TOWN PLANNING ASSESSMENT KAUFLAND SUPERMARKET NETWORK VICTORIAN ENTRY PROPOSAL. PART FOUR CENTRE ROAD, OAKLEIGH SOUTH Revision 2

Transcription

1 TOWN PLANNING ASSESSMENT KAUFLAND SUPERMARKET NETWORK VICTORIAN ENTRY PROPOSAL PART FOUR CENTRE ROAD, OAKLEIGH SOUTH Revision 2

2 Table of Contents Part Four Centre Road, Oakleigh South Local strategic context Urban context The Subject Site Site interfaces Key contextual cues Proposal Proposed changes to the Kingston Planning Scheme Proposed use and development Kaufland store layout and built form Planning policy context Plan Melbourne & State Planning Policy Framework Planning for the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster Local Planning Policy Framework (LPPF) Current planning controls Planning merits Key planning considerations Consideration against the Strategic Assessment Guidelines Is the proposal supported by strategic policy directives? Consistency with zone, overlay controls and other provisions Are acceptable built form, urban design, & streetscape outcomes achieved? Will the development be adequately serviced and accessible? Conclusion Net community benefit State level planning objectives Proposed planning framework & approval mechanism Proposed use and built form... 26

3 Part Four Centre Road, Oakleigh South 1 Local strategic context The Subject Site at Centre Road, Oakleigh South is located within the boundaries of Kingston City Council. This is a strategic location sitting at the edge of the state significant Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster, which Plan Melbourne proposes as an area as a focus for investment and growth that will provide a major contribution to the Victorian economy. Subject Site Site Context. Source: directory.com.au The site itself has already previously been used for another large format retail use (a Bunnings Warehouse ), and this proposal provides an opportunity to consolidate this site in a way that provides greater local amenity and servicing at a neighbourhood level with a Kaufland store, as well as substantially contributing to the objectives for the employment cluster through the intended siting of Kaufland s national headquarters for its Australian operations (subject to a later / future approval). The Site is located in an Industrial 1 Zone (IN1Z) and is not affected by any overlays. It forms part of a broader industrial precinct that is bounded by Centre Road to the north, Clarinda Road to the east, Bunney Road to the south and Jacks Road and Carroll Road to the west, as shown in Figure 1 below. This industrial area consists of a range of industrial and commercial uses including large format office and warehouse buildings and some smaller manufacturing, warehouse and distribution buildings. There is a range of public transport options, that operate along the sites Centre Road frontage being: Bus Route 703 Middle Brighton Blackburn, via Mt Clayton, Huntingdale. Bus Route 733 Oakleigh Box Hill, via Clayton, Monash University, Mt Waverley.

4 Subject Site Extract of Local Area Map, Mornington 2 Urban context Source: Public Transport Victoria 2.1 The Subject Site The Subject Site is located on the south side of Centre Road, near its intersection with Clarinda Road and Huntingdale Road. The Site has two street frontages, with Centre Road being the primary street frontage and Clarinda Road the secondary street frontage. The Site is currently occupied by Bunnings Warehouse, which consists of a large-format warehouse building that covers nearly half of the Site and is surrounded by an open car park for customer and staff parking. A number of large trees are scattered throughout the Site, with more substantial planting located within the front setbacks along the two street frontages. The Site has two vehicle access points, with the main entrance from Centre Road, and the secondary entrance from Clarinda Road. Both entrances allow both left hand and right hand turns into / out of the Site. The main customer car park is located to the east of the building, with a secondary car park to the rear of the building at the most southern end of the Site. A separate crossover and accessway has been provided for deliveries to Bunnings and is provided from Centre Road along the western boundary. The loading bay is located in the south-west corner of the building.

5 Subject site Source: Nearmap Entrance to the Site from Centre Road Clarinda Road entrance Service road entrance (from Centre Rd) Car park at the rear of the Site (south)

6 2.2 Site interfaces North The land directly north of the Site is used as a golf course, which is heavily landscaped along its south boundary with substantial trees, shrubs and associated fencing. The land to the west of the golf course is occupied by residential uses, with single dwellings the predominant housing type and some multi-dwelling developments also evident. The land on the north east corner to Huntingdale Road and Centre Road is occupied by a 4 storey apartment building East The land to the east of the Site across Clarinda Road predominantly consists of residential uses, with the prevailing housing type being single dwellings. On the south side of Centre Road on the other side of Clarinda Road the two adjoining sides are contained within the Commercial 1 Zone (C1Z), with the southwest corner containing a single storey dwelling, which appears to be abandoned, and the south-east corner containing a 7 Eleven petrol station. The Clarinda Primary School, tennis club and Presbyterian Church is located further east of the residential area, along Centre Road.

7 2.2.3 South The land immediately to the south of the Site consists of an existing business park with medium-sized tenancies that house the head offices and storage base for a number of small businesses, such as Simply Spanish. Further south of the Site is the Clarinda electrical substation West The land to the west of the Site is occupied by a Stocklands Industrial Park. This consists of a number of large office/warehouse buildings which contain car parking within the front setback of the Site. The uses within this industrial park including display suite / retail (Matt Blatt), logistics / distribution (Star Track) and a number of other storage, office and restricted retail uses.

8 2.2.5 Emerging Context The following changes in the area contribute to the emerging context of the surrounding area: Kingston Amendment C126 rezones land to the east of the Site (along Centre Road) from IN1Z to General Residential Zone (GRZ) and Mixed Use Zone (MUZ). This demonstrates that there is a shift in the broader area for redundant industrial land to be rezoned to allow mixed-use and residential developments. A number of developments have been approved and constructed in the surrounding area, which includes a 4 storey apartment development on the corner of Centre Road and Clarinda Road. This also demonstrates the increase in residential population and density that is occurring in the surrounding community. More significantly, the relatively recent identification of the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster and associated planning elevates the strategic significance in terms of the role and opportunity that the site affords Accessibility The GTA report provides an overview of the transport access and movement in and around the Site. The Site has its access from Centre Road to the North and Clarinda Road to the east, both of which are roads controlled by VicRoads (Road Zone Category 1). The existing customer entrances / exits from Centre Road and Clarinda Road as well as the existing service entry / exit are not proposed to be altered as part of this development. However, a new service road is proposed from Clarinda Road. A bus stop is located in front of the Site on the Centre Road frontage. 2.3 Key contextual cues The key contextual elements that have been taken into account and informed the preparation of the design response include: The Site is located in an industrial zone, but is surrounded by a range of different zones, including residential, commercial and special use zones. The zoning characterises the diverse land uses in immediate area which is suggestive that this site has the capacity to be used for an alternative appropriate use that the historic INZ1 provides for. The Site is on the edge of the existing industrial precinct. This location is beneficial in terms of exposure and also as it will ensure no unreasonable impacts on the existing industrial uses.

9 The Site benefits from its existing vehicle access arrangements, including slip lanes which allow multidirectional access to both frontages. There is an existing car park on site which provides appropriate provision, configuration and design in connection with the existing land use. There is existing, established landscape buffer around the periphery of the Site, which contributes to softening the appearance of the car park and building on the Site. The existing Bunnings Warehouse land use on the Site already provides an alternative use to that traditionally seen in industrial zones, particularly in relation to the operation of the business, which more so trades as a retail use as opposed to a typical industrial land use. The industrial land uses that immediately surround the site have similar design features to the subject site, including car parking within the front setback and large format warehouse or retail buildings.

10 3 Proposal The land use of shop is prohibited under the IN1Z. This includes land used for a supermarket, hence a Planning Scheme Amendment is proposed to facilitate the proposed use via an incorporated document. 3.1 Proposed changes to the Kingston Planning Scheme This proposal will seek to amend the following clauses of the Kingston Planning Scheme: Schedule to clause (Specific site exclusions): - Update the schedule to include reference to a proposed incorporated document comprising site specific controls to allow the proposed use and development subject to appropriate conditions. Schedule to clause (Incorporated documents): - Update the schedule to include reference to the proposed incorporated document and associated Planning Scheme Amendment. 3.2 Proposed use and development Proposed Kaufland Store The proposed Kaufland store comprises the following elements; Use and development of the site for a 6,907sqm building containing the following, inter alia: - 3,610sqm of supermarket floor area sqm bottle shop sqm food hall and 136sqm outdoor area. - Associated inhouse facilities including 1,404sqm back of house facilities, 169sqm services, 307sqm of administration. - Loading area. - Associated signage (refer details below) bicycle spaces (comprising 22 staff spaces and 14 customer spaces). Reconfiguration of the existing car park to provide a total of 414 car parking spaces including: standard spaces accessible spaces family spaces. - 6 senior spaces. The Kaufland store will involve employment generation in the order of ongoing jobs Proposed future Kaufland Australia national headquarters Indicative details of the future Kaufland office development are notated on the architectural plans for information. The office development will be subject to a later / future approval. 3.3 Kaufland store layout and built form The proposed development adopts a built form and scale that is generally reflective of the previous Bunning s store on Site and the adjacent medium and large-scale warehouse buildings. The building will be single storey building with a predominant height in the order of 8-9 metres, with a maximum height of 11m to the feature parapet at the north east corner of the building..

11 The proposed store is oriented with its primary frontage addressing Centre Road. The presentation is one of a contemporary, supermarket building articulated with a range of materials and finishes. The proposed materials include feature cladding, FC sheet cladding, metal deck roofing and clear double-glazed glass. Solar panels are proposed to be provided on the roof. The customer entrance to the building is proposed in the north east corner of the building, with the retail tenancies located along the northern frontage of the building. The front of house building interfaces are treated with a combination of footpath areas, canopy treatments and public realm and landscaping treatments. The existing car park area is generally proposed to be retained, with changes proposed to the layout and design of the car park. The car park design includes landscaping, generous means of circulation and parking areas, and dedicated footpaths and crossing points for pedestrians. The car park is located in the Centre Road and Clarinda Road frontages and is provided with direct dedicated access from both these roads. The back of house area and loading bay is located to the south side of the building. Separated service access to the loading area will be provided by the existing accessway from Centre Road, along the west side of the Site. Surplus land areas toward the rear of the site (as marked on the plans for information) presents a future development opportunity for the Kaufland offices which will be subject to further design development and later / future approval. A number of signs are proposed within the Site as detailed and located on the architectural plans and described as follows: Internally illuminated logo signage: Entry logo sign 1a (5m x 5m), typical logo sign 1b (5m x 5m),typical logo sign 1c (4m x 4m) and typical logo sign 1d (3m x 3m). Billboard signage lit by linear LED lighting from brackets above: 5.01m x 3.51m. Internally illuminated tenancy signage: 10m x 1.3m. Pylon sign type 1: 8m (h) x 2-2.4m (w). Pylon sign type 2 (pole sign): 22m (h) with a sign 5m x 5m and tenany signage 5m x 1.3m. Trolley enclosure signage / graphic treatment.

12 4 Planning policy context 4.1 Plan Melbourne & State Planning Policy Framework The proposal is broadly supported by Plan Melbourne and state level planning policy directives having regard to those elements of policy as summarised in Part One to this report. 4.2 Planning for the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster Plan Melbourne nominates the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster (NEIC) as a key location and strategy for achieving the goal of creating jobs closer to where people live. It recognises that each cluster will need a high level of amenity to attract workers and be investment-ready to attract new firms. Plan Melbourne states that the Monash cluster has the potential to attract a broader range of businesses including office and retail and is the largest existing cluster outside the CBD with circa 75,000 jobs. The national employment clusters are a major strategic focus for Plan Melbourne and the VPA has prepared a draft framework plan for the Monash cluster. The framework plan intentionally does not seek to define boundaries for the cluster noting its ability to grow and evolve and given the planned doubling of existing jobs in the area. It does however focus on a 10km radius of connectivity. The subject site is notionally located at the edge of the cluster and in good proximity to some of the key sites identified within the cluster including Huntingdale Activity Centre (approx. 1.6km) and Clayton Activity Centre (approx. 1.8km). It recognises precincts such as underutilised industrial land offer opportunities for urban renewal, and also nominates a series of large scale (e.g. 30ha-100ha) strategic sites or precincts that have come to the end of the post-war manufacturing economy and are available for re-investment with a particular focus on economic and social participation through development of ongoing local employment opportunities. Centre Road is nominated as a focal point for intensification and high capacity public transport.

13 The Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster Framework Plan (source: Figure 2, Monash Draft Framework Plan, VPA, March 2017).

14 4.3 Local Planning Policy Framework (LPPF) Parts of the Kingston LPPF appear to be significantly outdated, and the local policy framework is presently under review Current local planning policy Relevant clauses of the existing MSS include: Clause places a focus on the significant role Kingston plays as a location for business and a generator of employment. Clause recognises the challenges for the municipalities older industrial areas which are in need of revitalisation and investment if they are to remain viable. A focus is placed on prioritising activity centres as being preferable locations for retail investment in order to achieve metropolitan planning objectives. Clause recognises that new investment in supermarkets is required, yet also seeks to discourage additional out-of-centre development following the establishment of a series of large format centres emerging outside Kingston s recognised activity centres. It nominates key issues as being consolidating retailing activity within centres, the need to limit restricted retailing activity to the consolidation of existing restricted retailing precincts and ensuring new office development provides sufficient differentiation to further diversify Kingston s employment base. Clause contains policy that appears to be based on a reference document dated from 1997 (Kingston Industrial Development Strategy 1997). It generally seeks to protect industrial land from nonindustrial encroachments and includes a strategy to protect industrial land from inappropriate rezoning and encourage retail and office uses to locate in appropriate business zones, except where such uses form part of an integrated development plan for industrial estates. It also includes a strategy to redevelop smaller pockets of industrial land located within residential areas for innovative residential or mixed use development, taking into account local environmental and amenity issues. There are no current relevant local planning policies aside from clause This policy outlines objectives for outdoor signage that is appropriate in size, appearance and character for the associated land use and surrounding context, and seeks to ensure that commercial businesses are able to adequately identify their premises and promote the goods and services they offer Amendment C132 Kingston Planning Scheme Review The C132 explanatory report advises this is essentially a policy neutral updating of the Kingston MSS and local planning policies. It also advises the updating of the LPPF was based on a review of the Kingston Planning Scheme undertaken in At the time of writing the proposed updated LPPF has been adopted by Council and is being considered by the Minister for Planning for approval and gazettal. There has been no independent review of the proposed Amendment by a planning panel. The proposed updated LPPF; Continues to place a focus on the existing activity centre hierarchy at proposed clause 21.02, including to consolidate new retail use within the boundaries of existing activity centres. Updates retail policy at proposed clause to recognise that retail trade is a significant employment creator in Kingston and is fundamentally important to the economic wellbeing of the community Includes a new proposed policy provision at clause which seeks to avoid establishing traditional retail floor spaces within identified restricted retail precincts. Includes a new provision at clause related to industry recognising that the nature of the City s employment base is changing with a rise in the number of high skilled jobs. With limited stock of

15 greenfield industrial land, the re-use and redevelopment of older sites will become more important as employment creators in the future. Includes a new objective 5 (at clause ) to promote high skill, high wage jobs for Kingston residents including a strategy to ensure that employment outcomes are an integral part of any proposed rezoning of industrial land. Retains the 1997 Kingston Industrial Strategy as a reference document. 4.4 Current planning controls The subject land is presently included in the Industrial 1 Zone. The proposed use and development will also need to be considered against the following particular provisions: Clause Signage: A permit is required for the proposed signage due to the size of signage (classified major promotion signs). An industrial area is designated as a minimum limitation area under this clause. Clause Licensed Premises: A permit is required to use land to sell liquor. Clause Land Adjacent to a Road Zone Category 1: a permit is required to create or alter access. A permit is not required under the following planning scheme provisions: Clause Car parking: The car parking provided on the Site exceeds the statutory car parking rates in Clause for a supermarket and shop and do not require a permit. Clause Bicycle Facilities: The bicycle parking and end of trip facilities required by clause and Clause are provided on the Site and do not require a permit.

16 5 Planning merits This section of the report provides an objective assessment of the planning merits of the proposal. Cl of the Kingston Planning Scheme (Integrated decision making and decision guidelines) provides that Planning authorities and responsible authorities should endeavour to integrate the range of policies relevant to the issues to be determined and balance conflicting objectives in favour of net community benefit and sustainable development for the benefit of present and future generations (emphasis added). Ultimately, when considering applications, as set out at clause 65, the responsible authority must decide whether the proposal will produce acceptable outcomes in terms of the decision guidelines of this clause (emphasis added). 5.1 Key planning considerations Based on review of the urban context and the statutory planning context, the key planning considerations for this proposal are set out and addressed in turn below. Consideration of the proposed Amendment against the strategic assessment guidelines see Practice Note 46 Is the proposal supported by and aligned to strategic policy objectives? Is the proposal consistent with the zone, overlay and other provisions? Are acceptable built form, urban design, and streetscape outcomes achieved? Will the development be adequately serviced and accessible? Does the project provide net community benefit? 5.2 Consideration against the Strategic Assessment Guidelines Given the proposal for a site specific exclusion would otherwise require a review of the current zoning, consideration against the Strategic Assessment Guidelines for evaluating planning scheme amendments is warranted, in line with Planning Practice Note 46 (PPN46). A review against the criteria suggested in PPN46 is set out below. 1. Why is an amendment required? An Amendment is required to facilitate development of the subject land for the use of a supermarket with associated retail uses. The proposal could not be facilitated through the usual processes available and the proposed Amendment will enable the coordinated consideration, approval and delivery on this site as part of the broader Victorian entry proposal. In line with PPN46 the Amendment will result in net community benefit and a good planning outcome based on assessment contained in this report, the economic assessment prepared by Dimasi and Co, and supporting access and acoustic studies. 2. Does the amendment implement the objectives of planning and address any environmental, social and economic effects? The amendment assists in the implementation of the following objectives set out at Section 4 (1) of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 (the Act): To provide for the fair, orderly, economic and sustainable use and development of land; To secure a pleasant, efficient and safe working, living and recreational environment for all Victorians and visitors to Victoria.

17 To balance the present and future interests of all Victorians. The Amendment seeks to achieve the objectives listed above by allowing land uses that would otherwise be prohibited, to occur on the land. Given the mixed nature of the zoning to the surrounding land, the proposed Kaufland Supermarket and associated retail uses would complement the residential nature of the surrounding area and would positively contribute to the fair, orderly, economic and sustainable use and development of the land. The proposed land use would not only generate local employment and economic benefits, but it would also provide a local shopping amenity option within walking distance of the surrounding residents and workforce. The proposal would provide an appropriate transition between the more intensive industrial uses within the centre of the precinct and the sensitive residential uses to the north and east of the site, which would positively contribute to the fair and orderly planning of the area. The intent to site Kaufland s national headquarters in this location is also aligned to metropolitan strategic objectives associated with the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster and subject to a future approval would provide improved access to high value, high skilled jobs. The expected improvements to access and movement within the site, and the retention of the existing landscaped character will create a secure, pleasant and safe place for the community to live and work. Given that the population within Kingston Council and within the nearby area is increasing, the provision of such facilities will play an increasingly important role in providing for the present and future interests of the community, which would not adversely impact on the performance of the existing industrial precinct particularly noting the existing large format retail presence on site. 3. Does the amendment address relevant bushfire risk? This area is not prone to bushfire risk and bushfire planning provisions are not likely to be relevant. 4. Does the Amendment comply with all the relevant Minister s Directions? Ministerial Direction No.1 Potentially Contaminated Land Environmental site investigations have been undertaken by Cardno and the Amendment, which does not seek to facilitate any sensitive uses, complies with this direction. Ministerial Direction No. 9 Metropolitan Planning Strategy The Amendment has been prepared with regard to Ministerial Direction No. 9 Metropolitan Strategy and is highly consistent with Plan Melbourne as discussed in part one of this report and with respect to particular objectives for employment generation in and around the Monash NEIC. Ministerial Direction on the form and content of Planning Schemes The Amendment will comply with the Ministerial Direction on the form and content of Planning Schemes. 5. Does the amendment support or implement the State Planning Policy Framework? The proposed amendment will support the relevant objectives of the State Planning Policy Framework (the SPPF). The Amendment will assist in achieving objectives in relation to the following clauses: Clause 11 - Settlement: Clause 11 provides strategic guidance for responding to the needs of existing and future communities through the provision of appropriately zoned and serviced land for commercial, retail, and industrial uses, among other considerations. In addition, clause seeks to attract investment and create jobs. The Amendment supports clause 11 by providing strategic direction at a local level to facilitate a commercial development, which complements the mix of land uses in the surrounding area and will also meet the current and future needs of the local

18 community through creating jobs and investment in the area, in addition to convenient access to daily shopping needs. Clause 13 Environmental Risk: Clause 13 seeks to ensure that potentially contaminated land is suitable for its intended future use and development and is used safely. As demonstrated in the Preliminary Site Investigation prepared by Cardno Victoria Pty Ltd there is a low contamination risk for the proposed Kaufland supermarket development (including retail and office), and that the proposed commercial land uses would not be precluded, and any contamination issues can be appropriately managed. Clause 15 Built Environment and Heritage: Clause 15 seeks to create urban environments that are safe, functional and provide a sense of place whilst minimising detrimental impact on neighbouring properties. The Amendment supports this clause by providing a building design and site layout that appropriately responds to the sensitive residential interfaces to the north and east, maintains the landscaped character on site and is consistent with the character of industrial and commercial development in the area. In addition, the development will be designed to provide functional and safe vehicle and pedestrian movement. Clause 17 Economic Development: Clause 17 encourages development which meets the communities needs for retail, office and other commercial services. It also seeks to ensure the availability of land for industry and seeks to avoid out-ofcentre development for single use unless there is a net community benefit, which has been demonstrated through the work undertaken by Dimasi and Co. Further, the Kaufland store itself is a multi-use proposition containing a broad range of goods and a mixture of retail tenants. Due to the existing large format retail use the Amendment will not result in the loss of available industrial land. The proposed Supermarket development will provide convenient retail amenity essential provisions for local residents and workers. This is considered to be a positive outcome for the local area and will positively contribute to the viability of the existing industrial precinct through investment and providing complementary land uses. 6. How does the amendment support or implement the LPPF and specifically the MSS? Consistency with the Kingston LPPF needs to be considered in context of the LPPF being under review, not having been tested by Panel, and with some relevant elements being based on outdated policy work requiring further review, such as the 1997 Industrial Strategy. Notwithstanding, the existing and proposed policy frameworks consistently place a focus on limiting out of centre retailing, going further than the SPPF which seeks to manage out of centre development. Existing policy recognises that older industrial pockets are in need of revitalisation and investment, and seeks to consolidate out of centre development in existing restricted retailing precincts, and ensuring new office development diversifies Kingston s employment base. The proposed Amendment supports these aspects of policy noting the site is already an out-of-centre location. The local policy objective at clause to consolidate new retail within the boundaries of existing activity centres needs to be considered in the context of the following key factors;

19 Consistency with the above aspects of the LPPF. The SPPF which seeks to manage single use out-of-centre development and Plan Melbourne and its implementation plan which include recognition of the challenges for new retail formats to obtain a foothold in centres. The challenges associated with sourcing a 25,000sq.m site in existing activity centres. The site location which is already used for large format retail use and hence does not constitute a loss of industrial land notwithstanding it is not clear that updated strategic planning has been undertaken for understanding Kingston s industrial area requirements. The multi-use nature of the proposal which will support Kingston s employment base. The future proofing of the design which enables a later / future approval for Kaufland s intended office development provides a further opportunity to implement state level policy with respect to the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster. The demonstrable net community benefit that the proposal will deliver. Having regard to the existing and proposed elements of the LPPF and the above factors, on balance the benefits of the proposed Amendment are considered to outweigh any disbenefits associated with not locating within an existing centre. As such in an overall and strategic sense, the Amendment is aligned to the orderly planning of Kingston, and is considered to be supporting of the MSS vision for city strategy and economic development which is to provide strategic leadership for the City and to facilitate strategic land use, sustainable economic development and job creation within a framework of concern for environmental and social implications. Aligned to this vision the proposal is expected to generate between jobs on site associated with the Kaufland store. 7. Does the amendment make proper use of the Victoria Planning Provisions? The proposal makes proper use of the Victoria Planning Provisions. The proposal is consistent with Planning Practice Note 13 (Incorporated and Reference Documents, June 2015), which states that a document must be incorporated if the document is necessary to determine the extent of a planning control. Other than updating the relevant schedules to clause and 81.01, no further planning scheme changes are proposed at this stage. This enables the existing zoning framework to be retained pending future strategic review that may be required or intended including of the broader area, e.g. following preparation of industrial policy or a review in connection with the Monash NEIC. 8. Does the amendment address the requirements of the Transport Integration Act 2010? Based on technical review and assessment undertaken by GTA consultants, the proposed Amendment is not expected to have a significant impact on the transport system, as defined by section 3 of the Transport Integration Act How does the amendment address the views of relevant agencies? It is proposed that the views of relevant agencies be incorporated through appropriate engagement and participation through the planning approval process.

20 10. What impact will the new planning provisions have on the administrative costs of the responsible authority? It is not anticipated that the new planning provisions would have any meaningful impact on the administrative costs of the responsible authority. 5.3 Is the proposal supported by strategic policy directives? The proposal has strong strategic support and is highly aligned with State and Local planning policies and the directions of Plan Melbourne as considered above. The proposed development will contribute to the growth of jobs within the City of Kingston and will also provide convenient shopping access to the surrounding residential and working population. Whilst the Site is located in an industrial zone, it is located on edge of the broader industrial precinct and interfaces with a range of zones including commercial and residential zones. Given the diversity of surrounding land uses as well as the locational attributes of the Site, the proposed land use will benefit residents and workers in the broader area without impacting on the integrity and functionality of the broader industrial precinct. The Site benefits from its location and accessibility as it has direct access to two arterial roads, being Centre Road and Clarinda Road. In addition, the Site is within proximity to the Princess Highway, Nepean Highway and Monash Freeway, which further enhances accessibility to the Site. The proposed development will strengthen the ability for nearby residents to do their weekly shopping locally, would not detract from the hierarchy of activity centres within Kingston, and will effectively respond to the evolving nature of the commercial market (refer to clause 21.06). In addition, the building will be designed to complement the surrounding built form context, including the provision of signage that is appropriate in size, appearance and character of the surrounding context (clause 22.15), and a general scale, configuration and interface treatment that is not dissimilar to current arrangements on the site Plan Melbourne This project will deliver on some of the major initiatives contained at the top level of planning policy through Plan Melbourne in the following ways; Will attract investment from an internationally renowned supermarket chain, which will also result in the creation of jobs. It will contribute to the creation of a city of 20-minute neighbourhoods. Utilisation of environmentally sustainable design technologies in the building design SPPF This project is aligned with the following aspects of the SPPF: The proposal complements the mix of land uses in the surrounding area and will also meet the current and future needs of the local community through creating jobs and investment in the area in addition to convenient access to daily shopping needs. The development will provide a positive urban design response to the surrounding context a building design and site layout that appropriately responds to the sensitive residential interfaces to the north and east of the Site, maintains the landscaped character of the Site and is consistent with the style of industrial development in the area. The proposed supermarket will positively contribute to convenience needs of the local area, whilst retaining the viability of the existing industrial precinct through providing complementary land uses. The proposal will not prejudice the ongoing operation of the industrial precinct.

21 5.4 Consistency with zone, overlay controls and other provisions Zone The Site is in an IN1Z, the purpose of which is to: To implement the State Planning Policy Framework and the Local Planning Policy Framework, including the Municipal Strategic Statement and local planning policies. To provide for manufacturing industry, the storage and distribution of goods and associated uses in a manner which does not affect the safety and amenity of local communities. In this case it is not considered to be appropriate to rezone the land from its existing Industrial zoning due to its location within a broader industrial precinct. However, a site-specific exemption is deemed to be appropriate given the mixed nature of the land uses in the immediate surrounding area, (a mixture of residential, commercial, industrial and leisure and recreation land uses) and the existing large format retail presence. It is considered that the proposed Kaufland Store is appropriate within the context of the Site, consistent with the SPPF and the local MSS vision. The proposed use will also provide an appropriate transition between the existing residential areas to the north and east and the industrial precinct to the west. Therefore, it is considered that the proposed use and development will have a positive affect on the safety and amenity of the local community and will not disadvantage the continuing use of the existing industrial precinct Car parking and loading The car parking layout and design generally adopts the same layout and general configuration of access points, car parking areas and pedestrian access points as per the previous operations. Clause generates a statutory requirement for car parking provision on site as documented in the GTA report. The proposal will have 414 car parking spaces, in excess of statutory car parking requirements. Car park design has been in accordance with clause design standards for car parking. Loading is provided at the rear of the building and is separated from pedestrians and the main vehicle access. Loading access will be provided from Centre Road, along the west side of the Site. Two loading docks have been provided for the intended use of a 19m semi-trailer. The traffic and car parking assessment prepared by GTA consultants provides further details and confirms the appropriateness of proposed traffic and access arrangements requirements Bicycle requirements Clause sets out the statutory requirements for the provision of bicycle facilities for the proposed development. The proposal provides for 36 spaces on-site. Staff bicycle parking is provided in a secure area appropriately located at the rear of the proposed Kaufland store. The traffic and car parking assessment prepared by GTA consultants provides and confirms the appropriateness of the proposed bicycle and end of trip facility arrangements Liquor The proposal will incorporate the sale of packaged liquor for consumption off premises in a separate retail premise of 354sqm within the proposed building form. It is envisaged that this liquor will be a component of the primary supermarket use. Clause requires consideration of the impact of the licensed premises on the amenity of the surrounding area. In this instance, it is submitted the proposal will have a limited impact as the proposed

22 liquor provision operates ancillary to the supermarket use, is unlikely to have a negative impact on the amenity of the area by virtue of the surrounding non-sensitive commercial / industrial uses, and that only packaged liquor is proposed to be sold as part of a much broader retail offering characterised in large part by food and groceries Signage A consideration of clause and clause is relevant to an assessment of signage. The proposal incorporates several types of signage on each of the building s interfaces and two pylon signs and a pole sign within the Site. The Site is classified as a category 2, low limitation area (office and industrial) in accordance with clause As demonstrated in the signage plan prepared by Leffler Simes Architect, some of the business identification signs are classified as major promotions signs subject to the definition in clause 73 as they are over 18sqm in area. The location, size and detail of the proposed signage has been specified on the plans. Kaufland is an international brand with an established corporate branding that allows international brand recognition. A signage strategy has been developed specifically for the Australian entry into the market with careful consideration to local conditions for built form and development. As required under clause 22.15, the proposed signs achieve maximum effectiveness without being excessive in their number, height or appearance. The signs have been designed in a coordinated manner, with all signage adequately spaced within the Site to reduce visual clutter, whilst complementing the design and appearance of the building. The internally illuminated signs have been designed and located to ensure there will be no unreasonable light omitted to any surrounding sensitive interfaces, including residential uses and the surrounding road network. The proposed pole signs will be sited within the built form context of a large site with large scale surrounding subdivision and built form character, and will provide effective advertising for the business without detracting from the local character. In the context of the Site s location and industrial character (with a low limitation designation) it is submitted that the signage as proposed is acceptable. 5.5 Are acceptable built form, urban design, & streetscape outcomes achieved? The siting approach is generally reflective of the layout of the existing Bunnings store with the orientation and siting of the building similar to that of the existing Bunnings building. Overall, the building will be sufficiently setback from both street frontages and will be provided with a carpark configuration that is similar to the existing car park provided within the Site s frontages. Sufficient landscaping will be provided within the front setbacks of Centre Road and Clarinda Road as well as within the carpark, which will soften the appearance of hard surfaces within the Site. This includes an approximately 15m deep landscaping zone to Clarinda Road to buffer and filter views to the area set aside and intended for development in connection with the head office and subject to a later / future approval Built form The built form has been designed to appropriately respond to the character of the surrounding industrial and commercial buildings. Whilst the building is designed to incorporate a supermarket, the design detail includes materials, finishes and detailing to ensure an attractive and quality built form. The scale of the proposed building is similar to the built form and design of the surrounding industrial area. Building height is also in keeping with surrounding built form. The built form includes a clearly recognisable and functional entrance at the north-east corner of the Site, with the northern façade activated with a tenancy and outdoor eatery and differentiated through design with timber pattern and dark grey feature cladding, with activation wrapping around to the eastern corner. The

23 east, south and west interfaces predominately feature light grey cladding, has and include appropriate visual breaks and articulation through the use of signage, highlight windows and louvres. This combination of materials and finishes seek to provide an attractive and quality retail building. Exterior elements and roof top services will be incorporated within the building design and sited appropriately. The overall built form is typical of a good quality contemporary supermarket design, and the built form response has been carefully conceived to ensure that the development will provide a meaningful built form contribution to the corner of this broader employment precinct and its interfaces to Clarinda Road and Centre Road Setbacks & interfaces The proposed development will be located in a similar position, along the west side of the Site, to the existing Bunnings building. However, the extent of built form will be varied, which increases the setback of the building from the Centre Road frontage (approximate 80-85mm setback). The building is also setback approximately a similar distance from Clarinda Road, allowing for generous car parking and landscaping to be provided within these frontages. In terms of other interfaces, the building is situated approximately 8m from the west boundary (which ensures the service road is retained for loading purposes. In summary, the setbacks have largely been informed by the previous building on site enabling continuity of streetscape character, with additional setbacks provided from Centre Road Landscaping The landscaped setbacks that currently exist along the Clarinda Road and Centre Road frontages of the Site will largely be retained. The existing trees and landscaping is generally well established and positively contributes to the vegetated character of the area. Internal to the Site will feature new landscape areas where possible Fencing & storage There will be no boundary fencing along the main frontages of the Site. There will be internal screening adjacent to the loading areas and rear of the building that is incorporated into the overall design approach in order to maintain the quality and character of the development. 5.6 Will the development be adequately serviced and accessible? The traffic and transport assessment undertaken by GTA consultants concludes that the proposed vehicle movements, car parking numbers, and configurations are appropriate noting: The provision of 414 car parking spaces. The proposal for a separate service vehicle access road. The ability for the Head office to accommodate its own onsite car parking primarily as result of the land size. The appropriate provision of bicycle parking. Satisfactory space for loading and unloading, and for general access and manoeuvrability throughout the sit.. For further details please refer to the assessment provided by GTA consultants.

24

25 6 Conclusion Having regard to the relevant planning strategies, policies and controls, this assessment has demonstrated that overall and on balance, the proposal will deliver significant net community benefit, and will reflect sustainable and economic development principles as sought by the Kingston Planning Scheme. For the following reasons, favourable consideration of this significant and important proposal both locally and collectively as a whole to the State of Victoria, is warranted. 6.1 Net community benefit Net community benefit will be derived from factors including the following: Significant employment generated through the construction phase of the project. Significant ongoing and additional permanent job creation, which is anticipated to be in the order of 100 direct jobs associated with the Kaufland store. The creation of local employment opportunities that will be equitable in an accessibility sense, located at the edge of a strategic employment cluster accessible to the south and east regions of Melbourne. Greater range and quality of product and grocery lines available to the local community. Downward pressure on pricing of groceries that can be reasonably anticipated through the creation of greater competition in the grocery and supermarket sector which has historically and is presently dominated by a limited number of major operators. Broader economic and supplier benefits derived from a major investment sourced from offshore funds additional to the Victorian economy. 6.2 State level planning objectives Plan Melbourne provides a supportive policy framework for this proposal generally, including having regard to the objectives for the Monash National Employment and Innovation Cluster. The proposal is aligned to and reflective of Plan Melbourne s key objectives for the city to become a global city of opportunity and choice, and a city that is innovative and attracts investment. It is also supported by Plan Melbourne directives for accessible employment creation, and the efficient and competitive use of metropolitan land more generally as the city continues its significant growth trajectory with accompanying growing demand for retail servicing spread across existing suburban areas which are to accommodate 70% of new dwelling stock. The SPPF supports the managed introduction of out-of-centre development, particularly where non single use outcomes are facilitated and where net community benefit is achieved for the region to be serviced both tests that Oakleigh South Kaufland proposal satisfies. This is to be considered in the context of a broader current SPPF policy environment that is geared towards economic growth, local employment and the pragmatic and efficient use of metropolitan land, and an industrial zoned site that has already been used for large format retailing purposes 6.3 Proposed planning framework & approval mechanism Due to the level of planning and timing certainty required to commit to a significant investment involving coordination, implementation and operation of numerous stores, national headquarters and a major distribution centre, a facilitated planning process is necessary to enable entering and competing in the Victorian market, including where a review of existing zoning would otherwise be required in this instance. Hence, the proposed approval via incorporated document pursuant to clause is necessary and appropriate.