CRTPO Bicycle & Pedestrian Project Costs Panel Discussion Introductions & Purpose By. Curtis Bridges CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
CRTPO Bicycle & Pedestrian Project Costs CRTPO Funding Sources How can local agencies benefit? Alternatives Program (TAP) o $3.6 Million allocated in 2016 o $2.4 Million allocated bi-annually beginning in 2017 Surface Directly Attributable (STP-DA) o $27.9 Million currently available o $15.4 Million annually Congestion Mitigation & Air Quality (CMAQ) o $7.5 Million in both FY 2016 & 2017 CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
CRTPO Bicycle & Pedestrian Project Costs Panel Discussion Greenway Elements & Costs Right-of-Way, Easement, & Property Owners By. Gwen Cook & Jay Higginbotham CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
Greenways Typical Greenways Sub-urban Trail Torrence Creek Greenway Predominately asphalt, and often follow riparian corridors with sewer lines 10 min. width, 12 preferred Mowed grass shoulders Urban Trail Little Sugar Creek Greenway Combination of asphalt and concrete. Width varies, preferred 14 min. Often includes more park-like amenities
Greenways Typical Creek Crossing Fiberglass Bike/Ped Bridge Reedy Creek Greenway 6-8 wide, light weight, modular, site assembled, typically 100 psf ped loading Cost: $1,200 per LF Prefabricated Steel Bike/Ped Bridge Clarks Creek Greenway Cor-ten steel, fully assembled off site, low maintenance, 5-20 ton loading Cost: $1,500-$2,500 per LF Suspension Bike/Ped Bridge Neuse River Greenway Steel/concrete construction, Site built, great for long spans Cost: High
Greenways Typical Low Water/Swale Crossing Wooden Swale Bridge Irwin Creek Greenway Used for short spans over shallow swales. Built on site. Light duty. Cost: $5,000-$7,000 Wooden Ped Bridge with Rails Reedy Creek Greenway Used for deeper channels. Built on site. Ped rated only. Cost: $800 per LF Concrete Low Water/Swale Bridge Irwin Creek Greenway Typically 10 wide, 10 long. Poured in place. 5 ton loading. Cost: $7000- $12,000
Greenways Typical Wetlands Crossing Wood Boardwalk 4 Mile Creek Greenway, near Rea Rd. 10-12 wide, 100 PSF to 5 ton rating, max 30 off ground below. Cost: $250-$400 per LF Wood Boardwalk w/ Rails 4 Mile Creek Greenway, Matthews 10-12 clear width, 100 PSF to 5 ton rating Cost: $400-$500 per LF Concrete Boardwalk Connector at Streets of Torringdon 10-12 wide, 5 ton rated, can be wood, concrete or steel substructure. Cost: $500-$700 per LF
Greenways Roadway Underpasses Toby Creek @ Harris Blvd Torrence @ Gilead Bridge/Roadway Underpass Toby Creek Little Sugar Creek Culverts Costs vary widely depending on site specifics. Often require local or NCDOT encroachment agreements Typically poured in place concrete (for durability) Typically subject to frequent flooding Typically subject to wetland, flood plain, and water quality permitting Typically have poor construction access and overhead obstructions.
Greenways Trailheads & Neighborhood Accesses Neighborhood Connections Typical cul-de-sac Direct connection with sidewalk or streets 8-10 wide with fence and landscaping Cost: $50,000 Trailhead w/parking 4-Mile @ Bevington Typically 40 spaces +/- Light duty asphalt Cost: $200,000-$250,000 Trailhead w/ Restroom & Parking 4-Mile @ Johnston Rd. 40-60 spaces Small restroom building with water fountains Cost: $500,000-$600,000
Greenways Special Constraints Land Acquisition Can be very time consuming Easement vs. Fee Simple Potential Impact: Project delays, disconnections in the system Permitting USACE, SWIM buffer, FEMA Floodplain Development permits Potential Impact: Delays and added expense Budget Constraints Hard to estimate projects Limited number of qualified contractors Volatile bidding atmosphere Potential Impact: Delays and added cost
Greenways Special Constraints Construction Access Utilities Weather Impacts Narrow site corridors with limited road frontage Streams, wetland, poor soils Limited points of entry Water Mains, Sewer Lines and Structures PNG Gas lines Duke Transmission Low lying, Poorly drained sites Seasonal constraints (asphalt and concrete install)
Greenways Special Constraints Historic Features Cemetery at Clark s Creek Greenway Cemeteries Historic Structures Potential Impact: re-design, rerouting of trail, added expense Wetlands 4 Mile Creek Greenway Added design, permitting, and construction costs. Potential Impact: Permitting delays, added project expense Endangered/Threatened Species Mecklenburg County Probable/Potential Mandated protection of threatened species (Northern long-eared bat). Potential Impact: Schedule impacts due to clearing restrictions.
Greenway Under Construction Toby Creek Greenway, Phase 2 Rocky River Rd to Hwy. 49 1.5 Miles (To be Completed Feb. 2017) Funded by a CMAQ Grant with City & County match Design: $250,000 Construction: $2,700,000 CEI: $225,000 Total Cost: $3,175,000
Planned Greenways Cost Breakdown Creek/ Corridor Stewart Creek Greenway McAlpine Creek Greenway Section/ Description Rozzelles Ferry Rd to State St Green Rea Rd to Johnston Miles per Polaris New Gwy Miles (10% added) Base Cost (1 mile trail, 1 bridge, 1 swale bridge, 2 nbhd entr, permitting) $1.5 M Wayfinding ($25,000 per mile; $5,000 ea. Add'l mile) Extra Bridges ($150K avg; $80K under 100'; $300K over 100') Mecklenburg County Greenways: Cost Analysis Parking Lot (50 cars) ($200K) Restr'm ($350K) Underpass ($100K - $500K) Mitigation ($50K min.) Railroad (1) Trestle $500K (2)Tunnel $5K/ft (3)Atgrade impr. $1M HAWK Ped Crossing ($100K min.) Pocket Park ($100K) Add'l N'Hood Entrances 500' length ($50K each) Other Cost Const. Cost Contingency (10% of Const. cost) Cost for Federal (30% const cost Design (16%) Total Project Cost 0.7 0.77 1,155,000 25,000 450,000 0 0 200,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 1,830,000 183,000 549,000 292,800 $2,854,800 0.8 0.86 1,287,000 25,000 300,000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 50,000 0 1,662,000 166,200 498,600 265,920 $2,592,720
Sample Greenway Cost Breakdown Creek/ Corridor Sample Creek Greenway Section/ Description ABC Rd to Sample Creek Miles per Polaris New Gwy Miles (10% added) Base Cost (1 mile trail, 1 bridge, 1 swale bridge, 2 nbhd entr, permitting) $1.5 M Wayfinding ($25,000 per mile; $5,000 ea. Add'l mile) Extra Bridges ($150K avg; $80K under 100'; $300K over 100') Mecklenburg County Greenways: Cost Analysis Parking Lot (50 cars) ($200K) Restr'm ($350K) Underpass ($100K - $500K) Mitigation ($50K min.) Railroad (1) Trestle $500K (2)Tunnel $5K/ft (3)Atgrade impr. $1M HAWK Ped Crossing ($100K min.) Pocket Park ($100K) Add'l N'Hood Entrances 500' length ($50K each) Other Cost Const. Cost Contingency (10% of Const. cost) Cost for Federal (30% const cost 0.0 0.00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 $0 Design (16%) Total Project Cost
Questions? Greenway Elements & Costs Right-of-Way, Easement, & Property Owners CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
CRTPO Bicycle & Pedestrian Project Costs Panel Discussion Sidewalk Costs & Pedestrian Crossings By. Dan Leaver CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
Sidewalks Bicycle/Pedestrian Accommodations Sidewalk with Planting Strip Multi-use Path/Widewalk Sidewalk at back of curb 5 minimum width local streets 6 minimum width (thoroughfares) Typically 10 wide or more Asphalt or concrete 6 minimum width Only used in specific conditions
Sidewalk Projects Cost Breakdown Average cost/mile: $1.15M* *Not including outliers in red
Sidewalk & Pedestrian Crossings Examples Pedestrian Beacon Ardrey Kell Road New Sidewalk Colony Road Sidewalk Mid-Block Crossing W. Tyvola Road Description: Ped Hybrid Beacon Cost: $165,000 (0.05 mi.) Description: Colony Rd. Sidewalk (2009-2012) Cost: $267,000 (0.2 mi) Description: Sidewalk gap project with mid-block ped. crossing Cost: $300,000 (0.85 mi.)
Sidewalk/Ped Refuge Cost Breakdown Average cost per mile varies significantly depending on multiple factors Location/Right-of-Way acquisition Utilities Public Involvement
Sidewalk & Pedestrian Crossings Crosswalk Signal / Signage Crosswalk Striping Bike Lanes/Sharrows Cost varies depending on location Typically done with resurfacing program & Capital projects Typically done with resurfacing program & Capital projects
Roads Construction Costs* Two lane road w/ wide shoulders (no curb & gutter) Three lane road w/ curb & gutter, sidewalk & bike lane Five lane road with curb & gutter, sidewalk & bike lane Description: cost per mile Cost: $4,625,000 Description: cost per mile Cost: $5,025,000 Description: cost per mile Cost: $6,925,000 *Construction Cost Only And Does Not Include Any Necessary Right Of Way Or Utility Relocation Costs https://connect.ncdot.gov/projects/bikeped/pages/guidance.aspx
CRTPO Bicycle & Pedestrian Project Costs Panel Discussion Bicycle Facilities, Road Diets, Paint & Striping By. Michael Taylor CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
Pavement Markings Construction Costs Sharrows Plaza Midwood Description: cost per lane mile Cost: $4,000 Green Bike Lanes (Thermoplastic) E 4 th St and College St Description: cost per sf Cost: $12-$20 (city forces or contractor) Bike Box Carson and South Blvd Description: cost per sf Cost: $12-$20 (city forces or contractor)
Road Diet Construction Costs* Restripe roadway (grind existing markings install thermos markings) Description: cost per mile/lane stripe dependent on how many lines changing. Cost: $11,000/stripe/mile Restripe roadway (1.5 mill and overlay existing pavement thermos) Description: cost per lane mile Cost: $100,000 Two way protected bike lanes (cycle track) 12 th Street and Brevard St. Description: cost per mile including bollards Cost: $16,000 - $50,000 *Construction Cost Only And Does Not Include Any Necessary Right Of Way Or Utility Relocation Costs
Separated On-road Bike Facilities Construction Costs Memphis Asheville (Radtip Project) Chattanooga Raleigh (30% Design) Protected Bike Lanes Memphis, Chattanooga, Atlanta, Asheville, Raleigh, Charlotte??? Description: cost per mile/lane stripe dependent buffer treatment/drainage/ surface. Cost: Highly variable and specific per application Atlanta Charlotte Rendering
Bike and Ped Signals Construction Costs* Manual push-buttons $4,000 In-pavement, radio-control $8,000 Magnetometer sensors. $14,000 In-pavement inductive loop $16,000 Video camera $25,000 RRFB Bike Detected Signals Bike Signals Description: cost per each install Cost: $5,000 to $6,000 Description: cost per install Cost: $4,000 - $25,000 Description: cost per each Cost: $2,000 does not include signal timing revision or additional controller needs. *Construction Cost Only And Does Not Include Any Necessary Right Of Way Or Utility Relocation Costs
Questions Sidewalk Costs & Pedestrian Crossings Bicycle Facilities, Road Diets, Paint & Striping CRTPO: Bicycle & Pedestrian Work Group
CRTOP Bike & Pedestrian Project Costs Panel Discussion - October 18, 2016 NEPA Compliance Environmental Documents Derrick Weaver, Programs Management
Minor Projects Programmatic Categorical Exclusion (PCE) Other Laws and Regulations 2
Programmatic Categorical Exclusion Most Locally Administered Projects are categorically excluded from NEPA Document that the project is an approved CE action Perform a level of environmental investigation to verify there is no potential for significant project impacts 3
Other Laws and Regulations Section 4(f) Act Public Areas and Historic Resources Section 106 Historic Act Historic Resources SHPO Concurrence Section 7 Endangered Species Act Federally Protected Species 4
NCDOT Programmatic Categorical Exclusion Action Classification Form 5
Type I Categorical Exclusion Activities Construction of bicycle and pedestrian lanes, paths, and facilities Landscaping Installation of fencing, signs, pavement markings, small passenger shelters, traffic signals, and railroad warning devices Emergency repairs under 23USC 125 (Governor Declared Emergency) Replacement of Guardrail 6
Type II Categorical Exclusion Activities 7
PCE Form continued 8
PCE Form continued Ecological 1. Will the project have a substantial impact on any unique or important natural resource? 2. Does the project involve habitat where federally listed endangered or threatened species may occur? 3. Does the project involve water classified as Outstanding Water Resources (OWR) and/or High Quality Waters (HQW)? 4. Does the project involve any know underground storage tanks (UST s) or hazardous material sites. 9
PCE Form continued Permits and Coordination 1. If the project involves the acquisition of right of way, is the amount of right of way acquisition considered minor? 2. Will the project have an effect on structures /properties eligible for/or listed on the National Register of Historic Places? 10
PCE Form continued 11
PCE Form continued 12
PCE Form continued 13
Major Projects Environmental Assessments/Finding of No Significant Impact Environmental Impact Statements Merger Process Scoping Meetings Public Outreach 14
Common Issues Natural Resources Technical Report Qualified Person Right of Way Permanent and Temporary Early Scoping USFWS, SHPO Preliminary Plans Geotechnical Review Public Involvement Signatures Detailed Descriptions Location Map, Aerial Photo Review Time 15
Early Scoping US Fish and Wildlife Service Marella Buncick marella_buncick@fws.gov NC State Historic Preservation Office Renee Gledhill-Earley renee.gledhill-earley@ncdcr.gov 16
Questions Derrick Weaver dweaver@ncdot.gov 919-707-6601 17
Charlotte Regional Planning Organization October 18, 2016 Locally Administered Projects Overview Marta Matthews NCDOT Local Programs Management Office
Local Programs Management Office What you will learn from this Presentation: Overview of On-Line Local Project Management Tool Major Steps of Administering a Federal-aid Project by a Local Government Agency Typical Challenges Experienced by Locals on Federal-aid Projects 2
Federal-aid Project Delivery by Locals Federal-aid funding is cost-reimbursement Funding Authorization is required prior to each phase of work Local Government Agency (LGA) has the responsibility to deliver the project NCDOT has the responsibility to provide oversight to LGAs and ensure appropriate use of funds 3
Resources https://connect.ncdot.gov/municipalities/funding/pages/default.aspx 4
Resources 5
Navigating NCDOT 6
Local Projects On-Line Project Management Tool 7
Local Projects On-Line Project Management Tool 8
Local Project On-Line Project Management Tool 9
Getting Access to Project Management Tool 10
Local Project On-Line Project Management Tool What Projects are in the New Project Management Tool? Locally-Administered Projects with funding from STP-DA, TAP-DA, or CMAQ through your MPO. What Projects will be managed in the future in the Project Management Tool? Projects funded with TAP funding directly from NCDOT, old SRTS funding, Municipal Bridge funding will be added in a future phase. Locally-Administered Projects with state funding will also be added in a future phase. What Projects are not managed in the Project Management Tool? DOT-let projects, even if LGAs are participating in costs. 11
Local Project On-Line Project Management Tool HELPFUL RESOURCES 12
Project Delivery Major Steps
Pre-Construction Steps (climb the mountain!) Final Plans, Specifications, and Estimate Right of Way Certification Right of Way (ROW) Authorization Right of Way Acquisition (and Utility Relocation) Right of Way Plans / Location & Design Approval Environmental Document Preliminary Engineering (PE) Authorization Procuring Professional Services Agreement Programming (includes Schedule) 14
Construction Steps (another mountain!) Maintenance Final Voucher Date Final Inspection and Project Acceptance Construction Engineering & Inspection Construction Construction (CON) Authorization Bidding, Letting and Awarding Construction Contract 15
Important Items to Remember The following slides illustrate the areas where we see challenges and the need to think ahead about certain issues. 16
Initial Project Idea Before You Ask for Funding Identify project scope from Long-Range Plan, citizen input, etc. Do Your Due Diligence: Environmental Concerns ROW issues Utility relocations Project delivery Budget/Schedule Work with your Division Office Identify funding source (i.e. MPO, NCDOT, etc.) and process for approval/allocation of funds 17
Professional Services All procurement must follow qualifications-based selection. The firm you choose needs to be pre-qualified by DOT in all the work codes listed OR have subs that are pre-qualified. Average length of time to sign a contract with a PEF once funding is authorized? 8 months. City holds the contract with the consultant, not NCDOT. 18
Funding Authorization No costs can be incurred prior to authorization. Certain deliverables need to be complete prior to requesting the authorization. Once funds are authorized, move quickly to incur costs and request reimbursement to keep project active. 19
Right of Way Acquisition All acquisition must follow the Uniform Act, even if you re not receiving reimbursement for Right of Way. Acquisition of Right of Way always takes longer than you think. 20
Contract/Bid Proposal Construction Must use NCDOT Standard Specifications (unless project is one that NCDOT does not have standards for). Construction Be familiar with NCDOT Construction Manual. Ask the Division for assistance in setting up records for consistent documentation. 21
Close-out Be aware of costs that LGA may need to reimburse to NCDOT. Keep all records in a safe place for future audits. 22
Questions or Comments? 23
THANK YOU Marta Matthews Local Programs Management Office 919-707-6626 mtmatthews@ncdot.gov 24