rule 10A.2.3, or modification of notable trees by any network utility operator to ensure the safety and integrity of any network utility or to maintain access to the network utility. Standards Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed building. 4. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. 5. The matters within Policy Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. The matters listed in Policy Effects on context and surroundings. Appeals Version March [10-15] -

16 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity Standards Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion 5. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Tahi: a) land disturbance not meeting the permitted activity standards; b) additions and alterations to lawfully established buildings; and c) fencing (not meeting the permitted activity standards) d) roads and network utilities. 1. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed building. 4. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. Comment [ET9]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct Note: land disturbance under this Rule which does not meet the restricted discretionary activity standard falls under Rule 10A The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Rua: 1. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed building. Comment [ET10]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct Appeals Version March [10-16] -

17 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity a) alterations and additions to lawfully established buildings which do not comply with the permitted activity standards; b) land disturbance which does not comply with the permitted activity standards; c) new buildings which do not comply with the permitted activity standards; and d) roads and network infrastructure. Note: Land disturbance under this Rule which does not meet the restricted discretionary activity standard falls under Rule 10A The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Toru: a) alterations to lawfully established buildings Standards 1. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion 4. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed building. 4. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on Comment [MM11]: 14 - Heritage New Zealand. Appeals Version March [10-17] -

18 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity which do not comply with the permitted activity standards; b) roads and network utilities; c) land disturbance not meeting the permitted activity standards; d) clearance of karaka at Mataihuka Pā (WTS0216); and e) new buildings which do not comply with the controlled activity standards. Note: land disturbance under this Rule which does not meet the restricted discretionary activity standard falls under Rule 10A The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Wha: a) scheduled historic site land disturbance not meeting the permitted Standards 1. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Effects on landscape and amenity. 3. Layout, design and location of proposed building. 4. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Comment [MM12]: 14 - Heritage New Zealand. Appeals Version March [10-18] -

19 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity activity standards; b) new buildings and alterations which do not comply with the permitted activity standards; c) any building or structure that obstructs views or existing access between key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage; and d) roads and network utilities. Note: land disturbance under this Rule which does not meet the restricted discretionary activity standard falls under Rule 10A.5.1. Standards Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion Heritage. Appeals Version March [10-19] -

20 Table 10A.3 Restricted Discretionary Activities The following activities are restricted discretionary activities, provided that they comply with all corresponding restricted discretionary activity standards in this table, and all relevant rules and standards in other Chapters (unless otherwise specified). Restricted Discretionary Activity 9. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori - Wāhanga Rima: a) new buildings that do not comply with the controlled activity standards under Rule 10A.2.4; b) subdivision; c) new network utilities; d) land disturbance, alterations to existing buildings, fencing, and relocation of lawfully established buildings that do not comply with the permitted activity standards. Note: land disturbance under this Rule which does not meet the restricted discretionary activity standard falls under Rule 10A.5.1. Standards 1. The Accidental Discovery Protocol, set out in Schedule 10.2, must be followed. 2. Subdivision: compliance with subdivision rules and standards for the underlying zone(s). 3. New network utilities must comply with network utility rules and standards within Chapter 11. Matters over which Council will restrict its discretion 1. Effects on historic heritage values. 2. Layout, design and location of proposed buildings. 3. Imposition of financial contributions in accordance with Chapter 12 of the Plan. 4. Degree of compliance with Council s Subdivision and Development Principles and Requirements, 2012 (or structure plan or guideline). 5. Layout of the subdivision. 6. Effects on landscape and amenity values. 7. Effects on context and surroundings including any effects on key access and view points listed in the Schedule of Historic Heritage. Appeals Version March [10-20] -

21 Table 10A.4 Discretionary Activities The following activities are discretionary activities. Discretionary Activities 1. Any activity affecting a historic heritage feature which is specified as a Restricted Discretionary Activity and does not comply with one or more of the relevant standards, unless otherwise specifically stated. 2. Relocation of historic heritage as a scheduled historic building or structure, scheduled historic site, or scheduled historic area (except where specified in this Plan to be a Non-Complying activity). Comment [ET13]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd in relation to Ngarara Zone and Ngarara Precinct 3. Partial demolition, demolition or destruction of a scheduled historic building or structure, scheduled historic site, or scheduled historic area (except where specified in this Plan to be a Non-Complying activity). Appeals Version March [10-21] -

22 10A.5 Non-Complying Activities The following activities are non-complying activities. Non-Complying Activities 1. Partial demolition, demolition or destruction of Heritage New Zealand Category 1 or 2 historic heritage identified scheduled historic buildings or structures, scheduled historic sites, scheduled historic areas, or as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori. For the avoidance of doubt land disturbance which does not comply with the restricted discretionary activity standards under Rules 10A.3.5, 10A.3.6, 10A.3.7, 10A.3.8 and 10A.3.9 is deemed destruction under this Rule. 2. Relocation of Heritage New Zealand Category 1 historic heritage identified scheduled heritage buildings and structures, scheduled historic sites, scheduled historic areas, or as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori. 3. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Tahi: a) new buildings; and b) intensive farming 4. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Māori Wāhanga Rua and Wāhanga Wha: a) intensive farming. 5. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and Places and Areas of Significance to Iwi Wāhanga Toru: a) intensive farming; and b) subdivision where the number of lots the Scheduled item is contained within is increased. Comment [SH14]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd (in relation to Ngarara Zone and Precinct only) Comment [SH15]: 8 - Maypole Environmental Ltd seeks to add an exemption from the rules as they apply to the Ngarara Zone and WTS0318 Taewapirau and WTS0318A Taewapirau waahi tupuna Criteria for notification: any application under this Rule shall either be publicly notified or notice served on relevant iwi authority and Heritage New Zealand as affected parties. 6. The following activities in an area scheduled as waahi tapu and other places and areas of significance to Maori Wāhanga Rima: a) intensive farming. Appeals Version March [10-22] -

23 Schedules 1. Schedule 10.1 Schedule of 2. Schedule 10.2 Accidental Discovery Protocol 3. Schedule 10.3 Standard Tree Evaluation Method Appeals Version March [10-23] -

24 Schedule 10.1 Schedule of Historic Places, including buildings and structures (and surroundings/setting, if applicable) (including commercial buildings, industrial buildings, residential buildings, public buildings, recreational structures (e.g. gazebos), infrastructure (e.g. bridges), memorials, retaining walls, etc). The column includes, where available, the Heritage NZ register number ( HNZ### ), the NZ Archaeological Association site number ( NZAA### ), and GPS coordinates ( GPS### ). Name Address Legal Description Description/Significance or Contributory Places B Ōtaki Railway Arthur St, Ōtaki SO Originally constructed in Station Railway land Exterior is a fine Lot 1 DP (CT example of the work of WN55D/455) and Pt George Alexander Troup Te Awaroa 12A (CT ( ). WN55D/456), Wellington Land B Pukekaraka Presbytery B St Mary's Church (Catholic) 2-4 Convent Rd, Ōtaki 2-4 Convent Rd, Ōtaki Pukekaraka 5 ML 401 Pukekaraka No 5 Lot 1 Pt Lot 2 DP 1660 & Lot 1 DP Pukekaraka 5 ML 401 Pukekaraka No 5 Lot 1 Pt Lot 2 DP & Lot 1 DP The third Pukekaraka presbytery to be built on this site. Constructed in St Mary's Church, Pukekaraka, built in , is considered to be New Zealand's oldest surviving Catholic church still in use. HNZ Category Cat. 2 B Cottage - Brown 3 Main Highway Lot 2 DP Constructed circa Cat. 2 Sugar Cafe (SH1), Ōtaki B Railway House 206 Mill Rd, Ōtaki SO Sec 4 Blk Cat. 2 IX Waitohu SD B Railway House 208 Mill Rd, Ōtaki SO Sec 3 Blk Cat. 2 Cat. 2 Cat. 1 Appeals Version March [10-24] -

25 B Rahui Milk Treatment Station B Rahui Factory Social Hall B Ōtaki Children s Health Camp Rotunda B Māori University Building (Te Wānanga-O- Raukawa College) B Te Rauparaha Memorial & Jubilee Memorial Monument B Māori School (next to Rangiātea Church site) Name Address Legal Description Description/Significance or Contributory Places IX Waitohu SD 35 Rahui Rd, Ōtaki Lots 1, 4 DP 4014 Pt Matitikura ML 258 A/ Rahui Rd, Ōtaki Lots 1, 4 DP 4014 Pt Matitikura ML 258 A/349 Health Camp Rd, Ōtaki SO Appt of Sec 5, Pt Sec 18 Blk VIII Waitohu SD Tasman Rd, Ōtaki Pt 4 DP 3364 Pt Lot 3 8 DP Lot 6 DP cnr Te Rauparaha & Hadfield Sts, Ōtaki Te Rauparaha St, Ōtaki B Lovat House 29 Hadfield Rd, Peka Peka B Kildoon Stables 48 Winara Ave, B Kildoon House 48 Winara Ave, B Arapawaiti (Ferry 10 Hana Udy Place, House Inn) Beach B Paekākāriki Railway Main Rd, Paekākāriki Station Corner, North Island Pt Mangapouri Māori Reserve ML 5304 HNZ Category Cat. 2 Cat. 2 Cat. 1 Cat. 2 Cat. 1 Pt Church Mission Cat. 2 Grant Ml 461 Pt Lots 1, 7 DP Pt Piritaha No.4 Lot 2 DP Blk Cat. 2 VI Kaitawa SD Pt Lot 5 DP Cat. 2 Lot 1 DP Pt 5 DP Cat. 2 Lot 1 DP Lot 1 DP Cat. 2 Railway land ( ) Cat. 2 Appeals Version March [10-25] -

26 Name Address Legal Description Description/Significance or Contributory Places Main Trunk Line, State Highway 1 and Beach Road and Tilley Road B South end signal box Railway Station, Main Rd, Paekākāriki Corner, North Island Main Trunk Line, State Highway 1 and Beach Road and Tilley Road B Paekākāriki Railway Yard Water Vats x 2 B Paekākāriki Railway Station Goods Shed (old rail-air shed) Railway Station, Main Rd, Paekākāriki Paekākāriki Railway Yard B26 Memorial Gates Mackays Crossing, Queen Elizabeth Park Railway land ( ) Railway land ( ) Lot 11 DP (CT WN54A/80) Wellington Land Railway land ( ) Lot 11 DP (CT WN54A/80) Wellington Land Sec 100 Blk II Paekākāriki SD SO 24783, SH1 B Restaurant Main Rd, Paekākāriki Pt Paekākāriki 1B ML 1436 & Pt Plan A/2237 B28 Anglican Church Beach Rd, Paekākāriki Pt Lot 4 DP 830 St Peter's Anglican Church and grounds and associated fixtures HNZ Category Cat. 1 Cat. 1 Cat. 2 Appeals Version March [10-26] -

27 B29 B30 Name Address Legal Description Description/Significance or Contributory Places Te Nikau Bible Valley Rd, Lot 4 DP Lot 1 House College DP & Closed Early Californian bungalow style house 52 Tilley Rd, Paekākāriki B31 Ōtaki Beach Pavilion Marine Pde, Ōtaki Beach B Ngatiawa Bridge Mangaone South Rd, Old road bridge Reikorangi B33 Anglican Church 1 Elizabeth Street, B Old Post Office (1906) 9 Elizabeth St, 7A Elizabeth Street, B35 Barn - Horse Stables Queen Elizabeth Park B36 B37 Original School Room William Jenkins cottage. Also known as Misses Jenkins' cottage 21 Ruapehu St, 206 Ōtaki Gorge Road, Ōtaki B38 Mill stones 20 Tasman Road, Ōtaki Road Lot 10 Blk III DP 2465 Beachfront opposite Rupini Street located between Lot 3 DP and Pt Sec 61 Blk X Kaitawa SD Lot 4 DP Sec 1 Town of Parata SO Pt Lot 4 DP 1031 Pt Sec 3 Blk II Paekākāriki SD SO Lots 24, 25 Blk II DP 462 Sec 26 SO Lot 1 DP Blk III Kaitawa SD Lot 1 DP and Pt 1 Taumanuka ML House - built 1920 Art Deco era St Lukes Church-origins in a Māori Village in 1850's (near Kauri Tree, Greenaway Road) Currently Kapiti Coast Museum Built 1887, now used as school library at School. Local identity and hero. Very old building. HNZ Category Cat. 2 Cat. 2 Appeals Version March [10-27] -

28 Name Address Legal Description Description/Significance or Contributory Places 1507 B40 Historic residence 44 Atkins Road, Lot 1 DP Built from Totara bush, Ōtaki 1885 B41 Old church building, Christian 1896 Holiday Park, Kauri Rd, B43 Clark memorial and Paekākāriki Hill Road bush. (Hair Pin Bend) B44 Old school house Main Road North, Paekākāriki B45 Paekākāriki Tennis 14 Wellington Rd, Club Paekākāriki B46 Post and telegraph 8 Ngapotiki St, wrought iron Beach standard B47 Old house 91 Main Highway (SH1), Ōtaki B48 Paekākāriki Wellington Rd, Playcentre Paekākāriki B49 Historic Building cnr Ōtaki Gorge Rd/Te Horo Hautere Cross Rd, Ōtaki B50 Memorial Gates Memorial Park - Tutanekai St, B52 Water catchment system Gully behind BP Service Station, Paekākāriki Lot 1 DP 24354, Lot 1 DP 27661, Lot 1 DP Used for worship, weddings, prayer. Relocated from Apiti. Sec 93 Wainui Dist Built 1888 Blk II Paekākāriki SD Pt Lot 7 DP 1879 Historic Building - built 1930s Lot 18 DP Remnant of telegraph line s. Pt Plan A/2425 Lot 7 DP Pt Sec 103 Blk II Wainui Dist SO Lot 5 DP Lot 5A DP 463 SO Pt Lot 2 DP heart rimu and kauri. Historic Building - built 1890s Built 1892 (Old Post Office) In memory of soldiers who fought in previous World war HNZ Category B53 Old house 290 Main Road (SH1), Ōtaki Lot 2 DP originally used as home for homeless and Appeals Version March [10-28] -

29 B54 B55 B56 Name Address Legal Description Description/Significance or Contributory Places deprived children Once Te Horo 990 State Highway 1, Ngakaroro Pt 3 D1 Railway Station Te Horo No. 6 Blk II Kaitawa SD ML 1526 Original Post Office 12 Elizabeth St, Lot 1 DP CT Built now currently a Store 17A/129 dairy. Originally Methodist Aotaki St, Ōtaki Pt 83 Town of Ōtaki Built Church ML 956 B57 Family Hotel 30 Main St, Ōtaki Pt Secs Town of Ōtaki, ML 3205, 1458 Built 1881 B58 Telegraph Hotel Tasman Road, Ōtaki Pt Lot 2 DP Built 1895 HNZ Category B59 Jubilee Hotel 17 Waerenga Road, Ōtaki Pt Lot 1 DP 7103 Built currently House of Hope B60 Court House Centennial Reserve, Lots 1-4 DP Main Road, Ōtaki B62 Ōtaki Library 148 Tasman Road, Lot 4 DP 2554 Built 1904 Ōtaki B64 Osneloc House 1 Hadfield St, Ōtaki Pt Secs 59, 60 Town of Ōtaki ML 3204 Old historic house - built 1899 B65 Shop and dwelling 72 Main Street, Ōtaki Pt Sec 113 Town of Built around 1880 Ōtaki ML 1083 B67 Historic home 98 Waerenga Rd, Lot 3 DP Built 1903 Ōtaki B68 Raukawa Dairy 90 Mill Rd, Ōtaki Pt Sec 164 Town of Ōtaki ML 5258 Built 1890s originally for R J Staveley, Solicitor, as an office B69 Coaching stables 282 Rangiuru Rd, Ōtaki Lot 3 DP 7938 Built currently car repair business. B72 Greenaway 14 Kauri Rd, Lot 57 DP Built Appeals Version March [10-29] -