Consultation Document Southern Section. Project LT68 Orkney Grid Connection. October 2018

Similar documents
Rannoch 132 / 33 kv Substation Extension

Dorenell Wind Farm 132 kv Grid Connection

Route Alignment Options Summary Report

Assessing the impact of smallscale wind energy proposals on the natural heritage

Consultation Document - Alignment Selection. Creag Dhubh substation to Dalmally substation. 275kV Overhead Line REF: LT000029

Introduction. Who we are. Purpose of this public consultation

Caithness HVDC Switching Station Pre Application Consultation Event. August 2016

GUIDELINES FOR THE ROUTEING OF NEW HIGH VOLTAGE OVERHEAD TRANSMISSION LINES

7. The Landscape. 7.1 Introduction. Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) Scoping Report

TOPIC PAPER 2: Links to other sustainability tools

An Bord Pleanála. Eirgrid Plc. Meath County Council Cavan County Council Monaghan County Council

High Speed Rail (London- West Midlands)

Our approach to the design and routeing of new electricity transmission lines

Examination of South Cambridgeshire Local Plan

Perth and Kinross Council Development Management Committee 20 February 2013 Report of Handling by Development Quality Manager

9 Archaeology & Cultural Heritage

Caithness HVDC Switching Station Consultation

PURPOSE OF MEETING MEETING GUIDELINES PROJECT BACKGROUND ESKOM CLOCOLAN-FICKSBURG 88 KV POWERLINE, FREE STATE

volume 11 environmental assessment section 2 environmental impact assessment Part 7 ha 218/08

Identify matters regarding the project which inform the preparation of the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS);

Perth and Kinross Council Development Management Committee 24 April 2013 Report of Handling by Development Quality Manager

Perth and Kinross Council Development Control Committee 28 November 2012 Report of Handling by Development Quality Manager

6B.1 INTRODUCTION B.1.1 Background B.1.2 Purpose of the Study... 2

Tandridge Local Plan Assessing the Ecological Suitability of 183 sites considered for development Tandridge District Council, Surrey

Tara Skryne Landscape Conservation Area Project: Progress Report: Phase 1

Policy DM19: Development and Nature Conservation

Newcombe House & Kensington Church Street

CONSULTING SERVICES FOR THE WHITEBELT VISIONING EXERCISE ADDENDUM TO THE GTA WEST LAND USE STUDY WORK PROGRAM

Delegated Report. Application Type: Full Planning Permission. Recommendation - Approve subject to conditions. Ward - Wigtown West

Ebbsfleet Development Corporation

Perth and Kinross Council Development Management Committee 8 June Pre-Application Report by Development Quality Manager

CAIRNGORMS NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY

Lower Sensitivity. VS Classification Level 2: Exposed Upland/Plateau

Environmental Assessment (Scotland) Act 2005: Clackmannanshire Council Sustainability Strategy Scoping Request

CORRECTIONS WITHIN DESIGN MANUAL FOR ROADS AND BRIDGES AUGUST 2009

Proposed 132kV Grid Connection to Lorg and Longburn Wind Farms

CAIRNGORMS NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY

Alternative Route Selection

DESIGN AND MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVES PART 5 HA 90/01 PLANNING AND POLICY FEATURES SUMMARY

Replacement Golf Course Facilities and Residential Development, Churston. Environmental Statement Non-Technical Summary

PANSHANGER QUARRY, Hertfordshire

TOWN AND COUNTRY PLANNING (SCOTLAND) ACT 1997

Alternative Routes. St. Vital to La Verendrye Station - Southern Loop Transmission Corridor. 20 different segments 4 segments common to all routes

Wind energy development in the South Pennines landscape

BREEDON NORTHERN LIMITED

Heart of Neolithic Orkney World Heritage Site: Statement of Outstanding Universal Value

Wyvern Park Skipton Environmental Statement. Non-technical Summary - April 2015

Archaeological Monitoring of Land at 29 Royal Pier Road, Gravesend, Kent

Guide to Transmission Equipment Maintenance

RURAL ZONE - POLICY. Rural Zone Policy. Issue: Rural Environment. Ruapehu District Plan Page 1 of 8

Form to Submit Land for Residential Evidence Gathering Shepway Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment (SHLAA) Partial Review

Circular L8/08 2 September Water Services Investment and Rural Water Programmes Protection of Natural Heritage and National Monuments

Thank you for coming. We want to hear your views on proposed improvements to the A1 between junction 65 (Birtley) and junction 67 (Coal House).

Andershaw to Coalburn 132kV Overhead Line Environmental Statement. April 2009

Environmental Impact Assessment

CAIRNGORMS NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY

REFERENCE: B/03745/12 Received: 02 October 2012 Accepted: 05 October 2012 WARD(S): Totteridge Expiry: 30 November 2012.

The Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) (Wales) Regulations 2016, Regulation 13 Scoping Opinion

LAND AT WEST YELLAND. Environmental Statement Non-Technical Summary Welbeck Strategic Land LLP

MAKING SENSE OF PLACE

Welcome to the Public Consultation Exhibition

A21. Start of works exhibition Tonbridge to Pembury. Welcome. Dualling Scheme

PRESENTATION TO THE CROSS PARTY GROUP ON ARCHITECTURE AND THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT A MANIFESTO FOR THE BUILT EMVIRONMENT

Land East of Cromwell Lane

Site Assessment Technical Document Appendix A: Glossary

Interim Advice Note 76 / 06 ASSESSMENT PART 1 AIMS AND OBJECTIVES OF ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT. Contents

Proposed St. Vital Transmission Complex

Kier Infrastructure and Overseas Limited Greenburn Surface Mine, Dalgig Farm Site

NOTICE OF PREPARATION

Report reference: LT/WTE/LZH/1655/01/SCOPING June 2015

14 Visual Amenity 14-1

PHASE 1 ARCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT ERF 3 ROBERTSON WESTERN CAPE PROVINCE

London Road, Derker. Non Technical Summary. Introduction

Velindre Cancer Centre Environmental Statement Vol.1: Environmental Statement Text. Chapter 1: Introduction

HERITAGE POLICY...Safeguarding the Built Heritage. Conservation Plans. A Guide to the Preparation of Conservation Plans

North Wales Wind Farm Connections. Route Corridor Report

Overhead Line Insulators

PUBLIC NOTICE UNDER CLAUSE 5 OF SCHEDULE 1 OF THE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT ACT 1991 PLAN CHANGE 12 TO THE OPERATIVE CITY OF NAPIER DISTRICT PLAN

UTT/17/2075/FUL - (BERDEN) (Referred to Committee by Councillor Janice Loughlin. Reason: In the Public Interest)

Town of Cobourg Heritage Master Plan. Statutory Public Meeting

Public Consultation. Land at Monks Farm, North Grove. Welcome

Natural Heritage Guidance and Information. 6 th of December 2007 Brendan Turvey

3. Highway Landscaping Assessment

orld Heritage Site W

Settlement Boundaries Methodology North Northumberland Coast Neighbourhood Plan (August 2016)

Request for a Scoping Opinion by Provectus. Proposed Surface Mining of Coal on Land west off the A61, Hill Top Farm, Clay Cross, Derbyshire

Grantham Southern Quadrant Link Road Environmental Statement

REPORT CLIENT: COMPANY: EirGrid PLC The Oval 160 Shelbourne Road Ballsbridge Dublin 4

Land to the North of Main Road, Wybunbury

NON TECHNICAL SUMMARY

Cape Environmental Assessment Practitioners(Pty)

Final Revisions: Reason: For the avoidance of doubt and in the interests of proper planning.

Leaside to Main Infrastructure Refurbishment Project

CITY OF VAUGHAN EXTRACT FROM COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF NOVEMBER 15, 2016

Vaughan Metropolitan Centre (VMC) Black Creek Renewal CLASS ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT

Northbury Farm, Castle End Road, Ruscombe, Berkshire

Response by The Dartington Hall Trust

Final Revisions: Provision of single storey modular classroom and associated works.

Cardiff International Sports Village Waterfront Development Volume IV : Non-Technical Summary of the Environmental Statement

Scottish Hydro Electric Transmission Visual Impact of Scottish Transmission Assets (VISTA) Inverness 11 November 2015

Transcription:

Consultation Document Southern Section Project LT68 Orkney Grid Connection October 2018

Orkney Grid Connection Consultation Document Southern Section October 2018

QUALITY MANAGEMENT Issue/Revision 1 2 3 4 Date 14/9/18 15/10/18 Remarks DRAFT FINAL Prepared by Louise Robertson and Keith Grant Louise Robertson and Keith Grant Signature Checked by Keith Grant illiam Hazell Signature Authorised by illiam Hazell Simon Hall Signature Project number 0427615 0427615 Report number File reference Scottish Hydro Electric Transmission plc Inveralmond House 200 Dunkeld Road Perth PH1 3AQ Tel: +44 (0)1738 456 000 www.ssepd.co.uk i

CONTENTS LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS III 1. INTRODUCTION 1-1 1.1 Purpose of this Document 1-1 1.2 Document Structure 1-1 1.3 Next Steps 1-1 2. THE PROPOSALS 2-1 2.1 Need for the project 2-1 2.2 Project Overview 2-1 2.3 Construction activities 2-3 2.4 Programme 2-3 3. ROUTE AND ALIGNMENT SELECTION PROCESS 3-1 3.1 Guidance documents 3-1 3.2 Main Considerations 3-1 3.3 Area of search 3-2 3.4 Baseline conditions 3-2 3.5 Appraisal method 3-2 4. DESCRIPTION OF ROUTES 4-1 4.1 Identification of sections 4-1 4.2 Identification of route options 4-1 5. COMPARATIVE APPRAISAL 5-1 5.1 Introduction 5-1 5.2 Finstown to St Mary s (FS) 5-1 5.3 South Ronaldsay to St Mary s (SS) 5-4 5.4 Hesta Head to South Ronaldsay / South Ronaldsay to Hoxa Head (HS/SH) 5-5 5.5 Hoxa Head to Rinnigill (HR) 5-8 5.6 Rinnigill to Melsetter (RM) 5-9 6. ALIGNMENT SELECTION 6-1 6.1 Introduction 6-1 6.2 Alignment FS, Finstown to St Mary s 6-1 6.3 Alignment SS, South Ronaldsay to St Mary s 6-23 6.4 Alignment HS/SH, Hesta Head to Hoxa Head 6-27 6.5 Alignment RM, Rinnigill to Melsetter 6-37 6.6 Hoxa Head to Rinnigill (HR) 6-41 7. CONSULTATION ON THE PROPOSAL 7-1 7.1 Introduction 7-1 7.2 Next steps 7-1 ii

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS GDTE HES kv Km NSA LNCS OHL OS pspa SHE Transmission SAC SEPA SNH SPA SSSI RAG RSPB LA HS Ground ater Dependent Terrestrial Ecosystem Historic Environment Scotland Kilovolt Kilometre National Scenic Area Local Nature Conservation Site Overhead Line Ordnance Survey Proposed Special Protection Area Scottish Hydro Electric Transmission plc Special Area of Conservation Scottish Environmental Protection Agency Scottish Natural Heritage Special Protection Area Site of Special Scientific Interest Red, Amber, Green Royal Society for the Protection of Birds ild Land Areas orld Heritage Site iii

1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Purpose of this Document This consultation document invites interested parties to comment on the proposals by Scottish Hydro Electric Transmission plc (SHE Transmission) to construct a single circuit 132 kv double wood pole trident overhead line (OHL) on Orkney. The consultation document outlines the process by which the preferred route and alignment for the wooden pole trident OHL has been selected. Comments are now sought from statutory authorities, key stakeholders, elected representatives and the public on the routeing process and the preferred alignment described. These comments will inform further consideration of the alignment and the eventual selection of a proposed alignment for which consent will be sought. Consultation on preferred routes was undertaken with statutory authorities and the public in April and May 2018 and this report summarises the results of this process for the overhead line running south from Finstown to South Ronaldsay and Hoy (the Southern section, see Figure 2.1). Consultation on preferred alignments was undertaken with statutory authorities and the public in September 2018 and this report summaries how the preferred alignment was selected. 1.2 Document Structure This Consultation Document comprises the following sections: Section 1: Introduction Section 2: The Proposals Section 3: Route and alignment selection process Section 4: Description of routes Section 5: Comparative appraisal Section 6: Description of alignments Section 7: Comparative appraisal Section 8: Alignment selection Section 9: Consultation on the proposals 1.3 Next Steps Following completion of the consultation process, SHE Transmission will review all comments received from statutory authorities, landowners and the public. Together with further assessment of potential environmental impacts and technical studies, the comments will be used to refine the preferred alignment into a proposed alignment. Final technical and environmental assessment will then be undertaken to provide information to support an application to Scottish Ministers for consent for the construction and operation of the overhead lines (OHLs) under section 37 of the Electricity Act 1989. A Report on Consultation will also be produced which will document all consultations received, and the decisions made in light of these responses. The intention is to submit the application for consent in Q2 2019. 1-1

2. THE PROPOSALS 2.1 Need for the project SHE Transmission is a wholly owned subsidiary of the SSE plc group of companies. SHE Transmission owns and maintains the electricity transmission network across the north of Scotland and holds a licence under the Electricity Act 1989 to develop and maintain an efficient, co-ordinated and economical system of electricity transmission. The Orkney Islands currently have no 132 kv transmission infrastructure and are served by two 33 kv distribution subsea cables between Rackwick Bay on Hoy, and Murkle Bay near Thurso. These cables were installed in 1982 and 1998 with a total import/export capacity of 40 M. Demand on the islands varies between 7 M in summer and 46 M in winter and a standby diesel generator is located in Kirkwall to secure demand. The current connected embedded generation in Orkney uses all of the capacity of the existing 33 kv cables. At present, there are contracted connection agreements between National Grid and developers in Orkney for 461 M of new generation. This has led to the requirement for a transmission connection between Orkney and mainland Scotland. The development is in line with SHE Transmission s commitment and licence obligations to facilitate the connection of renewables generators to the grid through an economical, efficient and coordinated approach to transmission reinforcement. SHE Transmission has a duty under Section 9 of the Electricity Act 1989 to facilitate competition in the generation and supply of electricity. The preferred route and alignment is the option considered to present the best opportunity to achieve an economically viable, technically feasible and environmentally acceptable connection for two contracted renewable energy developments south of Finstown. 2.2 Project Overview The Proposed Development consists of 132 kv electricity overhead line infrastructure as illustrated on Figures 2.2 and 2.3. The technology solution proposed and appraised is a single circuit double wood pole (H pole) trident OHL. The most common height is anticipated to be 14 m although depending on terrain, the height may vary between 12 m and 17 m. The overall Orkney 132 kv Infrastructure project is required to connect contracted renewable energy developments to the new transmission network at the proposed Finstown substation. Due to its scale the project has been split into two geographical parts in order to achieve the design programme and to enable consent applications to progress in a staged manner. The parts are shown on Figure 2.1 and are: Northern Section (north of Finstown); and Southern Section (south east of Finstown via Burray, South Ronaldsay, Flotta to Hoy). This report considers the southern section only and other sections will be the subject of separate consultation reports. 2-1

EC ER Northern Section Route EC Route ER Route FE Southern Section Route FS Route HR Route HS/SH Route RM Route SS FE FS 0 1 2 3 4 5 Kilometers ± HR SS SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 VERSION: A03 DRAN: B RM HS/SH PROJECT: 0348229 DATE: 04/09/2018 Figure 2.1 Overview of All Routes CHECKED: KG APPROVED: H PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\Overview Figures\0348229_RouteOverview_A03.mxd

Figure 2.2 Example of a trident H wood pole Figure 2.3 Comparison drawing of proposed 132 kv trident H pole against scale of existing 33 kv infrastructure on Orkney 2.3 Construction activities Key tasks during construction will involve: Potential localised improvements to the public road network to allow safe construction access; Establishment of suitable construction compound and laydown areas for materials; Upgrades to existing tracks and potential installation of temporary track solutions where required for safe construction access; Delivery of structures and materials to pole positions; Assembly and erection of wood pole structures and stays; and Stringing of conductors using hauling ropes and winches. Installation of the wood poles would involve the following tasks: Excavation of a suitable area for the wood poles, and backfilling after installation of the pole; In some pole locations, it may be necessary to add imported hardcore backfill around the pole foundations to provide additional stability in areas where the natural sub soils have poor compaction qualities; Conductors would be installed on the wood poles using full tension stringing to prevent the conductor coming into contact with the ground; and Remedial works would be carried out to reinstate the immediate vicinity of the structure, and ground disturbed, to pre-existing use. 2.4 Programme A summary of the indicative development programme is provided in Table 2.1. 2-3

Table 2.1 Indicative Development Programme Date Tasks 2016/ 2017 Identify possible overhead line routes. Identify technology options of overhead line routes, and outline designs for substation sites. Development of overhead line routes including site walkovers, desk based assessments and appraisals. 2017/ 2018 Selection of preferred overhead line route options Consider feedback, and make modifications to preferred overhead line routes, as necessary. Confirmation of proposed overhead line routes Baseline environmental surveys of overhead line routes, including bird surveys, otter surveys and habitat surveys. 2018/2019 Identification of preferred overhead line alignments, including pole locations. Screening for the Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) and scoping if required Undertake environmental assessments, and modify proposed overhead line alignments as necessary Consider feedback from public consultation events and make amendments, as necessary Submit Section 37 applications for overhead lines 2019/ 2020 Receipt of consents and determination of planning applications 2020 Subject to all consents, construction work starts on site 2022 Construction complete, commissioning and energisation 2-4

3. ROUTE AND ALIGNMENT SELECTION PROCESS 3.1 Guidance documents The approach to route and alignment selection is informed by the following SHE Transmission guidance: High Voltage ood Pole Transmission and Distribution Main Interconnector Lines in Rural Landscapes: Detailed Routeing Guidelines (TG_PS_651) High Voltage ood Pole Transmission and Distribution Main Interconnector Lines in Rural Landscapes: Strategic Routeing Principles (Adapted From Holford Rules For Overhead Transmission Line Routeing) (TG-PS-650) Procedures for Routeing Overhead Lines of 132 kv or above, SHE Transmission, The guidance develops a process which aims to balance environmental, technical and economic considerations throughout the route and alignment optioneering process. In consideration of these principles, the method of identifying an environmentally preferred route and alignment in this study has involved the following four key tasks: Identification of the baseline situation; Identification of alternative route/alignment options; Environmental, technical and economic analysis of route/alignment options; and Identification of a preferred route/alignment option. The approach to route selection is informed by SHE Transmission s guidance The SHE Transmission Approach to Routeing of Overhead Lines. This new guidance broadens the basis for routeing decisions to reflect contemporary practice, and ensures environmental, technical and economic considerations are identified and appraised at each stage of the routeing process. The guidance splits a project into six stages, as follows: Pre-Routeing Activities: Selection of proposed connection option Stage 0: Routeing strategy development Stage 1: Corridor Selection Stage 2: Route Selection Stage 3: Alignment Selection Stage 4: Consenting This consultation document presents the appraisal completed at stages 2 and 3. 3.2 Main Considerations Route options were identified following site appraisals, taking into account the most notable constraints identified during the baseline studies. Considerations have included a review of the steps outlined in the Holford Rules and SHE Transmission s approach to routeing. In summary, the following has been taken into account as far as is practicable at the routeing and alignment selection stages: Avoid if possible major areas of highest amenity value (including those covered by national and international designations and other sensitive landscapes); Avoid by deviation, smaller areas of high amenity value; Try to avoid sharp changes of direction and reduce the number of larger angle towers required; Avoid sky lining the route in key views and where necessary, cross ridges obliquely where a dip in the ridge provides an opportunity; Target the route towards open valleys and woods where the apparent height of towers will be reduced and views broken by trees (avoid slicing through landscape types and try to keep to edges and landscape transitions); Consider the appearance of other lines in the landscape to avoid a dominating or confusing wirescape impact; and 3-1

Technical issues related to clearances, connectivity, outages, maintenance and faults. 3.3 Area of search Overhead lines are required between up to six potential new substations in Orkney. Substation site locations will be determined by renewable energy developers at Costa Head, Rendall, South Ronaldsay and East Hoy. A proposed new grid substation location near Finstown has been identified by SHE Transmission. Developer substation site selection is underway and proposed sites are yet to be identified. For the purposes of route selection, route options start and end at a central point in the substation search areas, or where appropriate, cover all substation site options being considered. Routes and alignments between the following start and end points are considered in this document: Finstown to St Mary s (FS) Rinnigill to Melsetter (RM) Hesta Head to Hoxa Head (HS/SH) South Ronaldsay to St Mary s (SS) Hoxa Head to Rinnigill (Flotta) (HR) 3.4 Baseline conditions Initial desk studies established the key environmental features of the study area. Identification of environmental designated sites and other constraints, utilising GIS datasets available via SNHi Site Link and other sources; Identification of archaeological designations and other recorded sites, utilising GIS datasets available via Historic Environment Scotland Data Services and Local Historic Environment Teams; Review of the Orkney Local Development Plan 2017; Review of landscape character assessments of relevance to the study area; Review of ordnance survey mapping (OS) (1:50,000 and 1:25,000 and online GIS data sources from OS OpenData) and aerial photography (where available) to identify other potential constraints such as settlement, properties, walking routes, cycling routes etc.; Extrapolation of OS Vectormap GIS data to identify further environmental constraint including locations of watercourses and waterbodies, roads classifications and degree of slope; and Review of other local information through online and published media such as tourism sites. In addition, a suite of environmental surveys has been undertaken to provide additional baseline information, these covered: Landscape and visual walkover survey by landscape architects; Cultural heritage walkover survey by archaeologists; Bird survey including for wildfowl, raptors, breeding birds and wintering birds; Habitat survey; Otter survey; and Peat survey. Site visits were also undertaken by SHE Transmission OHL engineers and other project team members to help inform the technical and economic appraisal of options. 3.5 Appraisal method Appraisal of route options has involved systematic consideration against the following environmental, technical and economic topic areas: Environmental: 3-2

Natural Heritage (Designations, Protected Species, Habitats, Ornithology and Geology, Hydrology and Hydrogeology); Cultural Heritage (Designations and Cultural Heritage Assets); People (proximity to dwellings); Landscape (Designations and Character); and Land Use (Agriculture, Forestry and Recreation). Environmental sensitivity has been considered qualitatively, based on professional judgement and utilising the red, amber, green (RAG) rating. It has been applied to each topic area indicating potential impacts. This rating is based on a three point scale as described in Figure 3.1 below. SSE guidance Procedures for Routeing Overhead Lines of 132 kv or above has been followed. Figure 3.1 RAG Rating for Comparative Analysis Most Preferred Lower Impact Low potential for the development to be constrained Moderate Impact Intermediate potential for the development to be constrained Least Preferred Higher Impact High potential for the development to be constrained 3-3

4. DESCRIPTION OF ROUTES 4.1 Identification of sections This report considers the southern section routes of the Orkney Grid Connection Project which are: Finstown to St Mary s (FS) Rinnigill to Melsetter (RM) Hesta Head to Hoxa Head (HS/SH) South Ronaldsay to St Mary s (SS) Hoxa Head to Rinnigill (Flotta) (HR) 4.2 Identification of route options 4.2.1 Finstown to St Mary s (FS) Three route options were identified: Route FS heads south along Germiston Road to the west of Loch Kirbiser, turns east along the route of the A964 passing south of Kirkwall before picking up the route of the A961 and a minor road as far as Bay of Cornquoy. Route FS1 passes down the Loch Kirbister Valley to the east of Loch Kirbister before heading east along the A961 and same route as route FS as far as Bay of Cornquoy. Route FS2 runs east from Finstown to the north of the hills as far as ideford Hill before it passes to the south and picks up the same route options FS and FS1 as far as the Bay of Cornquoy. The routes are illustrated on Figures 4.1, 4.2 and 4.3 together with environmental designations. 4-1

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G GGardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE FS OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A01 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 21/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.1 Proposed Overhead Line Route: FS PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Original_A01.mxd

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G GGardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE FS1 OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A01 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 21/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.2 Proposed Overhead Line Route: FS1 PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Original_A01.mxd

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G GGardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE FS2 OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A01 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 21/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.3 Proposed Overhead Line Route: FS2 PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Original_A01.mxd

4.2.2 Rinnigill to Melsetter (RM) One route option was identified: Route RM runs from Rinnigill to Melsetter. Given the number of environmental designations and the topography of Hoy, no further route have been identified. The route is illustrated in Figure 4.4 together with environmental designations. 4.2.3 Hesta Head to South Ronaldsay Switching Station/ South Ronaldsay Switching Station to Hoxa Head (HS/SH) One route option was identified: Route HS/SH heads north from the proposed Hesta Head wind farm east of the A961 before heading west south of St Margaret s Hope to the north of the B9043. The route is illustrated on Figure 4.5 alongside environmental designations. 4-5

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Proposed Subsea Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G G Gardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE RM OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A04 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 18/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.4 Proposed Overhead Line Route: RM PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Revised_A01.mxd

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G GGardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE HS/SH OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A01 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 21/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.5 Proposed Overhead Line Route: HS/SH PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Original_A01.mxd

4.2.5 South Ronaldsay to St Mary s (SS) One route option was identified: Route SS heads north east from the proposes switching station on South Ronaldsay to Bu sand on Burray. The route is illustrated in Figure 4.6 together with environmental designations. 4.2.6 Hoxa Head to Rinnigill (Flotta) (HR) One route option was identified: Route HR passes through the centre part of Flotta. The route is illustrated in Figure 4.7 together with environmental designations. 4-8

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Proposed Subsea Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G G Gardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE SS OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A04 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 18/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.6 Proposed Overhead Line Route: SS PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Revised_A01.mxd

Listed Building: A B C Scheduled Monument orld Heritage Site Sensitive Ridgeline Proposed OHL Route Other Proposed OHL Route Proposed Subsea Route Special Protection Area (SPA) Special Area Conservation (SAC) Ramsar Site Heart of Neolithic Orkney orld Heritage: Site Boundary Site Buffer Zone Site Sensitive Area National Scenic Area RSPB Reserve ildland G G G Gardens Designed Landscape G G G Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) Geological Conservation Review Area Proposed SPA ROUTE HR OpenStreetMap (and) contributors, CC-BY-SA ± 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 Kilometres SCALE: See Scale Bar SIZE: A3 PROJECT: 0348229 VERSION: A04 DRAN: B CHECKED: KG DATE: 18/06/2018 APPROVED: H Figure 4.7 Proposed Overhead Line Route: HR PROJECTION: British National Grid SOURCE: See Map Frame; Reproduced by permission of Ordnance Survey on behalf of HMSO. Crown copyright and database right [2016] all rights reserved. Ordnance Survey Licence number EL273236; Natural England copyright. Contains Ordnance Survey data Crown copyright and database right 2016. Path: \\ukedidc01\data\edinburgh\projects\0348229 Orkney - Site selection.kg\00 GIS\MAPS\orking\0348229_ERMProposedOHLCorridors_Revised_A01.mxd