TULSA PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT

Transcription

1 TULSA PRESERVATION COMMISSION STAFF REPORT Tuesday, May 26, 2015 COA COA NUMBER: COA PROPERTY ADDRESS: 1145 E. 16 TH STREET DISTRICT: NORTH MAPLE RIDGE HISTORIC DISTRICT APPLICANT: MOLLY CAMPBELL REPRESENTATIVES: NONE A. CASE ITEMS FOR CONSIDERATION 1. Replace non-original window with aluminum-clad exterior, wood interior window submitted B. BACKGROUND DATE OF CONSTRUCTION: CA ZONED HISTORIC PRESERVATION: 1993 NATIONAL REGISTER LISTING: MAPLE RIDGE HISTORIC DISTRICT: 1983 CONTRIBUTING STRUCTURE: NO PREVIOUS ACTIONS: NONE C. ISSUES AND CONSIDERATIONS 1. Replace non-original window with with aluminum-clad exterior, wood interior window submitted i. The applicant requests to replace her existing, non-original window with a window more in character of the building. The side room was originally a porch before it was filled in either in the 1950s or 1960s. The window facing 16 th Street will remain and features 15 panes. This application was continued from the Thursday, May 14 meeting. The original window proposed featured a casement picture window with a three-pane transom with exterior nine-over-one, double hung, vinyl windows. The proposed window will be a picture window with the outside windows featuring nine-over-nine double hung with the central windows featuring a single pane with no transom. The proposed material is aluminum-clad exterior, wood interior. ii. References: Unified Guidelines for Residential Structures SECTION B GUIDELINES FOR REHABILITATION OF EXISTING STRUCTURES A.4 WINDOWS AND WINDOW TRIM Page 1 of 2

2 A.4.1 Retain and preserve original historic windows, including glazing, trim, muntins, and character-defining details. COA A.4.3 To return the home to its original historic appearance, remove non-historic windows and trim. When selecting replacements, use physical or pictorial evidence. If no evidence exists, select windows which are consistent with the architectural style of your home. A.4.5 If replacement of deteriorated windows is necessary, match the original historic windows in sash design, size, shape, muntin pattern, location, glazing area and tint. Insulated glass (double pane) windows may be used. Exterior muntins are required on simulated divided light windows..1 Brady Heights Match the original historic window material. iii. Item Considerations 1. The proposed window was one of the suggestions given at the Tuesday, May 12, 2015 meeting. Page 2 of 2

3 Proposed Window Replacement Site Plan:

4

5 The Eden Companies LLC East 47th Place Tulsa, OK Phone: Fax: QUOTE: 521 QUOTE SUMMARY Project Number: 521 Printed: 5/18/ :48:57 AM CQ Prj #: 521 System #: 0 Order Date: 5/18/2015 is Valid: 6/18/2015 Dealer Prj #: 521 Sold To: 8 Customer ID: Ship To: 1 HOMEOWNER THE EDEN COMPANIES LLC EAST 47TH PLACE TULSA, OK TULSA, OK Phone: Fax: Phone: Fax: Delivery Instructions: Drop Ship: Weather Shield Proposes to Furnish Products as Stated Below. Item Number: 1 Signature Series Screen Color-Cameo Quantity: 1 Double Hung Tilt Picture Comb. Total Jamb To Jamb: 102 7/8 X 60 1/2 Rectangle Total Rough Opening: 103 3/8 X 61 O Exterior Frame Finish-Aluminum Clad Exterior Color-Cameo Overall Jamb Depth-4 9/16 Glass Type-Insulated Low E Lite Configuration-SDL W/GBG PO: Per Unit: Ext. Price: JOB NAME: MOLLY CAMPBELL LOCATION: SUNROOM Unit Price: $2, $2, Misc Item: Qty: Price: Less Discount: Tax Amt: Ext Price: INSTALLATION MATERIALS (SHIMS SCREWS SEALANT FOAM INSULATION ETC..._ 1 $75.00 $6.39 $81.39 INSTALLATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH MANUFACTURER S RECOMMENDATIONS (PER UNIT INCH) 170 $4.00 $0.00 $ Total: $ Net Amount: $2, State Taxes: $98.53 Cty Taxes: $20.08 Local Taxes: $67.88 Taxes(Other): $0.00 Misc Charges: $ Grand Total: $3, QUOTE MAY NOT INCLUDE TAXES, SHIPPING CHARGES OR MINIMUM CHARGE ADJUSTMENTS. Charges for shop drawings, field measurements, and handling fees are not included. Page 2 of 4 Quote 521 Weather Shield CustomQuote