Attachment C Elm Street Business District: Streetscape and Signage Plan VILLAGE OF WINNETKA DOWNTOWN MASTER PLAN TASK FORCE MTG #4 Final Streetscape & Signage Planning Teska Associates 26 February 2018 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 11
Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May PHASE 1 analysis tf 10. 30.17 PHASE 2 prelim master plan p tf tf vc PHASE 3 final master plan 12.04.17 01.15.18 02.06.18 p tf vc tf vc Task Public tf p vc Force Village Council 02.26.18 04.03.18 04.24.18 05.15.18 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 12
REPORTING BACK: VILLAGE COUNCIL MEETING (02/06/18) KEY THEMES AND COMMENTS 1. Interest in narrowing crosswalk at Green Bay Road emphasis on IDOT coordination and evaluation of traffic impacts; 2. Support for focus on trees and seating areas at bumps outs; 3. Support for separating specialty lighting (apart from tree plantings); 4. Concur with maintaining outdoor café spaces with clear sidewalk passing area; 5. Interest in incorporating community postings at kiosks; 6. Consider how community events may benefit from or be impacted by proposed streetscape; and 7. Address costs and budget concerns in planning. IDOT COORDINATION MEETING (02/23/18) KEY THEMES AND COMMENTS 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 13
SITE FURNISHINGS: ELEMENTS Standard Bike Rack custom graphics Bike Bollard Bike repair station Clustered seating at planters Precast Concrete Planters Benches 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 14
LIGHTING - PREVIOUS EFFORTS TO CARRY FORWARD Kim Roadway Fixture on 30 ht Valmont pole Sternberg Pedestrian Fixture on 11-3 fluted pole with Augusta base Sternberg Lighted Bollard 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 15
LIGHTING NEW ELEMENTS Decorative poles and festoon lighting Street light décor 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 16
LIGHTING HIERARCHY 7 Kim / Valmont Sternberg Roadway Pole Festoon (existing) Pole 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 17 Sternberg Combination Pole Sternberg Standard Pole (existing)
COMMUNITY IDENTITY GATEWAY & WAYFINDING SIGNAGE Gateway Sign Optional stone base Optional internal illumination Gateway Sign Optional internal illumination 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 18 Directional Sign 4 letter ht (IDOT ROW) Directional Sign 3 letter ht (local ROW)
COMMUNITY IDENTITY GATEWAY & WAYFINDING SIGNAGE Identity Banner Fabric or Metal Options Parking Identifier Custom bracket options Parking Directional Sign Business Directory Kiosk Bicycle Route Directional Sign 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 19
STREETSCAPE CHARACTER TYPOLOGIES Shopping / Dining Street Transitional Street Throughfare Street Bridge Crossing 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 20
SHOPPING AND DINING STREET TYPOLOGY Chestnut Street 13.5 MIN. 8 MIN. 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 21
SHOPPING AND DINING STREET TYPOLOGY Chestnut Street 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 22
SPRUCE ST BIRCH ST CHESTNUT ST 13 ELM LINCOLN AVE ST OAK ST 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 23 SHOPPING & DINING STREETS / ELM STREET BRIDGE
KIM / VALMONT ROADWAY POLE SPRUCE ST STERNBERG FESTOON POLE STERNBERG COMBINATION POLE BIRCH ST CHESTNUT ST 14 ELM LINCOLN AVE ST STERNBERG STANDARD POLE OAK ST LIGHTING HIERARCHY 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 24
GATEWAY SIGN SPRUCE ST NEW COMMUNITY EVENTS SIGN BUSINESS DIRECTORY KIOSK SCULPTURE PAD BIRCH ST CHESTNUT ST 15 ELM LINCOLN AVE ST OAK ST GATEWAY SIGNS, BUSINESS DIRECTORY KIOSKS & SCULPTURE PADS 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 25
SPRUCE ST NW QUADRANT NE QUADRANT BIRCH ST CHESTNUT ST 16 ELM LINCOLN AVE ST SW QUADRANT SE QUADRANT OAK ST 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 26
SPRUCE ST CHESTNUT ST ELM ST NW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 27
The Hudson Company Chamber of Commerce PARKING EXISTING PROPOSED SPRUCE ST Chestnut St (north of Elm) 44 37 {-7} Starbucks Elm St (east of Chestnut) 23 18 {-5} Scissors Edge Marian Michael Avli Estiatorio Elm St (west of Chestnut) 15 11 {-4} Avli Rotisserie Classic Kids Marlene s Nail Fred s Garage Emporium Caffe Buon Giorno Doyle Optician 18 Neopolitan Zia Gallery Sparkly Nails Little Ian s CHESTNUT ST Denim & Soul Bleachers Sports & Training Kaehler Luggage True Juice Classic Stitch Crystal Cleaners Botanic Nails & Spa Ellens on Elm Athene Noahs Ark Pet Supply Berkshire Hathaway Chestnut Florist Peet s Coffee Book Stall Village Toy Shop Michelle s Cleaners Chase JP Morgan NW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 28
Planter Pots / Bollards SPRUCE ST Kim/Valmont Pole Business Directory Kiosk In Ground Planter (Existing Tree, Benches, Starbucks Litter/Recycling, Bike Racks) Café Seating Decorative Paving CHESTNUT ST Fred s Garage Sidewalk with Paving Ribbon NW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 29
True Juice Berkshire Hathaway CHESTNUT ST Peet s Coffee Combination Sternberg Light / Festoon Pole Seating Cluster (Optional Sculpture Pad or Fireplace) Bike Racks In Ground Planter Michelle s Chase JP (Ex Tree, Benches, Cleaner Litter/Recycling, Bike Racks) Morgan Alley Café Seating Business Directory Kiosk ELM ST Planter Pots / Bollards Kim/Valmont Light Pole Decorative Paving ELM ST Bliss Salon Citibank Christian Science Reading Room Lakeside Foods Alley NW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 30
ELM ST CHESTNUT ST OAK ST SW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 31
22 Post Office CHESTNUT ST Bliss Salon Citibank Heffernan Christian Science Reading Room Lakeside Foods BMO Harris OAK ST SW QUADRANT H Gary Frank Architects Good Grapes Hair Couture Bellas Day Spa Trifecta Grill PARKING EXISTING PROPOSED Chestnut St (south of Elm) 26 18 {-8} Winnetka Village Hall Spynergy Home Ice Bratschii Plumbing 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 32 CHESTNUT CT
Sternberg Light Good Grapes Seating Cluster Café Seating 23 CHESTNUT STREET CHESTNUT CT Sidewalk / Curb Replacement Existing trees in open pits New Benches Business Directory Kiosk Sculpture Pad Decorative Paving Sidewalk with Paving Ribbon SW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 33
Sternberg Light / Planter Pots 24 Combination Light / Planter Pots Garden Wall & Plantings Trifecta Grill Bench Planter Pot Litter/Recycling Crosswalk OAK STREET SW QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 34
ELM ST GREEN BAY ROAD LINCOLN AVE SE QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 35
LINCOLN AVE 26 GREEN BAY ROAD Metra Station SE QUADRANT Future One Winnetka Site Café Aroma Maize Home New Trier Township Elm Cleaners Trueman Catering One Winnetka Office (pending) Winnetka Dental Group Arborvitae Park PARKING EXISTING PROPOSED Elm St (east of Lincoln) 38 31 {-7} Lincoln Ave (south of Elm, east side) 20 15 {-5} 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 36
Bump Outs / Mid Block Crossing Planter Pots Little Ricky s Rib Joint LINCOLN AVENUE SE QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 37 Festoon Light Bollards / Planter Pots Bike Racks Sculpture Pad / Plantings Benches
Little Ricky s Rib Joint LINCOLN AVENUE Café Aroma Business Directory Kiosk Festoon Light ALLEY Kim / Valmont Pole Seating Cluster (Optional Fireplace or Sculpture Pad) Combination Pole / Festoon Decorative Paving ELM STREET Future One Winnetka Site SE QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 38
29 LINCOLN AVE NE QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 39
PARKING EXISTING PROPOSED Lincoln Ave (north of Elm) 70 58 {-12} Jameson/Sotheby s International Realty Brady & Ford Orthodontics North Shore Community Bank and Trust S&A Chiropractic Beauty Lash Elm St Pediatrics Coldwell Banker TJ Cullen Jeweler N Shore Frugal Fashionista Blow Dry Boutique Your Loss Your Gain Body Gear Physical Therapy LINCOLN AVE Donald Stuart Antiques M. Stephanich Antiques Mirani s at Home J. McLaughlin Conlon Christies Real Estate Sara Campbell KMK Consignment Optique AJ Retreat Oui Madame Spa Nail City Fitness Together Bake 425 Face Forward Spa Little Ricky s Rib Joint Orrington Jewelers Stacked & Folded Mark Beard LTD Café Aroma Maize Home Elm Cleaners Truman Catering Arborvitae Park NE QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 40 ELM ST
Decorative Paving at Crosswalk Planter / Seating Cluster Combination Pole / Planter Pots Jameson/ Sotheby s International Realty North Shore Community Bank and Trust LINCOLN AVENUE Planter / Bike Racks Brady & Ford Orthodontics S&A Chiropractic NE QUADRANT 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 41
PARKING SUMMARY PARKING EXISTING PROPOSED {#} represents existing parking spaces converted to landscaped bump out / seating areas. Chestnut St (north of Elm) 44 37 {-7} Chestnut St (south of Elm) 26 18 {-8} Elm St (east of Chestnut) 23 18 {-5} Elm St (west of Chestnut) 15 11 {-4} Elm St (east of Lincoln) 38 31 {-7} Lincoln Ave (south of Elm, east side) 20 15 {-5} Lincoln Ave (north of Elm) 70 58 {-12} TOTALS 236 188 {-48} Conceptual parking quantities are calculated for Shopping and Dining Street areas only and are based on aerial photography and past planning studies. 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 42
TREE IMPACT AREAS SPRUCE ST TOTAL TREE IMPACTS Tree plantings are relocated from sidewalks to landscaped bump out / seating areas WEST 1 Tree preservation Tree removals 3 20 New trees 18 WEST 2 Tree preservation 0 WEST 3 WEST 1 CHESTNUT ST 33 ELM Tree preservation 19 Tree removals 90 New trees 59 Net decrease 31 WEST 2 EAST 2 LINCOLN AVE ST EAST 1 EAST 1 Tree preservation Tree removals 0 23 New trees 14 EAST 2 Tree preservation 1 Tree removals 13 Tree removals 22 New trees 5 WEST 3 Tree preservation 15 WEST 3 GREEN BAY ROAD New trees 8 Tree removals 12 New trees 14 OAK ST 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 43
STREETSCAPE BUDGET COSTS: PROJECT CATEGORIES & ELEMENTS Roadway & Drainage Site mobilization; curb & gutter remove and replace; pavement resurfacing; tree protection & removals; pavement marking; detectable warning plates; drainage allowance. Lighting & Support Infrastructure Hardscape & Furnishings Signage Plantings Kim/ Valmont pole remove and replace, Sternberg standard poles; Sternberg combination poles, Sternberg festoon poles, fest and décor elements; bollards; underground utility allowance. Clay brick pavers, jointed concrete sidewalk, benches, planter pots, litter & recycling. Gateway signs (not illuminated), business directory kiosks, community events sign. Trees, shrubs, perennials/groundcover, soils, mulches. Streetscape budget costs are provided for Village planning purposes. Costs are derived based on past planning efforts, aerial photography and site reviews. Final design and engineering is required to produce final cost estimates. 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 44
SPRUCE ST WEST 1 EAST 2 WEST 3 CHESTNUT ST 35 ELM WEST 2 BRIDGE LINCOLN AVE ST EAST 1 WEST 3 OAK ST 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 45 STREETSCAPE BUDGET COSTS: PROJECT AREAS
WEST 1 Roadway & Drainage $456,000 SPRUCE ST Lighting & Support Infrastructure $862,000 Hardscape & Furnishings $655,000 WEST 1 Signage $ 80,000 Plantings $ 54,000 TOTAL $2,107,000 WEST 3 CHESTNUT ST 36 WEST 2 WEST 2 Roadway & Drainage $223,000 Lighting & Support Infrastructure $315,000 Hardscape & Furnishings $183,000 Signage -- Plantings $ 23,000 TOTAL $744,000 WEST 3 WEST 3 Roadway & Drainage $244,000 Lighting & Support Infrastructure $498,000 Hardscape & Furnishings $524,000 Signage $115,000 OAK ST 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 46 Plantings $ 48,000 TOTAL $1,429,000
BRIDGE Roadway & Drainage $ 90,000 Lighting & Support Infrastructure $ 5,000 Hardscape & Furnishings $199,000 Signage $ 50,000 Plantings $ 6,500 TOTAL $350,500 EAST 1 Roadway & Drainage $610,000 Lighting & Support Infrastructure $795,000 EAST 2 LINCOLN AVE STREETSCAPE SUMMARY WEST 1 $2,107,000 WEST 2 $ 744,000 WEST 3 $1,429,000 BRIDGE $ 350,500 EAST 1 $2,197,000 EAST 2 $1,161,000 TOTAL $7,988,500 Hardscape & Furnishings $659,000 Signage $ 65,000 BRIDGE ELM ST EAST 1 Plantings $ 68,000 TOTAL $2,197,000 EAST 2 Roadway & Drainage $356,000 Lighting & Support Infrastructure $374,000 Hardscape & Furnishings $380,000 GREEN BAY ROAD Signage $ 15,000 Plantings $ 36,000 TOTAL $1,161,000 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 47
COMMUNITY IDENTITY WAYFINDING SIGNAGE WAYFINDING SIGNAGE Roadway Directional Signs $155,000 Bike Route Directional Signs $100,000 Parking Identifiers & Directional Signs $130,000 Fabric Banners $8,000 TOTAL $393,000 Gateway signs, business directory kiosks & community events signs accounted for in the streetscape budgets 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 48
IMPLEMENTATION PRINCIPLES 1. Streetscape should live within a budget & funding sources to be determined by the Council; 2. Streetscape improvements that benefit Winnetka s residents should be higher priority; 3. Streetscape improvements to shopping/dining streets & intersections should be higher priority; 4. Streetscape improvements should coordinate public & private improvements with proposed streetscape improvements to maximize implementation efficiency; 5. Streetscape improvements should be phased so as to minimize disruption to businesses; 6. When phasing streetscape improvements, minimize disruption to streetscape improvements made in previous phases. 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 49
SPRUCE ST WEST 1 EAST 2 WEST 3 CHESTNUT ST 40 ELM WEST 2 BRIDGE LINCOLN AVE ST EAST 1 ONE WINNETKA DEVELOPMENT FUTURE POST OFFICE REDEVELOPMENT WEST 3 OAK ST PHASING DISCUSSION 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 50
NEXT STEPS: Teska advances the Final Streetscape & Signage Plan March 31 Public Outreach - Egg Hunt Event April 3 Village Council Meeting April 24 Task Force Meeting May 15 Village Council Meeting Help us spread the word! WWW.WINNETKADOWNTOWNPLAN.COM 2-26-18 DMP Task Force Agenda Packet - Page 51