GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY BACKGROUND REPORT. January 22, 2018

Similar documents
4.1 Vaughan Metropolitan Centre Vaughan, Ontario. 4.2 Newmarket Secondary Plan Newmarket, Ontario BACKGROUND REPORT

Eglinton Avenue East & 50 Thermos Road - Official Plan Amendment Application Preliminary Report

SCARBOROUGH SUBWAY EXTENSION. Scarborough Subway Extension. Final Terms of Reference

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN. Community Consultation Meeting #3 June 26, 2018

Official Plan Review: Draft Built Form Policies

WELCOME. The Yonge-Eglinton area has experienced significant growth and change in the last decade.

Welcome. Walk Around. Talk to Us. Write Down Your Comments

PART 1. Background to the Study. Avenue Study. The Danforth

YONGE STEELES CORRIDOR SECONDARY PLAN. Young + Wright / IBI Group Architects Dillon Consulting Ltd. GHK International (Canada) Ltd.

SUBJECT: GO Station Mobility Hubs Preferred Concepts: Aldershot GO, Burlington GO and Appleby GO. Planning and Development Committee - Public Meeting

THAT the attached Terms of Reference for the Thornhill Centre Street Study be approved.

PUBLIC OPEN HOUSE HURONTARIO-MAIN CORRIDOR SECONDARY PLAN

1 Introduction. Chapter. In this chapter:

Planning and Growth Management Committee. Chief Planner and Executive Director, City Planning Division. Pg12013 (File No NNY 34 OZ)

Public Open House. YWCA, 87 Elm Street December 2nd, 2017, 10 a.m. 2 p.m.

1120 Haist Street - Pelham Arena Community Co-Design Recommendation Report Haist Street - Pelham Arena Community Co-Design Recommendation Report

Bloor St. W. Rezoning - Preliminary Report

PILLAR FOUR INTEGRATE LAND USE & TRANSPORTATION

3. Endorse the LRT vision in transforming Surrey into Connected-Complete-Livable communities, and more specifically, the official vision statement:

DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT DRAFT

CITY OF VAUGHAN EXTRACT FROM COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF NOVEMBER 15, 2016

and Richmond Street West - Official Plan Amendment Application - Preliminary Report

6 Growth Management Challenges and Opportunities

SUBJECT: Proposed Downtown Mobility Hub Precinct Plan and Proposed Official Plan Policies

Public Open House. Overview of the Downtown Plan Official Plan Amendment April 23, 2018

1.0 Purpose of a Secondary Plan for the Masonville Transit Village

ONTARIO MUNICIPAL BOARD

McCowan Precinct Plan Study Background & Deliverables

Figure 1- Site Plan Concept

Agincourt Mall Planning Framework Review Status Report

Long Branch Neighbourhood Character Guidelines Final Report

178 Carruthers Properties Inc.

Director, Community Planning, Etobicoke York District

John M. Fleming Managing Director, Planning and City Planner. Old East Village Dundas Street Corridor Secondary Plan Draft Terms of Reference

5 TOWN OF MARKHAM OFFICIAL PLAN AMENDMENT NO. 144 MILLIKEN MAIN STREET SECONDARY PLAN

Welcome to the Oakridge Centre Open House

Commercial, Retail and Tourism Executive Summary December 2018

Official Plan Review

This report presents the draft Don Mills Crossing Secondary Plan for public consultation.

Trafalgar Road Corridor Planning Study Open House

The Master Plan Framework

THE TOWN OF WASAGA BEACH

DOWNTOWN GEORGETOWN PLANNING STUDY

MAYFIELD WEST SECONDARY PLAN PHASE 2

St. Lawrence Neighbourhood Focused Area - Official Plan Amendment Status Report

K. SMART ASSOCIATES LIMITED

Planning for the Future Urban Area. in north Markham. Update. Development Services Committee. December 9, De Development Services Committee

13 THORNHILL YONGE STREET STUDY IMPLEMENTATION CITY OF VAUGHAN OPA 669 AND TOWN OF MARKHAM OPA 154

1071 King Street West Zoning Amendment Application - Preliminary Report

WELCOME and introduction

Transit-supportive development and city-building

ELMVALE ACRES SHOPPING CENTRE MASTER PLAN

WITNESS STATEMENT Of. Ronald Blake. On behalf of the Intervenor The Corporation of the City of Markham

Streets for People, Place-Making and Prosperity. #TOcompletestreets

Port Credit Local Advisory Panel October 20 th Meeting

CITY OF VAUGHAN EXTRACT FROM COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES OF JUNE 7, 2016

ELK GROVE GENERAL PLAN VISION

Scarborough Centre Transportation Master Plan Final Report

1.0 PLANNING MARKHAM S FUTURE CONTENTS

The Corporation of the Town of Milton

MAYFIELD WEST SECONDARY PLAN PHASE 2

SUBJECT: Waterfront Hotel Planning Study Update TO: Planning and Development Committee FROM: Department of City Building. Recommendation: Purpose:

Building out the Regional Growth Strategy in Surrey: a Strong Centre & a Connected Transit City

Queen Street West - Zoning Amendment Application - Preliminary Report

CONSULTING SERVICES FOR THE WHITEBELT VISIONING EXERCISE ADDENDUM TO THE GTA WEST LAND USE STUDY WORK PROGRAM

Elfrida Growth Area Study

12 AMENDMENT NO. 149, TOWN OF MARKHAM HIGHWAY 404 NORTH SECONDARY PLAN

Local Growth Planning in North Central Green Line Communities

Downtown Streetscape Manual & Built Form Standards

2040 LUP is a part of the Comprehensive Plan and carries the same legal authority. Economic Challenges

1.3 TRANSIT VISION 2040 FROM VISION TO ACTION THEME 1: PUTTING TRANSIT AT THE CENTRE OF COMMUNITIES. Fully integrate transit with community planning

MOUNT PLEASANT SECONDARY PLAN & VILLAGE BLOCK PLAN. Wednesday, March 5, 2008 Informal Public Open House

Create Policy Options Draft Plan Plan Approval. Public Consultation Events. Phase 2

Don Mills Crossing Study and Celestica Lands Development Application Community Meeting, Open House, and Breakout Discussions

The Five Components of the McLoughlin Area Plan

Finch Avenue West and Sheppard Avenue East Corridors - Planning Study Approach. Planning and Growth Management Committee

King-Spadina Secondary Plan Community Consultation Meeting. Michelle Knieriem, City Planner October 11, 2017

Complete Neighbourhood Guidelines Review Tool

8 Oak Street - Official Plan and Zoning By-law Amendment Application - Preliminary Report

Town Center (part of the Comprehensive Plan)

Tippett Road Area Regeneration Study Final Report. Planning and Growth Management Committee

The West Vaughan Employment Area Secondary Plan Policies

Sustainable Growth. Sustainable Growth

~!VAUGHAN NOV Z November 21, Mr. Denis Kelly, Regional Clerk The Regional Municipality of York Yonge Street Newmarket, ON L3Y 6Z1

NEW REGIONAL OFFICIAL PLAN HIGH LEVEL PROCESS & FRAMEWORK

North Fair Oaks Community Plan Summary and Information

THE CITY OF VAUGHAN BY-LAW BY-LAW NUMBER A By-law to adopt Amendment Number 1 to the Official Plan of the Vaughan Planning Area.

SECTION ONE: INTRODUCTION. introduction

844 Don Mills Road & 1150 Eglinton Avenue East - Official Plan Amendment Application - Preliminary Report

City of Welland Commercial Policies. Public Information Centre March 25 th, 2009

Land Use Amendment in Southwood (Ward 11) at and Elbow Drive SW, LOC

150 Eighth Street Zoning By-law Amendment Application Preliminary Report

PUBLIC MEETING AND OPEN HOUSE: Don Mills Crossing Phase 2 Celestica Development Applications. February 21, 2017

01 the vision NEW LYNN IS WAITING FOR THE GREAT LEAP FORWARD

60-64 Queen Street East and Church Street - Zoning Amendment Application - Preliminary Report

Urban Design Manual PLANNING AROUND RAPID TRANSIT STATIONS (PARTS) Introduction. Station Study Areas

Courtice Main Street Study Community Vision Workshop PLANNING SERVICES DEPARTMENT

4- PA - LD - LIVELY DOWNTOWN. LD - Background

UTSC SECONDARY PLAN COMMUNITY OPEN HOUSE

Relief Line Project Assessment

Transcription:

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY BACKGROUND REPORT January 22, 2018

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY BACKGROUND REPORT Version Control Version: Final Reviewed by: Jason Petrunia Shonda Wang Submitted to: City of Toronto Date: January 22, 2018 Cover photo: Golden Mile (Eglinton Avenue East & Victoria Park Avenue), 1949 City of Toronto Archives 2

Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Report Structure 13 1.2 Introduction to the Study 13 1.3 Study Area 15 1.4 Study Approach 16 2.0 CHANGING REGION 2.1 Introduction 19 2.2 Golden Mile History 19 2.3 Drivers of Change #1: Growth and Investment 20 2.4 Drivers of Change #2: Policy Directions 21 2.5 Drivers of Change #3: Private Sector Investment 30 2.6 Golden Mile Today 33 3.0 PLANNING AND DESIGN ANALYSIS 3.1 Introduction 43 3.2 Parks and Open Spaces 43 3.3 Streets and Blocks 52 3.4 Land Use 59 3.5 Built Form 69 3.6 Transportation 78 3.7 Servicing 82 3.8 Community Infrastructure 84 3.9 Economy 86 3.10 Public Art and Heritage 88 3.11 Soft Site Analysis 94 BACKGROUND REPORT 4.0 PRECEDENTS 4.1 Vaughan Metropolitan Centre 99 4.2 Newmarket Secondary Plan 99 4.3 No. 3 Road Corridor 102 4.4 Dufferin Wilson Regeneration Area Study 104 4.5 Comparison of the precedents 104 5.0 PUBLIC AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT OVERVIEW 5.1 Phase 1 Engagement Process 107 6.0 DRAFT VISION AND PRINCIPLES 6.1 Vision and Principles 111 6.2 Next Steps - From Phase 1 to Phase 2 114 APPENDICES A. Transportation Master Plan Existing Conditions Report B. Master Servicing Plan Study Existing Conditions Assessment Technical Memo C. Community Infrastructure Strategy Existing Conditions Report D. Community Infrastructure Strategy Focus Group Summary E. Market Analysis & Economic Strategy F. Engagement Summaries 3

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY Lists List of Figures Figure 1 Project team 14 Figure 2 Study boundaries 15 Figure 3 Processes towards a Vision 17 Figure 4 Schedule 1, Greater Golden Horseshoe Growth Plan Area, 2017 20 Figure 5 Schedule 5, Growth Plan for the Greater Golden Horseshoe, Figure 6 Province of Ontario, 2017 22 Map of the Golden Mile Secondary Plan Study Area with 500m radii around transit stations 23 Figure 7 City of Toronto, Official Plan Urban Structure, 2015 27 Figure 8 Eglinton Connects Planning Study recommendations 29 Figure 9 Development applications currently under review 31 Figure 10 Map of the Golden Mile today 33 Figure 11 Map of CIS Boundary 34 Figure 12 Open Spaces in the TMP Boundary 44 Figure 13 Open spaces in the GMSP Study Area 45 Figure 14 Existing and planned cycling facilities 47 Figure 15 Existing pedestrian connectivity 49 Figure 16 Opportunities for regional green framework 50 Figure 17 Existing street network 53 Figure 18 Existing streetscape 54 Figure 19 Existing blocks 55 Figure 20 Existing parcel fabric 56 Figure 21 Opportunities for connections 57 Figure 22 Official Plan land use designations 61 Figure 23 Existing uses 63 Figure 24 Permitted uses: Zoning By-Law 569-2013 65 Figure 25 Permitted uses: former Scarborough Zoning By-Laws 65 Figure 26 Opportunities for land use 67 Figure 27 Existing setbacks on Eglinton Avenue East 70 Figure 28 Existing setbacks on cross streets 71 Figure 29 Existing retail primary frontages 72 Figure 30 Existing surface parking 73 Figure 31 Permitted height: former Scarborough Zoning By-Laws 74 Figure 32 Permitted height: Zoning By-Law 569-2013 74 Figure 33 Existing height 75 Figure 34 Opportunities for built form 76 Figure 35 Transportation summary 81 Figure 36 Servicing summary 83 Figure 37 Community Infrastructure Strategy summary 85 Figure 38 Historical map of the Study Area 1947 88 Figure 39 Projected development timeline 95 Figure 40 Soft site categories 96 Figure 41 Soft site analysis 97 Figure 42 Vaughan Metropolitan Centre Secondary Plan, Schedule F Land Use Precincts 100 Figure 43 Newmarket Urban Centres Secondary Plan, Schedule 3 Land Use 101 Figure 44 City of Richmond Official Community Plan No. 3 Road Corridor Map - Five Character Zones 103 Figure 45 Figure ground comparison of precedents 105 Figure 46 Work plan overview 107 Figure 47 The five building blocks of the Study 111 Figure 48 Draft Guiding Principles 113 Figure 49 Process from Phase 1 to Phase 2 115 4

BACKGROUND REPORT List of Images Image 1 Photograph from 1949 19 Image 2 Image of Google 3D map 33 Image 3 Future Eglinton Avenue East envisioned in Eglinton Connects Planning Study 46 Image 4 Existing conditions of sidewalk at Eglinton Parkette 48 Image 5 Existing conditions of sidewalk on Civic Road 48 Image 6 Existing conditions at Ashtonbee Reservoir Park 48 Image 7 Victoria Park Community Hub - The HUB 84 Image 8 Golden Mile marquee 89 Image 9 Lady on the swing billboard 89 Image 10 Existing heritage plaques 89 Image 11 Existing Eglinton Town Centre signage and location of heritage plaques 89 Image 12 Frank Perna s A Sense of Place 90 Image 13 Long blocks and large parking lots along Eglinton 90 Image 14 Speech Bubble by Jennifer Marman and Daniel Borins 91 Image 15 Arlington Stop 91 Image 16 Possibilities by Michel de Broin 92 Image 17 Art bollards by Antony Gormley 92 Image 18 Examples of public art signs and billboards 93 Image 19 Photos of No. 3 Road streetscape improvements 102 List of Tables Table 1 Population by age group of Golden Mile and sub-areas 35 Table 2 Household size in Golden Mile and sub-areas 37 Table 3 Structural type of dwelling in Golden Mile and sub-areas 39 Table 4 Household income and prevalence of low income in Golden Mile and sub-areas and Immigrants status in Golden Mile and sub-areas 40 Table 5 Country of origin in Golden Mile and sub-areas, 2011 41 Table 6 Element breakdown in GMSP Study Area 55 Table 7 Number of participants at engagement events 108 5

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

BACKGROUND REPORT INTRODUCTION (SECTION 1) SvN Architects + Planners was retained by the City of Toronto, City Planning, Community Planning (Scarborough District) to undertake the Golden Mile Secondary Plan Study (GMSP Study). The GMSP Study is to develop a Vision and Planning Framework for a complete community for the Golden Mile area along Eglinton Avenue East between Victoria Park Avenue and Birchmount Road. The Vision and comprehensive Planning Framework will form the foundation and recommendations for a Golden Mile Secondary Plan (GMSP), Urban Design Guidelines, Conceptual Master Plan, Community Infrastructure Strategy, Transportation Master Plan, Master Servicing Plan, Parks and Open Spaces Strategy, and other strategies and planning tools. The GMSP and associated strategies and planning tools will be used to guide growth and change in the area that is anticipated to occur as a result of the public investment in the Eglinton Crosstown Light Rail Transit (ECLRT). SvN has identified five building blocks that are both derived from and align with the Study s objectives. The five building blocks will be used as the basis of the Study. Within each building block, existing conditions, opportunities and constraints will be assessed to inform an understanding of the Study Area. The five building blocks are as follows: (1) Land Use / Urban Design; (2) Transportation; (3) Servicing; (4) Community Infrastructure; (5) Economy. The transportation and servicing building blocks will fulfill the Municipal Class Environmental Assessment (MCEA) requirements. This Report presents the results of the first phase of a three phase study involving background analysis, consultation and public outreach (including the MCEA component), opportunity and constraint analysis, and visioning. Four distinct sub-studies are incorporated in the Report, including a Transportation Master Plan Study, Master Servicing Plan Study, and Community Infrastructure Strategy. The Report builds upon the recently completed Market Analysis and Economic Strategy. CHANGING REGION (SECTION 2) The future of the Golden Mile is one that is defined by its history, key drivers of change and current conditions. The story of the Golden Mile is not dissimilar to the story of the changing Greater Golden Horseshoe (GGH) Region - with roots in an era of major public sector investment, and ensuing rapid growth and change, followed by an era of urban disinvestment, de-industrialization and ensuing social polarity. The current era is one of urban re-investment partly in recognition of the role of urban areas as vital engines of economic growth and partly in response to the scale of growth facing urban centres in the GGH region. Key drivers of change within this context include: population and employment growth and associated public sector investment in infrastructure to support growth; provincial and municipal policy direction on growth and development within intensification areas, including transit corridors; and private sector investment in response to anticipated growth and policy direction. The GGH is expected to increase from 9 to 14 million persons in the next 25 years. The Provincial Growth Plan indicates that the City of Toronto is expected to grow by 1 million people and jobs from 2011 to 2041. In turn, Metrolinx s Big Move is investing $8.4 billion in transit in Toronto, the largest component of which is the $5.3 billion ECLRT. The ECLRT will include five stops within the Study Area at the future O Connor, Pharmacy, Hakimi-Lebovic, Golden Mile and Birchmount stations. Funding for the ECLRT and these future stations has been approved and construction is planned to be complete in 2021 representing the next era in the evolution of the Golden Mile. 7

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY The Provincial planing and policy framework directs and encourages growth to coincide with investment in transit. Together, the Provincial Policy Statement, Growth Plan and the Big Move support change within the Golden Mile towards the development of transit-supportive, complete communities that feature an appropriate mix and range of employment, housing and community infrastructure. Intensification of existing employment lands and introduction of residential uses in appropriate locations within the Golden Mile will be required to achieve Provincial policy direction. Furthermore, one of the key principles of Toronto s Official Plan is the integration of land use and transportation planning and the Official Plan identifies an Urban Structure that establishes areas in which future growth is to be encouraged. These areas are locations where good transit access can be provided along regular surface and higher order transit routes, including the Golden Mile. Directing growth to these areas will enable the efficient use of land, infrastructure and services, concentrate people and jobs in areas well served by transit, promote mixed-use development that increases opportunities for living close to work, provide opportunities for people of all means to be housed in an affordable way, and protect neighbourhoods, green spaces and natural heritage features and functions from the effects of nearby development. A number of recent development applications have been submitted and are under review by the City within the Golden Mile (see 2.5 Driver of Change #3: Private Sector Investment) which reflect private sector interest and potential investment, including: 1) 1 Eglinton Square: consisting of a proposed Official Plan Amendment (OPA) and Zoning By-law Amendment to redevelop a portion of 1 Eglinton Square with a mix of uses, including approximately 1,800 residential units, spread over five development blocks while retaining the existing mall. 2) 1880-1890 Eglinton Avenue East (Golden Mile Shopping Centre) consisting of a proposed OPA that would add new site specific policies to the Official Plan to guide the redevelopment of the Golden Mile Shopping Centre into a new mixed-use, transitoriented neighbourhood with approximately 2,500 residential units. 3) 1966-2050 Eglinton Avenue East: consists of a proposed Site and Area Specific Policy (SASP) to maintain the existing Mixed-Use Area designation and add development parameters and principles that would guide the phased development of the lands, featuring approximately 3,000 residential units. PLANNING AND DESIGN ANALYSIS (SECTION 3) A planning and design analysis focusing on existing conditions, opportunities and constraints resulted in the following summary of key findings (see Section 3 for existing conditions, opportunities and constraints and Section 6 for summary of key findings): Improve built form through appropriate scale and orientation of buildings that align with transit investment, public realm improvements and relationships within existing uses; Better reflect the history and identity of the Golden Mile and prominence of Eglinton Avenue East as the Golden Mile corridor; Improve the relationship and transitions between uses and integration of open space within the Golden Mile; Improve the health, safety and security of the Golden Mile for current and future residents; Improve the balance of employment, residential, commercial, open space and community uses to accommodate future growth in the Golden Mile; 8

BACKGROUND REPORT Ensure housing and amenities remain accessible within the Golden Mile and ensure the type and level of services are consistent with needs of current and future residents; Improve the connectivity of the street and block network and provide better access and circulation for all transportation modes; Improve the relationship of frontages to the public realm through appropriate set backs and edge treatments; Limit hardscaping, increase green system of parks and tree canopy and improve wayfinding; Better balance all modes of travel within the transportation network and improve connectivity including from future ECLRT to periphery of the Golden Mile; and Retain a range of businesses and jobs through transit, service and amenity improvements. PRECEDENTS (SECTION 4) Four precedent case studies were undertaken to examine planning processes and change in contexts similar to the Golden Mile (i.e. lowrise, predominantly retail-focused employment uses along a future transit corridor with policies that are supportive of intensification). Lessons learned from these case studies include: Supporting intensification with a new street and block network, new parks and open spaces and new community infrastructure Utilizing new connections to provide new frontages and consolidate site access. Phasing change with new transit-supportive uses existing side-byside with pre-existing auto-oriented uses. Transitioning a portion of existing uses from employment to mixed use while providing opportunities for intensification of employment uses where these uses are to be maintained. PUBLIC AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT (SECTION 5) The engagement process for Phase 1 of the GMSP Study focused on presenting and seeking feedback on existing conditions, opportunities and constraints and Guiding Principles, building towards the creation of the vision for the future of the Golden Mile. Phase 1 ran from June - December 2017 and involved a series of different meetings, including in sequence: Community Consultation Meeting 1 - Study Launch (June 28, 2017) Summer Pop Up Events (July-August 2017) Moving Conversations Walking Tour (September 25, 2017) Local Advisory Committee (LAC) Meeting 1 (September 28, 2017) Community Consultation Meeting 2 - Visioning Workshop (October 14, 2017) Many participants were engaged through these meetings (see below table for a detailed breakdown). Events Number of Participants Community Consultation Meeting #1 140 + & Study Launch Moving Conversation #1 (with LAC 12 members) Local Advisory Committee Meeting #1 25 Pop-up Events (3) 100 + Travel Survey 143 Community Consultation Meeting #2 35 + Visioning Workshop 9

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY VISION AND PRINCIPLES (SECTION 6) The development of a Vision for the Golden Mile ultimately starts with the drivers of change and the analysis of existing conditions, opportunities and constraints organized by the five building blocks. This analysis was informed by and tested with stakeholders and members of the public through engagement sessions. This analysis, shaped by participant input, was then distilled into what is working well, what could be improved, and what does this mean for the future of the Golden Mile. These key findings formed the basis of the Draft Guiding Principles, which seek to promote what is working well and establish a base for improvements. Lastly, the Draft Vision synthesizes the Draft Guiding Principles into a statement that can serve as a touchstone around which planning and development decisions can be made with respect to the Golden Mile. The four Draft Guiding Principles are as follows: 1. Towards a Complete Community Golden Mile will be a liveable, vibrant neighbourhood with a balance of development and open spaces, diverse mix of housing types, different scales of retail, and a range of employment uses while retaining its historical identity as a commercial retail centre in the region. 2. Towards a Connected Community Golden Mile will offer improved connections for all modes of travel, providing enhanced travelling experience as well as safety for all users of the street. It will be an accessible, green and pedestrian-friendly area for residents, businesses, and visitors. 3. Towards a Responsive Community Golden Mile will be flexible, responsive, and resilient to the changing needs of the community. It will have the basis to provide wide range of facilities, services, and programs that suits the diverse neighbourhood while anticipating and accommodating change over time. 4. Towards a Prosperous Community Golden Mile will provide an opportunity for prosperity for all. It will have enhanced competitiveness of the existing employment, while providing opportunity for new types of businesses to grow and flourish. These Draft Guiding Principles were then synthesized into a Draft Vision statement that can serve as a touchstone around which planning and development decisions can be made with respect to the Golden Mile. The Draft Vision for the Golden Mile is as follows: The Vision for the Golden Mile is for a connected, accessible and diverse mixed-use community that is a place of economic and social activity throughout the day. A balance of residential, commercial and employment uses is anchored by community services and an improved network of parks and open spaces that invites residents, workers and visitors to explore and interact within its neighbourhoods. Immediately identifiable as a distinct place, the Golden Mile is both a community and a destination, providing for the daily needs of all its residents while also attracting business where people can work and shop, maintaining its role as an important economic driver within the east end of Toronto. NEXT STEPS (SECTION 6) During Phase 1 of the Golden Mile Secondary Plan Study, the following elements were defined and analyzed: building blocks, drivers of change, existing conditions, and constraints and opportunities. These helped to form the Draft Guiding Principles and Vision. In conjunction with public 10

BACKGROUND REPORT and stakeholder feedback, the Vision and Principles will help create and differentiate development alternatives to be prepared in Phase 2 of the GMSP Study (see graphic below). Phase 2 will also provide an opportunity to examine and potentially refine the GMSP Study Area. Each development alternative will follow the Guiding Principles, but highlight or focus on different mix of opportunities to provide a variety of development alternatives. They will be assessed in terms of: Does it respond to opportunities? Does it realize the vision? Does it meet or exceed the Guiding Principles? Does it perform well according to the criteria? In addition to the above, a set of qualitative and quantitative criteria will be developed to measure the performance of each alternative. The public and stakeholder groups will provide feedback on these criteria and alternatives, which will then be used to refine the alternatives and establish the final recommended alternative. Process from Phase 1 to Phase 2 11

1.0 INTRODUCTION

BACKGROUND REPORT 1.1 Report Structure This Report presents Phase 1 findings of the Golden Mile Secondary Plan (GMSP) Study. The Report includes the following sections: Section 1: Provides an introduction to the Study, the Study Team, the Study Area and the Study Approach; Section 2: Provides an overview of what is driving change in the region and within the Golden Mile; Section 3: Describes opportunities and constraints within the Golden Mile and their importance to the future of Golden Mile; Section 4: Includes a summary review of different precedents that are experiencing similar drivers of change to the Golden Mile; Section 5: Provides an overview and summary of feedback from the engagement process to date; Section 6: Identifies the emerging Vision and Principles formulated through engagement and analysis to date; Four separate sub-studies inform the findings of the Report and are included as Appendices: A. Transportation Master Plan Existing Conditions Report B. Master Servicing Plan Study Existing Conditions Assessment Technical Memo C. Community Infrastructure Strategy Existing Conditions Report D. Community Infrastructure Strategy Focus Group Summary E. Market Analysis & Economic Strategy F. Engagement Summaries 1.2 Introduction to the Study SvN Architects + Planners was retained by City of Toronto City Planning, Community Planning (Scarborough District) to undertake the Golden Mile Secondary Plan Study (GMSP Study). The GMSP Study is to develop a vision and planning framework for a complete community for the Golden Mile area along Eglinton Avenue East between Victoria Park Avenue and Birchmount Road. The vision and comprehensive planning framework will form the foundation of and recommendations for a Golden Mile Secondary Plan, Urban Design Guidelines, Conceptual Master Plan, Community Infrastructure Strategy, Transportation Master Plan, Master Servicing Plan, Parks, Open Space and Public Realm Strategy and other strategies and planning tools. The vision and planning framework will demonstrate how the area can be redeveloped to allow for the creation of a finer grain of public streets and blocks to support, improve and expand the public realm, and provide amenities including parks and open spaces for employees and residents within the Study Area. Furthermore the vision and planning framework will demonstrate opportunities for mixed use development and encourage new employment and office development as well as amenities within the Study Area to support the planned Eglinton Crosstown Light Rail Transit (ECLRT). The Study will provide direction on appropriate built form and densities that respect and do not negatively impact adjacent Neighbourhoods, and Apartment Neighbourhoods and Parks and Open Space areas. The Study will review community infrastructure, servicing, transportation, built form and public realm relationships and synergies across all users and uses within the Study Area. Four distinct sub-studies will be incorporated in the development of the planning framework, including a Transportation Master Plan Study, Master Servicing Plan 13

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY Study, Community Infrastructure Strategy, and Market Analysis & Economic Strategy. The planning framework will build upon the recently completed Market Analysis and Economic Strategy. Local Advisory Committee & Community City of Toronto The consultant team is lead by SvN Architects + Planners along with HDR, Canadian Urban Institute, Cole Engineering, Workshop Architecture, and Swerhun Facilitation. The consultant team along with the City of Toronto Project Management Team reviews technical analysis and findings through the City of Toronto Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) and the community representative Local Advisory Committee (LAC) (see Figure 1). SvN Architects + Planners Land Use & Urban Design Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) City of Toronto Project Management Team (PMT) Workshop Architecture Public Art & Heritage Expression The Study is to be conducted over three phases as follows: Phase 1: Background Analysis, Consultation and Visioning which involves Study Commencement (including Municipal Environmental Assessment (EA) requirements), Public Outreach, Opportunity and Constraint Analysis, and Visioning; Phase 2: Design Analysis and Alternative Solutions involves identification, analysis and testing of design alternatives, selection of a preferred alternative and public outreach of the same (including Municipal Class EA requirements); and Phase 3: Final Design and Plan Development involving refinement of the preferred alternative, preparation of the final design and plan, and completion of the final Secondary Plan Study Report. Figure 1 HDR Transportation Planning Project team Cole Engineering Municipal Servicing SvN Consultant Team Lead Canadian Urban Institute Community Infrastructure Swerhun Facilitation Public & Stakeholder Engagement 14

BACKGROUND REPORT 1.3 Study Area 5.5km 1h 11 min The GMSP Study Area comprises 102 hectares of land and is generally defined by Ashtonbee Road to the north, Birchmount Road to the east, Civic Road / Alvinston Road to the south, and Victoria Park Avenue to the east (see Figure 2). Don Valley Pkwy Victoria Park Ave Warden Ave Birchmount Rd Kennedy Rd Midland Ave Lawrence Ave E Brimley Rd The area of Transportation Master Plan (TMP) Study is 2,067 hectares, bounded by Lawrence Avenue East to the north, Midland Avenue / Eglinton Avenue East / the CNR corridor / Danforth Road to the east, St. Clair Avenue East to the south, and the East Don Valley to the west. 2.1km 26min 4.6km 49min Eglinton Ave E Danforth Rd The area of Community Infrastructure Strategy (CIS) Study is 1,589 hectares, with its Boundary generally aligning with the TMP Boundary, with the exception of areas east of Kennedy Road and west of Victoria Park Avenue being removed. O'Connor Dr Transportation Master Plan (TMP) Boundary Community Infrastructure Strategy (CIS) Boundary Golden Mile Secondary Plan (GMSP) Study Area St Clair Ave E 0 0.25 0.5 1.0 km Figure 2 Study boundaries The three boundaries are shown in Figure 2, with the TMP Boundary and CIS Boundary being significantly broader than the GMSP Study Area. 15

GOLDEN MILE SECONDARY PLAN STUDY 1.4 Study Approach The GMSP Study will result in the development of a vision and planning framework that is based upon an analysis of land use, the development of a Conceptual Master Plan, Transportation Master Plan, Master Servicing Plan and the development of strategies respecting: parks and open space; streets and blocks; built form; streetscape and pedestrian amenities; public art/heritage expression; and community infrastructure. To develop this comprehensive vision and planning framework, SvN has identified five building blocks that are both derived from and align with the Study s objectives. The five building blocks will be used as the basis of the Study. Within each building block, existing conditions, opportunities and constraints will be assessed to inform an understanding of the Study Area. The transportation and servicing building blocks will fulfill the Municipal Class EA requirements. Furthermore, the Study brings forward a number of interrelated points of analysis and synthesis, including projected future growth and growth policy, opportunities and constraints, and a series of Guiding Principles that combined inform a Vision for Change (see Figure 3). The Vision and Guiding Principles will inform an evaluation framework which in turn will be used to assess alternative future scenarios. The Vision and Guiding Principles will also ultimately drive the preparation of the Secondary Plan, based on the selection of a Preferred Alternative. Feedback from the public, including residents, landowners, business owners, employees and consumers of the Golden Mile, will be a key part throughout the entire process, shaping and refining the Vision, Guiding Principles, and the Preferred Alternative. The five Building Blocks are as follows: Land Use / Urban Design Land use and density Built form and streetscapes Parks, open space and public realm Public art and heritage Assess redevelopment potential and examine highest and best use Identify a conceptual master plan, policy and planning tools Transportation Pedestrian, bicycle, transit and automobile networks Streets and blocks Assess transportation network alternatives, proposed streets and blocks Identify a preferred network (and satisfy phases 1 and 2 of the Municipal Class EA) Servicing Comprised of water, stormwater, wastewater infrastructure networks Assess bottlenecks and constraints within the network Identify network improvements Community Infrastructure Schools, libraries, community recreation centres, child care centres, etc. and human service agencies Assess neighbourhood demand and constraints for facilities and human service agencies Identify community infrastructure needs and opportunities to support future growth Economy Economic and employment conditions Current building stock and employment uses Land holdings and lease information Determine viability of the area as an employment generator Identify economic strategy to enhance / attract employment 16

BACKGROUND REPORT Building Blocks Drivers of Change Opportunities & Constraints Guiding Principles Land Use/ Urban Design Policy Growth Investment Finer street and block framework shop Need to prioritize appropriate uses within land available Complete Community Transportation Expected population and employment increase Transit Oriented Development Transitions between different uses Connected Community Vision Community Infrastructure Transportation network being built on Eglinton and the Region Safer travel for all modes Car-oriented environment Responsive Community Servicing Improved public realm What makes the Golden Mile special? Prosperous Community Economy Affordable housing Enhanced employment Public & Stakeholder Engagement Residents Landowners Business Owners Employees & Consumers Figure 3 Process towards a vision The five building blocks are derived from the different disciplinary ares of the GMSP Study and are used to organize the analysis of existing conditions. Once the conditions have been identified, various Drivers of Change are studied - these include changes in both municipal and provincial policies, current and projected growth, and investment. Using the results of the existing conditions analysis and review of drivers of change, opportunities and constraints unique to the Golden Mile were discerned. These form the Guiding Principles and the Vision, which will feed into the development alternatives. 17