A TWENTY YEAR PLAN (and visionary guide) TO RESTORE NAPLES BAY Michael R. Bauer, Ph.D. Natural Resources Manager City of Naples
City of Naples Natural Resources Division Management Science Restoration Outreach
Naples Bay Watershed 10 square miles 120 square miles
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Salinity in Naples Bay Salinity Naples Bay 2006-2009 GORDPK NBAY13 NBAY29 NBAYBV NBAYCC NBAYHC NBAYLLO NBAYNL SEPT 09 NOV 09 MAY 09 JULY 09 MAR 09 SEPT 07 NOV 07 JAN 08 MAR 08 MAY 08 JULY 08 SEPT 08 NOV 08 JAN 09 Salinity Naples Bay 2005-2009 MAY 07 JULY 07 JAN 07 MAR 07 NOV 06 JULY 06 SEPT 06 MAR 06 MAY 06 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 GORDJOE GORDPT GPASS6 NBAY21 NBAY33 NBAYKF NBAYTC NBAYWS OCT 09 JUNE 09 FEB 09 DEC 06 APR 07 AUG 07 DEC 07 JUNE 08 OCT 08 AUG 06 FEB 06 OCT 05 JUN 05 FEB 05 Salinity (ppt t) Salinity (ppt) )
Historic Habitat Comparison Pre Development (1950 s) Seagrass: approx. 68 acres (27 ha) Oyster beds: approx. 51 acres (21 ha) Post Development (2005) Seagrass: approx. 4 acres (2 ha) Seagrass only in lower region Oyster beds: approx. 12 acres (5 ha)
RESTORATION EFFORTS Water quantity Water quality Oysters Mangroves Seagrasses
TIME Current Efforts: Actions and Accomplishments Five years from now: The Results Ten years from now: The Critical Point Twenty years from now: The Legacy
Golden Gate Canal Diversions 200 mgd Henderson Creek
Five Years From Now: THE RESULTS One third of Golden Gate Canal water diverted to Henderson Creek. City s ASR well reduces flows another 10%.
Ten Years From Now: THE CRITICAL POINT Marco Island ASR takes another 10% of the flow. Water reaching bay reduced to 50% of current tlevels. l
Twenty Years From Now: THE LEGACY Golden Gate Canal water diverted south to Belle Meade area. Water influx to Naples Bay matches pre- development levels. l
Total Phosphorous Naples Bay Total Phosphorous Naples Bay 2005-2009 2009 0.16 0.14 0.12 01 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 0 GORDPK NBAY13 NBAY29 NBAYBV NBAYCC NBAYHC NBAYLLO NBAYNL Screening Level OCT 09 NOV 09 MAR 06 MAY 06 JULY 06 SEPT 06 NOV 06 JAN 07 MAR 07 MAY 07 JULY 07 SEPT 07 NOV 07 JAN 08 MAR 08 MAY 08 JULY 08 SEPT 08 NOV 08 JAN 09 MAR 09 MAY 09 JULY 09 SEPT 09 Total Phosphorous Naples Bay 2005-2009 0.18 GORDJOE GORDPK GORDPT GPASS6 NBAY21 NBAY33 0.16 0.14 012 0.12 0.1 0.08 0.06 0.04 0.02 NBAYKF NBAYTC NBAYWS Screening Level TS Fay DEC 08 FEB 09 APR 09 JUNE 09 AUG 09 0 FEB 05 APR 05 JUN 05 AUG 05 OCT 05 DEC 05 FEB 06 JUN 06 AUG 06 OCT 06 DEC 06 FEB 07 APR 07 JUNE 07 AUG 07 OCT 07 DEC 07 FEB 08 APR 08 JUNE 08 AUG 08 OCT 08 TP m g/l TP mg /l
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 1 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Total Nitrogen in Naples Bay Total Nitrogen Naples Bay 2006-2009 GORDJOE GORDPT GPASS6 NBAY21 NBAY33 NBAYKF NBAYTC NBAYWS Screening Level OCT T09 E 09 OCT 0 07 FEB B08 JUNE 08 OCT T08 FEB 0 09 JUNE Total Nitrogen Naples Bay 2006-2009 E 07 JUNE FEB B07 OCT 0 06 JUN 0 06 2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 GORDPK NBAY13 NBAY29 NBAYBV NBAYCC NBAYHC NBAYLLO NBAYNL Screening Level NOV 09 JULY 09 JULY 07 NOV 07 MAR 08 JULY 08 NOV 08 MAR 09 MAR 07 NOV 06 JULY 06 MAR 06 TN (mg/l) TN (mg/l)
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Chlorophyll a in Naples Bay Chlorophyll a Naples Bay 2005-2009 GORDJOE GORDPK GORDPT NBAYKF NBAYTC GPASS6 NBAY21 NBAY33 NBAYWS Annual Mean TS Fay DEC 08 FEB 09 APR 09 JUNE 09 AUG 09 OCT 09 OCT 08 JUNE 05 AUG 05 OCT 05 DEC 05 JUNE 06 AUG 06 OCT 06 DEC 06 FEB 07 APR 07 JUNE 07 AUG 07 OCT 07 DEC 07 FEB 08 APR 08 JUNE 08 AUG 08 Chlorophyll a Naples Bay 2006-2009 APR 05 FEB 05 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 GORDPK NBAY13 NBAY29 NBAYBV NBAYCC NBAYHC NBAYLLO NBAYNL A lm Otli Outlier NBAYCC 113 ug / l Algae Bloom 92 ug/l Chl a (ug/l) Chl a (ug/l l)
Result (cfu/10 00ml) Fecal Coliform 2005-2006 Naples Bay 600 GORDJOE Upper GR GORDPK GORDPT 500 GPASS6 400 300 200 Start of Rainy Season Just S of City Dock and Naples Yacht Club NBAY21 NBAY33 NBAYKF NBAYTC NBAYWS State Standard=800 Fecal Coliform 100 0 Fecal Coliform 2006 FEB 05 APR JUNE AUG OCT 05 DEC FEB 06 JUNE 250 AUG OCT 06 DEC Naples Bay 05 05 05 05 06 06 06 Shall not exceed 800 cfu/100ml in one day No more than 10% of samples exceeding 43 cfu/100 ml Result (cfu/10 00ml) 200 150 100 Naples Landing and SW outfall Lantern Lake Outfall GORDPK NBAY13 NBAY29 NBAYBV NBAYCC NBAYHC NBAYLLO NBAYNL 2005 39% exceeded 43 2006 27% exceeded 43 50 0 MAR 06 MAY 06 JULY 06 SEPT 06 NOV 06
10.00 9.00 8.00 7.00 6.00 5.00 4.00 3.00 2.00 1.00 0.00 Copper in Naples Bay Copper Naples Bay 2005-2009 2009 GORDJOE GORDPK GORDPT GPASS6 NBAY21 NBAY33 NBAYTC NBAYWS State standard NBAYKF FEB 06 JUN 06 AUG 06 OCT 06 DEC 06 FEB 07 APR 07 JUNE 07 AUG 07 OCT 07 DEC 07 FEB 08 APR 08 JUNE 08 AUG 08 OCT 08 DEC 08 FEB 09 APR 09 JUNE 09 AUG 09 OCT 09 Copper Naples Bay 2006-2009 OCT 05 DEC 05 AUG 05 JUN 05 FEB 05 APR 05 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 GORDPK NBAY13 NBAY29 NBAYCC NBAYHC NBAYLLO NBAYNL State Standard NBAYBV MAR 07 MAY 07 JULY 07 SEPT 07 NOV 07 JAN 08 MAR 08 MAY 08 JULY 08 SEPT 08 NOV 08 JAN 09 MAR 09 MAY 09 JULY 09 SEPT 09 NOV 09 NOV 06 JAN 07 SEPT 06 JULY 06 MAY 06 Copper (ug/l) Copper (ug/l)
WHAT IS A RAIN GARDEN? A landscaping feature planted with native perennial plants Used to manage stormwater t runoff from impervious surfaces Roofs, sidewalks, and parking lots
New Landscape/Fertilizer Ordinance Landscape City Certification For landscape professionals Learn BMPs for fertilization, pesticides, irrigation, plant selection Environmental component Become City-Certified
Five Years From Now: THE RESULTS Floating islands and aerators are located in 10 of the City s lakes. Outreach Coordinator working with residents To build rain gardens. To plant shorelines Water quality of the bay is improving and Water quality of the bay is improving and healthy habitat is increasing.
Ten Years From Now: THE CRITICAL POINT Two new filter marshes: Broad Avenue South Goodlette Frank Road. Goal of 1,000 rain gardens attained. Spring Lake dredged d d - Plan to dredge d remainder. Most lakes have aerators and floating islands. Shorelines have native wetland vegetation. ti Residents are beginning to replace sod with native vegetation. ti Stormwater runoff has declined by 50% Irrigation use is down by 30% The bay meets all state standards -- unimpaired.
Twenty Years From Now: THE LEGACY All City lakes have been dredged. Lakes are full of wetland vegetation. Yards are native plant gardens. Stormwater runoff captured in yards and swales. No fertilizer needed: compost and mulch. Filter marshes and swales have replaced pipes. Naples Bay is fishable and swimmable.
Historic Habitat Comparison Pre Development (1950 s) Seagrass: approx. 68 acres (27 ha) Oyster beds: approx. 51 acres (21 ha) Post Development (2005) Seagrass: approx. 4 acres (2 ha) Seagrass only in lower region Oyster beds: approx. 12 acres (5 ha)
Five Years From Now: THE RESULTS Oyster reefs have expanded to the north Fi tifi i l t f h b Five new artificial oyster reefs have been created and seeded by oyster farmers
Ten Years From Now: THE CRITICAL POINT Oyster reefs have increased to 50% of pre-development level. Healthy, diverse ecosystem in and around oyster reefs.
Twenty Years From Now: THE LEGACY The bay s oysters are edible. Licenses are available for seasonal harvesting. Naples Bay oysters are featured on the p y y menus of local restaurants.
Riprap p and Seawalls
Habitat restoration in your backyard
RIPRAP An Environmentally Friendly Alternative ti to Seawalls
2. RESTORATION
Five Years From Now: THE RESULTS Outreach program established educating about mangroves how to plant and trim. Bayview Park is lined with mangroves Gordon River shoal island restored Residents replacing seawalls with riprap
Ten Years From Now: THE CRITICAL POINT No new seawalls permitted. Outreach program has homeowners voluntarily planting mangroves. More than half the bay is now lined with y mangroves.
Twenty Years From Now: THE LEGACY Mangroves line the shores of Naples Bay. All private properties have mangrove fringes with unobstructed views of the bay Piers coexist with mangroves, extending through and beyond mangrove fringes Residents catch fresh fish for dinner along Residents catch fresh fish for dinner along their mangrove shorelines.
A single acre of seagrass Can produce 10 tons of leaves Support 4,000 fish and 50,000,000 invertebrates Provide food, habitat, and nursery grounds
Five Years From Now: THE RESULTS Golden Gate Canal diversions lower salinity and seagrasses expand. A new seagrass bed has become established north of Bayview Park.
Ten Years From Now: THE CRITICAL POINT Bayview bed has merged with new one. Two successful seagrass beds planted.
Twenty Years From Now: THE LEGACY Seagrass beds exist all the way to US 41 bridge. Dense beds of multiple species found at Windstar, Bayview Park, south end of Port Royal, and Cowpens area.
Bathymetric Mapping
Five Years From Now: THE RESULTS Required mitigation provides funds and materials for habitat islands. First island built in the southeastern part of bay.
Ten Years From Now: THE CRITICAL POINT Five small habitat islands built on southeast side of bay. The Naples Bay Habitat Islands are favorite close-in fishing spots. Shorebird nesting occurs on islands.
Twenty Years From Now: THE LEGACY Naples Bay Habitat Islands support nesting shorebirds and edible oysters. Seagrass beds have formed behind them. Islands provide environmental education p and recreation -- an urban access point to the wild.
CONCLUSIONS Twenty years from now, Naples Bay will look quite different than it does today A nonobstructing, low-lying mangrove fringe lines the bay. Small islands, oyster bars, and fishing boats dot its surface. Seagrasses visibly sway in the current. Fish jump and dolphins play in the Gordon River. Locals and visitors sample the local oysters at waterfront restaurants. The State of Florida uses Naples Bay as an example to other municipalities. The people of Naples take great pride in their bay and its The people of Naples take great pride in their bay and its restoration.