CARB Rule Changes- Affects on the Automotive Repair Industry Virginia St. Jean, CIH Industrial Hygienist/DPH Green Programs Manager SF Hazardous Materials Unified Program Agency Virginia.stjean@sfdph.org www.sfdph.org/dph/eh/green www.sfgreenbiz.org
SFDPH Clean and Green Program Launched in 2001 as pilot award program Compliance excellence Pollution prevention Toxics reduction Auto Repair and Maritime sector only 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 2
SFDPH s INTEREST Develop industry specific resource guides to provide latest toxics and compliance tips Serve roll as non-biased information resource- compliance, greener products/methods 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 3
Why Automotive Sector? Interest from industry/businesses Toxics/green washing concerns Businesses already well associated Requested information on ingredients of concern in new aerosol formulations after Dec 2010 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 4
Hazmats in Automotive Sector Most small containers (< 2 gal) regulated by CARB Stationary emission sources regulated by Local AQMDs 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 5
Stationary Emission Sources 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 6
Stationary Emission Sources Mixing Room Spray Booth 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 7
What Emission Sources Remain? Fueling Welding Smog Checks Coatings Application/Removal Parts Cleaning (general) Lubricating Aerosol Cleaning Miscellaneous 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 8
Aerosols 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 9
Adhesives Consumer Products in Auto Shops Adhesive Removers Battery Care Brake Cleaners & Anti-Squeak Carburetor Cleaners Electronic Cleaners Engine Degreasers Graffiti Removers 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 10
Lubricants: Products Consumer in Auto Shops Anti-seize Dry Lube Gear, Chain, Wire Multi-purpose Penetrants Rust Preventative Silicone-based Multi-purpose 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 11
Products Consumer in Auto Shops Multi-Purpose Degreasers Paint Strippers Spot Removers/Upholstery Cleaners Tire/Wheel Cleaners Undercarriage Cleaners Undercoatings 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 12
Ingredients of Concern Hexane Proposition 65 chemicals such as toluene, benzene, methanol, ethylbenzene, etc. Chlorinated hydrocarbon solvents N-Bromopropane (n-propyl bromide) N-Methyl Pyrrolidone 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 13
Interesting Side Note Air Board bans water pollutants as substitutes! Alkylphenol Ethoxylate Surfactants ban in substitutes for non-aerosols 12/31/2012: General Purpose Cleaners General Purpose Degreasers Glass Cleaner Heavy-Duty Hand Cleaner or Soap Oven or Grill Cleaner 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 14
Aerosol Cleaning Health concerns- worker exposure 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 15
5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 16
After Dec. 2010 Aqueous sink-top parts washing Aqueous dishwasher style Aqueous brake cleaning Solvent-based aerosol cleaning Water-based pump spray cleaning Replace parts vs clean them 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 17
Aqueous Sink-Top Parts Washers 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 18
Aqueous Dishwasher Style 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 19
Aqueous Cleaning Hot water with detergents and surfactants Usually high ph: Sodium carbonate, ethoxylated alcohols (C-9-C-11), fatty acids, neo-decanoic acid Enzymes Filters/sludge collectors Replenish with water 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 20
Brakes 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 21
Brake Cleaners 10%VOC Aqueous Sink-Top Aqueous pump spray (mild detergent) Aerosols: Acetone ~90%, CO2 10% VOC made up from Toluene Methanol Amyl acetate Heptane and/or heptane isomers Methyl cyclohexane 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 22
Brake Disc Quiet VOC-not regulated Aerosol version contains: Acetone N-hexane Ethyl acetate Naphtha Butane, propane as propellants Paste version contains: Acrylic polymers Ethylene glycol Water Pigments 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 23
Engine Degreasers Aerosols 10%VOC: Heavy Duty: Naphtha, aliphatic and aromatic blends Foamy: Surfactant, alcohol, glycol ether blend Orange: Petroleum distillates, d-limonene, ethoxylated alcohols Bulk (non-aerosol) 5% VOC: Non-ionic surfactant, disodium tetraborate, misc detergents 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 24
Carburetor, Choke, Throttle Body Cleaners Aerosols 10% VOC - Acetone blends plus: butoxyethanol, toluene methanol, toluene Petroleum solvents, organic ketone (??), hydrocarbon propellant heptane, methanol Non-aerosol- Aqueous solution (cleaner/degreaser) 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 25
Electrical Parts Cleaners Halogenated and only approved for cleaning energized electrical parts. Not allowed for non-energized parts cleaning. 45% VOC, sell thru dates for MeCl, Perc, TCE- 12/31/2011!!!!! Perchloroethylene or trichloroethylene and CO2 Other halogenated solvents to replace chlorinated banned solvents??? 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 26
Electronic Cleaners 75% VOC, non halogenated Usually very flammable- contain hexane or isohexane and HFC-152A (1,1-difluoroethane) Note- cannot use on energized parts due to flammability and it s the law! Anti-static cleaner- water, butoxyethanol 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 27
Mass Air Flow Sensor Cleaner Hexane isomers, n-hexane, synthetic isoparaffinic hydrocarbon, methanol, CO2 Not currently regulated under Consumer Products VOC Regs. USE WITH CARE- VERY FLAMMABLE and TOXIC!! 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 28
Multi-Purpose Solvent 12/31/2010, sell through date 12/31/2013 Chlorinated Hydrocarbon ban Global Warming Potential of 150 or greater prohibited No greater than 1% aromatic compound VOC Limits: 30% after 12/31/2010 3% after 12/31/2013 Alkylphenol Ethoxylates surfactants not banned 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 29
Glass and Window Cleaners Aerosols- VOC limit 10% Non-aerosols- VOC limit 4% 12/31/20004, 3% after 12/31/2012 Typically water-based with small amounts of alcohols and/or glycol ethers Green substitute- vinegar solution 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 30
Windshield Washer Fluid vs Water Repellent Windshield Water Repellant: Meant to be single treatments, not windshield washer fluid VOC allowance 75% after 12/31/2010 Windshield Washer Fluid: Type A areas (mountains, rural)- 25% VOC All other areas- 1% VOC 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 31
Graffiti Removers After 12/21/2006: Aerosols- 50% VOC Non-aerosol- 30% VOC Chlorinated Hydrocarbons banned 12/31/2009 Two types Dimethyl glutarate, n-methyl-pyrollidone (developmental toxicant!), (R)-p-mentha-1.8- diene (sensitizer) Soy with small amount of NMP (not very effective unless a lot of NMP) Need better alternative options!!! 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 32
Paint Strippers 50% VOC limit after 1/1/2005 Three types: Methylene Chloride formulations (toxic and carcinogen) N-methyl pyrrolidone (NMP) blends Benzyl Alcohol/NMP blends 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 33
Metal Polish or Cleansers Chlorinated Hydrocarbon ban effective date 12/31/2012, sell thru 12/31/2015 VOC limits: 30% after 1/1/2005 Aerosols 15% after 12/31/2012 Non-aerosols 3% after 12/31/2012 GWP Value <150 after 12/31/2012 (12/31/2015 sell thru date) Petroleum blends, methyl siloxane and surfactants or organic salts and surfactants 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 34
Tire/Wheel Cleaners Aerosol- 8% VOC limit LVP-VOCs, proprietary petroleum blends, siloxanes Non-aerosol- 2% VOC limit Water-based with various types of surfactants and/or siloxanes 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 35
Undercoating Aerosol rubberized coatings- used to protect undercarriage from water/salts/sand and general corrosion Cars mfr d with coating, shops tend to touch up as needed VOC Limit- 40% Contain typical paint solvents, polymer blends, pigments 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 36
What to do now? AEROSOL CLEAN OUT DAY!!! Use up old products, recycle empties Recycle (non-empty) aerosols as Universal Waste Purchase only CA compliant aerosols Avoid ingredients of concern Keep staff informed of your needs/choices for a safer shop Use refillable containers 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 37
What to do now? Use product only for intended use Provide extra training for users Work closely with vendors for the right product Talk to other shops/associations- survey others on best ways to use new products Think outside the box- is there a different way perform the maintenance or repair? 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 38
Low Hanging Fruit- Existing Resources HESIS Hazard Alerts www.cdph.ca.gov/programs/hesis DTSC Toolkits www.dtsc.ca.gov/pollutionprevention DTSC Green Chemistry http://dtsc.ca.gov/pollutionprevention/greenchemistryiniti ative/index.cfm EPP lists www.sfenvironment.org/sfapproved http://www.epa.gov/dfe/ www.greenseal.org www.ecologo.org Other national standards/checklists Prop 65/MSDSs www.oehha.ca.gov/prop65/prop65_list/newlist.html 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 39
THANK YOU!!! To CARB for the Rule Changes: For lowering VOCs and banning certain toxicants; makes a safer work place and environment To the GREEN CHEMISTS of the World: For determining better ways to perform required tasks To the AUTO SHOPS: For complying, providing feedback to manufacturers/vendors on new products AND.. THANK YOU TO THE AUDIENCE FOR LISTENING! 5/17/2012 Virginia St. Jean 40