Information for File MVP-2014-03830-MMJ; Reconstruction (Waconia and Watertown Townships) Applicant: Carver County Corps Contact: Melissa Jenny Address: 180 Fifth Street East, Suite 700, St. Paul, MN 55101 E-Mail: Melissa.M.Jenny@usace.army.mil Phone: (651) 290-5363 Primary County: Carver Location: Sections 3, 10 & 15, Township 116 N., Range 25 W., and Section 34, Township 117 N., Range 25 W. Information Complete On: January 21, 2015 Posting Expires On: January 30, 2015 Authorization Type: LOP-05-MN This application is being reviewed in accordance with the practices for documenting Corps jurisdiction under Sections 9 & 10 of the Rivers and Harbor Act of 1899 and Section 404 of the Clean Water Act identified in Regulatory Guidance Letter 07-01. We have made a preliminary determination that the aquatic resources that would be impacted by the proposed project are regulated by the Corps of Engineers under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. Our jurisdictional review and final jurisdictional determination could result in modifications to the scope of the project s regulated waterbody/wetland impacts and compensatory mitigation requirements identified above. Any approved jurisdictional determination made prior to reaching a permit decision will be posted on the St. Paul District web page at http://www.mvp.usace.army.mil/. Project Description and Purpose (as stated by the applicant): Carver County is proposing to reconstruct 3.2 miles of County State Aid Highway (CSAH) 10, from CSAH 30 (Waconia Township) to Trunk Highway (TH) 7 (Watertown Township), in order to improve vehicle, pedestrian and bicyclist safety and to meet current design standards. The project would involve widening the existing 4-foot gravel shoulders to 10- foot paved shoulders and upgrading to a 10-ton facility. Turn lanes would be added at West Shoreline Drive, North Shore Road and 62 nd Street. The project would also facilitate a connection to the Dakota Rail Regional Trail, including construction of a new parking lot for trail users. The project would result in the discharge fill material into 0.516 acres of wetland, as detailed below and on the attached figures. 1
Name, Area and Types of Waters (Including Wetlands) Subject to Loss: Aquatic Resource ID Wetland Community Type of Impact Size of Impact Duration of Impact W-5 Wet Meadow/Shallow Marsh Fill 0.306 acre Permanent W-7 Wet Meadow Fill 0.018 acre Permanent W-H Wet Meadow Fill 0.046 acre Permanent W-J Wet Meadow Fill 0.131 acre Permanent W-8 Wet Meadow Fill 0.015 acre Permanent Total Impacts 0.516 acre Alternatives Considered (as stated by the applicant): Alternative #1: No-Build Alternative Under the No Build Alternative, would not be reconstructed. The crash history/safety issues associated with this segment of would not be addressed, the 4-foot gravel shoulders would not be widened to provide acceptable recovery/clear zones, and horizontal and vertical deficiencies would not be improved. This alternative was dismissed because it does not meet the project purpose and need. Alternative #2: Avoidance Alternative There are no practicable alternatives which meet the project purpose that would not have wetland impacts. Alternative #3: Reconstruction on New Alignment The project is being reconstructed on the existing alignment. Construction on a new location would not improve the existing roadway deficiencies and would likely result in greater environmental and social impacts compared to reconstruction on existing alignment, including property acquisitions and utility relocations. Alternative #4: Reconstruction with Off-Road Trail A separated off-road bicycle trail was considered, but is not proposed as part of the project to avoid additional property and wetland impacts. Carver County will consider adding a trail in the future, but the trail would be constructed as a separate project. Compensatory Mitigation: The applicant has proposed to compensate for unavoidable permanent wetland impacts associated with the safety related portions of this project (0.385 acre) at a 2:1 ratio through the Board of Water and Soil Resources (BWSR) Local Road Replacement Program. The applicant has proposed to compensate for unavoidable permanent wetland impacts associated with the non-safety related portions of this project (0.131 acre) at a 2:1 ratio via purchase of wetland bank credits from a Corps approved wetland bank located within the same major watershed as the impact site Drawings: attached and labeled as 2014-03830-MMJ, Posting figures 1 11. 2
Page 1 of 11 Hennepin Anoka Ramsey Washington SP 010-610-046 END «7 Carver Project Location Scott Dakota Watertown Township Waconia Township ") 10 Project Limits ") 30 SP 010-610-046 START J:\Maps\8231\mxd\Fig01 - Project Location.mxd 0 1,250 2,500 5,000 Feet Service Layer Credits: Sources: Esri, DeLorme, NAVTEQ, TomTom, Intermap, increment P Corp., GEBCO, USGS, FAO, NPS, NRCAN, GeoBase, IGN, Kadaster NL, Ordnance Survey, Esri Japan, METI, Project Location Reconstruction Project SP 010-610-046 Carver County Figure 1
Page 2 of 11 Hennepin Anoka Ramsey Washington SP 010-610-046 END «7 Carver Project Location Scott Dakota Watertown Township Waconia Township ") 10 Project Limits ") 30 J:\Maps\8231\mxd\Fig02 - Existing Conditions - Aerial Photograph.mxd 0 1,250 2,500 5,000 Feet SP 010-610-046 START Service Layer Credits: Source: Esri, i-cubed, USDA, USGS, AEX, GeoEye, Getmapping, Aerogrid, IGN, IGP, and the GIS User Community Existing Conditions - Aerial Photograph Reconstruction Project SP 010-610-046 Carver County Figure 2
10/14/2014-7:53PM MVP-2014-03830-MMJ Page 3 of 11 Figure 3A H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3A
Page 4 of 11 W-9 0.000 AC. IMPACT H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3B 10/14/2014-7:55PM Figure 3B
Page 5 of 11 W-9 0.000 AC. IMPACT H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3C 10/14/2014-7:57PM Figure 3C
Page 6 of 11 W-8 0.015 AC. (SAFETY) H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3D 10/14/2014-7:59PM Figure 3D
Page 7 of 11 W-J 0.131 AC. (NON-SAFETY) H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3E W-I 0.000 AC. IMPACT 10/14/2014-8:01PM Figure 3E
Page 8 of 11 W-H 0.046 AC. (SAFETY) H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3F 10/14/2014-8:05PM Figure 3F
Page 9 of 11 W-7 W-7 0.018 AC. (SAFETY) H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3G 10/14/2014-8:08PM Figure 3G
Page 10 of 11 W-10 0.000 AC. IMPACT W-5 0.306 AC. (SAFETY) H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3H 10/14/2014-8:11PM Figure 3H
Page 11 of 11 W-4 0.000 AC. IMPACT W-5 SEE FIGURE 3H H:\Projects\8231\CAD_BIM\Graphics\8231-WETLAND-IMPACTS.dwg : FIG 3I 10/14/2014-8:13PM Figure 3I