Staff Review Date: June 10, 2015 HDC

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Staff Review Date: June 10, 2015 HDC"

Karen Davidson
5 years ago
Views:

1 Charlotte Historic District Commission Application for a Certificate of Appropriateness Staff Review Date: June 10, 2015 HDC LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT: PROPERTY ADDRESS: SUMMARY OF REQUEST: APPLICANT: Plaza Midwood 1926 The Plaza and 2010 The Plaza Demolition and New Construction Billy Maddalon The application was continued from May for the following items: 1) Traditional building materials, 2) Setback of building #1, 3) Garage orientation on buildings 11-13, 5) Setback and façade design of building 19, 6) No corner boards on cedar siding. Details of Proposed Request Existing Conditions The existing structure at 1926 The Plaza is a one story single family home constructed in Exterior features include two small hipped dormers and a small covered porch on the front. The property at 2010 The Plaza is the Van Landingham Estate, a local historic landmark. The four acre property has two accessory buildings with fairly dense landscaping. Proposal The proposal is a two part request. 1. Demolition of the structure at 1926 The Plaza. 2. New construction of 19 townhomes, a pool, pool house and other site features. a) Ten units are accessed from The Plaza and face the main house. Six units are accessed from Belvedere Avenue and three units face the main house with access from Thurmond Place. b) Maximum roof peak is approximately c) Proposed material palette is wood, Hardie board siding, synthetic wood (trim), brick, stone and copper (porch roof and gutters). d) Roof details include exposed rafter ends and synthetic wood trim. e) The pool and pool house are accessed from Belvedere Avenue and The Plaza. f) Other site features include landscaping, tree planting, a fence and new driveways and walkways. Revised Proposal May 13, Site plan includes a landscaping plan with the revised pool location along The Plaza in the front and side yard. 2. Setbacks (measured from back of curb) along The Plaza is approximately 39, 32 to 33 along Belvedere Avenue and approximately 28 +/- along Thurmond Place. 3. Mechanical units are located internally to the private lots and screened (site plan note). 4. Pool house is a one story structure, traditional materials. 5. Pool deck is decorative concrete or stone. Fencing is decorative aluminum style. 6. Townhouse elevations have been revised, roof pitch changed to 6:12 and height lowered Window details have been revised. 8. Minor changes to fenestration patterns and roof design. 9. Siding materials are brick, stone and wood. Gable material is Hardie-panel. 1

2 Revised Proposal June 10, Primary siding is wood lap with corner boards. 2. The setback along The Plaza increased from approximately 39 to The corner elevation on Belvedere Avenue has additional fenestration and extended porch (sheet D3). 4. Building 12 on Thurmond Avenue Sheet C1 shows a one car garage. The other units have two car garages. Policy & Design Guidelines for Demolition The Commission will make a determination as to whether or not this house is determined to be contributing to the Dilworth Local Historic. With affirmative determination, the Commission can apply up to 365 Day Stay of Demolition. Or if the Commission determines that this property is no longer contributing, then demolition may take place without a delay. 1. No building or structure located within a Local Historic District can be demolished without a Certificate of Appropriateness. 2. The Historic District Commission will evaluate demolition applications to determine if the structure in question contributes to the character of the Local Historic District. If 3. The HDC finds that the structure does not contribute to the character of the district or is unsalvageable, immediate approval of the demolition request may be granted. 4. Should the Historic District Commission find that the structure does contribute to the character of the historic district, the HDC can delay the issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness authorizing demolition for a period not to exceed 365 days, in order to work with the owner to seek alternatives to demolition. 5. When an application for demolition receives a 365-day delay, any consideration of applications for proposed new construction on the same site will be deferred for 90 days. 6. When an application for demolition receives a 365-day delay, the Historic District Commission Staff will seek an alternative to demolition and will contact, within one month of the delay vote, the property owner who has applied for demolition, Historic Charlotte, Inc., and Preservation North Carolina to inform them of the threatened status of the building. 7. A permanent injunction against demolition can be invoked only in cases where a building or structure is certified by the State Historic Preservation Officer as being of statewide significance. 8. Applications for the demolition of dilapidated accessory structures may be eligible for administrative approval. All other demolition applications will be reviewed by the full Commission. 2

9. The maximum delay period for the issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness authorizing demolition shall be reduced by the HDC where the Commission finds that the owner would suffer extreme

3 9. The maximum delay period for the issuance of a Certificate of Appropriateness authorizing demolition shall be reduced by the HDC where the Commission finds that the owner would suffer extreme hardship or be permanently deprived of all beneficial use or return from the property by virtue of the delay. Policy & Design Guidelines for New Construction New construction in Local Historic Districts has an obligation to blend in with the historic character and scale of the Local Historic District in which it is located. Designs for infill projects and other new construction within designated Local Historic Districts must be designed with the surroundings in mind. The Historic District Commission will not specify a particular architectural style or design for new construction projects. The scale, mass and size of a building are often far more important than the decorative details applied. However, well designed stylistic and decorative elements, as well as building materials and landscaping, can give new construction projects the attributes necessary to blend in with the district, while creating a distinctive character for the building. New construction projects in Local Historic Districts must be appropriate to their surroundings. The Historic District Commission will review the building details for all new construction as part of their evaluation of new construction project proposals. Policy & Design Guidelines Accessory Buildings (Other Accessory Buildings), page Accessory buildings cannot be located in front or side yards. 2. Accessory buildings that are visible from the street must be constructed using materials and finishes that are in keeping with the main building they serve, and that are appropriate to the district. 3. Designs for accessory buildings must be inspired by the main building they serve. Building details must be derived from the main structure. 4. Accessory buildings and their placement must be of a proper scale in relation to the main structure on a lot, and to structures on surrounding properties. 5. Prefabricated accessory buildings can be used only in locations where they will not be substantially visible from any street or when they are judged to be appropriate to the site. 6. The HDC will give special consideration to the installation of accessory buildings in non-residential uses. 3

4 7. Doors of accessory buildings that are substantially visible front any street must be of a style and materials that are appropriate to the building and the district. Stamped metal and vinyl doors are considered to be inappropriate, and are discouraged. Staff Analysis 1. The Commission will determine if the 365-Day Stay of Demolition should be applied. 2. The Commission will determine if the proposal meets the guidelines for new construction. 4

5 Charlotte Historic District Commission - Case Historic District; Plaza-Midwood Mimosa Av Mimosa Av Belvedere Av Belvadere Av Belvadere Av Kennon St Thomas Av The Plaza Thurmond Pl Belle Terre Av Haywood Ct Chestnut Av Chestnut Av Belle Terre Av The Plaza Thomas Av Belle Terre Av Nassau Bv Thurmond Pl!I Feet Map Printdate; Jan.; The Plaza Plaza Midwood Local Historic District Property Lines Building Footprints

8 Shaping the Environment Realizing the Possibilities Land Planning + Landscape Architecture + Civil Engineering + Urban Design 1717 BELVEDER AVE THE PLAZA 1945 THURMOND PL THE PLAZA 200 South Tryon Street, Suite 1400 Charlotte, North Carolina p f url+ SITE BILLY MADDALON 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina BELVEDER AVE THE PLAZA 1954 THURMOND PL. VANLANDINGHAM ESTATE 2031 THE PLAZA 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina SITE CONTEXT 1729 BELVEDER AVE THE PLAZA 2001 THE PLAZA SITE CONTEXT & PHOTOGRAPHS 2037 THE PLAZA Project No Issued Revised 1733 BELVEDER AVE THE PLAZA 2009 THE PLAZA 2100 THE PLAZA 1801 BELVEDER AVE NASSAU BLVD 2015 THE PLAZA 2101 THE PLAZA ADJOINING PROPERTIES HDC-100 The drawings, the project manual and the design shown theron are instruments of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A.. The reproduction or unauthorized use of the documents without consent of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A. is prohibited. ColeJenest & Stone, P.A c 1900 BELVEDER AVE NASSAUBLVD 2021 THE PLAZA 2107 THE PLAZA

9 NASSAU BOULEVARD THURMOND PLACE THE PLAZA LOT 5 [][] 15' ALLEY PIN: DONALD R RAWLINS KILEY R RAWLINS 2100 THE PLAZA. DB: PG: 915 PIN: LAURE BELL CHARLES M HEIDEL, JR BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 962 PIN: JEFFERY E BRANTNER 1725 BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 958 PIN: IAN C. MUIR JULE S CHAN-MUIR 1729 BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 272 BELVEDERE AVENUE Shaping the Environment Realizing the Possibilities EN IN 9 2 Land Planning + Landscape Architecture + Civil Engineering + Urban Design 200 South Tryon Street, Suite 1400 Charlotte, North Carolina N p f url+ LOT 8 LOT 9 [] [] [] [] LOT 7 [] FP [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] 3 4 POOL HOUSE [] EXISTING ESTATE 7 3 EXISTING ORANGERIE 4 1 EXISTING OFFICE EXISTING CARRIAGE HOUSE PIN: KRISTINE MARIE SICKELS 1800 BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 306 PIN: LAVERNE LIBBY STONE 2711 CANVASBACK TL. MYRTLE BEACH, SC DB: PG: 849 DEVELOPMENT SUMMARY PETITIONER: PROPERTY OWNER: TOTAL SITE AREA: TAX PARCEL #: EXISTING USE: PROPOSED USE: NUMBER OF UNITS: MINIMUM SETBACK: CLOSEST RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE TO: BELVEDERE AVE: THURMOND PL: THE PLAZA: LOT COVERAGE: TOTAL TREES REMOVED: HDC NOTES BILLY MADDALON 2010 THE PLAZA BILLY MADDALON 2010 THE PLAZA TOTAL: AC A B HOTEL/ SINGLE FAMILY DETACHED HOTEL/ SINGLE FAMILY ATTACHED 19 NEW SINGLE FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS. 1 EXISTING HOTEL/ EVENT FACILITY EXISTING RIGHT-OF-WAY OR 14' FROM BACK OF CURB, WHICH EVER IS GREATER ' LF 28.69' LF 39.37' LF (TO FIRE WALL) 41.4% (THIS CALCULATION INCLUDES EXISTING AND PROPOSED BUILD UPON AREA) 55 TREE GREATER THAN 6" DBH (SEE NOTE 1 SHEET HDC-200) 1. THE PETITIONER SHALL REPLANT A MINIMUM OF 30% OF THE TOTAL TREE DENSITY BEING REMOVED DUE TO CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITY ON SITE. 2. LANDSCAPE SCREENING TO BE PROVIDED ON SITE SHALL COMPLEMENT EXISTING VEGETATION. LANDSCAPE SCREENING SHALL INCLUDE, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO; HEMLOCK, YEW, AMERICAN BOXWOOD, TEA OLIVE, RHODODENDRON, AZALEA, AMERICAN HOLLY, INKBERRY HOLLY, YAUPON HOLLY, DWARF YAUPON HOLLY, MAGNOLIA, CRYPTOMERIA, PODOCARPUS & ARBORVITAE. 3. ALL BACKFLOW PREVENTORS SHALL BE SCREENED FROM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY. FINAL LOCATIONS TO BE DETERMINED DURING CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS PHASE, IN COORDINATION WITH CHARLOTTE WATER. SEE SHEET HDC-100 FOR ADJACENT PROPERTY CONTEXT SEE SHEET HDC-300 FOR CONTEXTUAL SETBACKS & BUILDING HEIGHT EXHIBIT SEE SHEET HDC-300 FOR TREE REMOVAL EXHIBIT BILLY MADDALON 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina VANLANDINGHAM ESTATE 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina DIMENSIONAL SITE PLAN Project No Issued Revised LOT 6 4. ALL MECHANICAL UNITS SHALL BE LOCATED INTERNALLY TO THE PRIVATE LOTS, AND SCREENED FROM VIEW WITH EITHER A DECORATIVE WALL OR VEGETATION. 5. ALL TRASH PICK-UP SHALL BE PROVIDED THROUGH A PRIVATE ROLLOUT SERVICE. LITTER AND RECYCLING RECEPTACLES SHALL BE STORED INTERNAL TO THE UNIT EN 10 MAILBOXES EIR PIN: EARL LEE SPARKS, SR. JUDY CAROL JONES 1945 THURMOND PL. DB: PG: 139 SCALE: 1"=30' N EIR HDC-200 PIN: ROBERT C GILLESPIE, JR THE PLAZA DB: PG: 511 The drawings, the project manual and the design shown theron are instruments of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A.. The reproduction or unauthorized use of the documents without consent of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A. is prohibited. ColeJenest & Stone, P.A c

10 NASSAU BOULEVARD THURMOND PLACE THE PLAZA LOT 5 [][] 15' ALLEY PIN: DONALD R RAWLINS KILEY R RAWLINS 2100 THE PLAZA. DB: PG: 915 PIN: LAURE BELL CHARLES M HEIDEL, JR BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 962 PIN: JEFFERY E BRANTNER 1725 BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 958 PIN: IAN C. MUIR JULE S CHAN-MUIR 1729 BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 272 BELVEDERE AVENUE Shaping the Environment Realizing the Possibilities EN IN 9 2 Land Planning + Landscape Architecture + Civil Engineering + Urban Design 200 South Tryon Street, Suite 1400 Charlotte, North Carolina N p f url+ LOT 8 LOT 9 [] [] [] [] LOT 7 [] FP [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] [] 3 4 POOL HOUSE [] EXISTING ESTATE 7 3 EXISTING ORANGERIE 4 1 EXISTING OFFICE EXISTING CARRIAGE HOUSE PIN: KRISTINE MARIE SICKELS 1800 BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 306 PIN: LAVERNE LIBBY STONE 2711 CANVASBACK TL. MYRTLE BEACH, SC DB: PG: 849 DEVELOPMENT SUMMARY PETITIONER: PROPERTY OWNER: TOTAL SITE AREA: TAX PARCEL #: EXISTING USE: PROPOSED USE: NUMBER OF UNITS: MINIMUM SETBACK: CLOSEST RESIDENTIAL STRUCTURE TO: BELVEDERE AVE: THURMOND PL: THE PLAZA: LOT COVERAGE: TOTAL TREES REMOVED: HDC NOTES BILLY MADDALON 2010 THE PLAZA BILLY MADDALON 2010 THE PLAZA TOTAL: AC A B HOTEL/ SINGLE FAMILY DETACHED HOTEL/ SINGLE FAMILY ATTACHED 19 NEW SINGLE FAMILY ATTACHED UNITS. 1 EXISTING HOTEL/ EVENT FACILITY EXISTING RIGHT-OF-WAY OR 14' FROM BACK OF CURB, WHICH EVER IS GREATER ' LF 28.69' LF 39.37' LF (TO FIRE WALL) 41.4% (THIS CALCULATION INCLUDES EXISTING AND PROPOSED BUILD UPON AREA) 55 TREE GREATER THAN 6" DBH (SEE NOTE 1 SHEET HDC-200) 1. THE PETITIONER SHALL REPLANT A MINIMUM OF 30% OF THE TOTAL TREE DENSITY BEING REMOVED DUE TO CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITY ON SITE. 2. LANDSCAPE SCREENING TO BE PROVIDED ON SITE SHALL COMPLEMENT EXISTING VEGETATION. LANDSCAPE SCREENING SHALL INCLUDE, BUT IS NOT LIMITED TO; HEMLOCK, YEW, AMERICAN BOXWOOD, TEA OLIVE, RHODODENDRON, AZALEA, AMERICAN HOLLY, INKBERRY HOLLY, YAUPON HOLLY, DWARF YAUPON HOLLY, MAGNOLIA, CRYPTOMERIA, PODOCARPUS & ARBORVITAE. 3. ALL BACKFLOW PREVENTORS SHALL BE SCREENED FROM THE RIGHT-OF-WAY. FINAL LOCATIONS TO BE DETERMINED DURING CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS PHASE, IN COORDINATION WITH CHARLOTTE WATER. SEE SHEET HDC-100 FOR ADJACENT PROPERTY CONTEXT SEE SHEET HDC-300 FOR CONTEXTUAL SETBACKS & BUILDING HEIGHT EXHIBIT SEE SHEET HDC-300 FOR TREE REMOVAL EXHIBIT BILLY MADDALON 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina VANLANDINGHAM ESTATE 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina DIMENSIONAL SITE PLAN Project No Issued Revised LOT 6 4. ALL MECHANICAL UNITS SHALL BE LOCATED INTERNALLY TO THE PRIVATE LOTS, AND SCREENED FROM VIEW WITH EITHER A DECORATIVE WALL OR VEGETATION. 5. ALL TRASH PICK-UP SHALL BE PROVIDED THROUGH A PRIVATE ROLLOUT SERVICE. LITTER AND RECYCLING RECEPTACLES SHALL BE STORED INTERNAL TO THE UNIT EN 10 MAILBOXES EIR PIN: EARL LEE SPARKS, SR. JUDY CAROL JONES 1945 THURMOND PL. DB: PG: 139 SCALE: 1"=30' N EIR HDC-200 PIN: ROBERT C GILLESPIE, JR THE PLAZA DB: PG: 511 The drawings, the project manual and the design shown theron are instruments of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A.. The reproduction or unauthorized use of the documents without consent of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A. is prohibited. ColeJenest & Stone, P.A c

11 MAILBOXES MAILBOXES NASSAU BOULEVARD THURMOND PLACE Shaping the Environment Realizing the Possibilities Land Planning + Landscape Architecture + Civil Engineering + Urban Design 200 South Tryon Street, Suite 1400 Charlotte, North Carolina N p f url+ BILLY MADDALON 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina BLDG HT. =32.5' BLDG HT. =26.9' BLDG HT. =21.4' BLDG HT. =27.0' BLDG HT. =21.4' VANLANDINGHAM ESTATE BELVEDERE AVE The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina EN IN THE PLAZA BLDG HT.=33.6' BLDG HT. =25.9' THURMOND PL. BLDG HT. =32.4' BLDG HT. =18.8' WM EN IN 2100 THE PLAZA. DB: PG: 915 DB: PG: 962 BELVEDERE AVENUE DB: PG: BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 272 WV FH WV SETBACK EXHIBIT Project No Issued BLDG HT. =18.5' GV EIR EIR EIR EN THE PLAZA LOT 8 LOT 9 FP GM WV Revised WB [] LOT [] 7 [] [] [] [] [] [] N SCALE: 1"=80' LOT LOT 5 GM EIR EN WM WV WV PIN: EARL LEE SPARKS, SR. JUDY CAROL JONES 1945 THURMOND PL. DB: PG: 139 HDC-300 The drawings, the project manual and the design shown theron are instruments of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A.. The reproduction or unauthorized use of the documents without consent of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A. is prohibited. WM EIR ColeJenest & Stone, P.A c CONTEXTUAL SETBACKS & BUILDING HEIGHT EXHIBIT N.T.S. TREE PROTECTION AND TREE DEMOLITION 15' ALLEY N.T.S.

12 MAILBOXES MAILBOXES NASSAU BOULEVARD THURMOND PLACE Shaping the Environment Realizing the Possibilities Land Planning + Landscape Architecture + Civil Engineering + Urban Design 200 South Tryon Street, Suite 1400 Charlotte, North Carolina N p f url+ BILLY MADDALON 2010 The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina BLDG HT. =32.5' BLDG HT. =26.9' BLDG HT. =21.4' BLDG HT. =27.0' BLDG HT. =21.4' VANLANDINGHAM ESTATE BELVEDERE AVE The Plaza Charlotte North Carolina EN IN THE PLAZA BLDG HT.=33.6' BLDG HT. =25.9' THURMOND PL. BLDG HT. =32.4' BLDG HT. =18.8' WM EN IN 2100 THE PLAZA. DB: PG: 915 DB: PG: 962 BELVEDERE AVENUE DB: PG: BELVEDERE AVE. DB: PG: 272 WV FH WV SETBACK EXHIBIT Project No Issued BLDG HT. =18.5' GV EIR EIR EIR EN THE PLAZA LOT 8 LOT 9 FP GM WV Revised WB [] LOT [] 7 [] [] [] [] [] [] N SCALE: 1"=80' LOT LOT 5 GM EIR EN WM WV WV PIN: EARL LEE SPARKS, SR. JUDY CAROL JONES 1945 THURMOND PL. DB: PG: 139 HDC-300 The drawings, the project manual and the design shown theron are instruments of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A.. The reproduction or unauthorized use of the documents without consent of ColeJenest & Stone, P.A. is prohibited. WM EIR ColeJenest & Stone, P.A c CONTEXTUAL SETBACKS & BUILDING HEIGHT EXHIBIT N.T.S. TREE PROTECTION AND TREE DEMOLITION 15' ALLEY N.T.S.

26 A 14 :: Enlarged Elevation - Unit 01 West Elevation at The Plaza scale: 1/4" - 1' 0" NEW REVISED ELEVATION March 30, 2015 burgess design studio Plaza Midwood Charlotte NC Vanlandingham Estate - Meeting Street A 14

27 A 14 :: Enlarged Elevation - Unit 01 West Elevation at The Plaza scale: 1/4" - 1' 0" REVISED ELEVATION May 20, 2015 burgess design studio Plaza Midwood Charlotte NC Vanlandingham Estate - Meeting Street A 14

Rezoning Petition Pre-Hearing Staff Analysis May 21, 2018

Rezoning Petition Pre-Hearing Staff Analysis May 21, 2018 Rezoning Petition 2018-018 Pre-Hearing Staff Analysis May 21, 2018 REQUEST Current Zoning: R-5 (single family residential), R-5 HD-O (single family residential, historic district overlay) and B-2(CD) HD-O