UCSF Parnassus Heights Re-Envisioning Process Community Working Group Meeting #5 February 27, 2019
Agenda Welcome, Introductions, Agenda Overview, and Review of Last Meeting Summary of Community Ideas (Working Draft) - Community Working Group Discussion Preferred Alternative - Community Working Group Discussion Environmental Review Public Comment Next Steps 2
Review of Last Meeting 3
Review of Last Meeting Meeting Topics Parnassus Heights Campus Walking Tour Citywide Planning Overview Initial Framework for CPHP Community Planning and Design Principles Design Principles and Emerging Concepts What We Heard Think about creative housing solutions, including short-term for patients and their families Consider navigation/wayfinding through and within campus Explore different ways for people to arrive and flow through the campus Consider event space to bring people to campus 4
Summary of Community Ideas (Working Draft) 5
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft Community Ideas Overview Major Categories 1 Housing 2 Campus Design 3 Connectivity with Nature 4 Multi-Modal Mobility 5 Public Realm 6 Programs and Amenities that Benefit the Neighborhood 6
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft 1. Housing 1.1 Allow for a range of creative housing options on campus that meet the needs of students, faculty, staff. 1.2 Allow for safe and convenient housing for patients and their families through on-campus and off-campus opportunities, including short-term rentals in the neighborhood. UCSF can serve as an information and referral resource for this. 1.3 Avoid displacement of existing residential units or individuals who could be displaced by converting housing to other uses. Continue the UCSF practice of not acquiring existing residential property for non-residential use. 1.4 Minimize impacts of additional housing on traffic and other infrastructure. 1.5 Consider partnerships with developers to provide workforce housing. 7
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft 2. Campus Design 2.1 Create a welcoming environment and a framework to the overall site design that helps make it comprehensible. 2.2 Take advantage of the topography of the site: open up view corridors and provide opportunities both within buildings and in the outdoor spaces to enjoy the views. 2.3 Provide open spaces and opportunities for social gatherings throughout the campus. 8
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft 3. Connectivity with Nature 3.1 Connect to open space opportunities such as Golden Gate Park and Mount Sutro. 3.2 Enhance access to open space within the campus, including to Mount Sutro. 3.3 Incorporate green design throughout the campus. 3.4 Enhance landscaping to soften edges along streets and buildings. 9
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft 4. Multi-Modal Mobility 4.1 Address impacts of vehicular trips to and from the Parnassus campus using enhanced Traffic Demand Management strategies. 4.2 Create a welcoming and accessible environment, including for those arriving by public transit. 4.3 Implement traffic management and calming measures. 4.4 Ensure easy pedestrian access through the site using stairs, tunnels and skyways, with consideration to those with mobility challenges. 10
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft 5. Public Realm 5.1 Provide for an activated campus frontage along Irving Street that is welcoming and accessible to all modes, especially transit. 5.2 Improve the streetscape experience of Parnassus Avenue. 5.3 Integrate the campus with the surrounding neighborhoods. 11
Summary of Community Ideas Working Draft 6. Programs and Amenities that Benefit the Neighborhood 6.1 Provide space on campus to house local non-profit organizations or community health and wellness services. 6.2 Create program and event spaces to bring people to campus to encourage evening and weekend activity. 6.3 Enhance retail, food and recreation opportunities for all campus residents and visitors, both on and off campus. 6.4 Enhance relationship between UCSF PD and the neighborhood. 6.5 Make the Parnassus campus easy to navigate through clear and attractive signage and wayfinding methods. 12
Community Working Group Discussion 13
Preferred Alternative 14
A FLEXIBLE PLAN Bold Vision to Change the Campus Near-term initiatives Vision at 2040 Site plan based on opportunities Design tools for bulk/height/scale Priority programs as articulated by faculty working groups and stakeholders how the vision can address them? Siting criteria and suggested locations for programs Implementation priorities Illustrative concepts for select elements
WHERE WE VE BEEN UCSF VISIONING 6 BIG IDEAS DRAFT ALTERNATIVES INPUT Utility Master Planning INPUT Benchmarking Peer Institutions INPUT Structural feasibility study INPUT UCSF Department Feedback INPUT High Level Costing and Circulation Impact assessment INPUT Building Code compliance survey INPUT Faculty Working Group Reports Public INPUT Community Working Group (on-going) Public INPUT Neighbor And Employee Survey Public INPUT Public Open House (ongoing) PREFERRED ALTERATIVE FINAL PLAN IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGIES 16
UCSF S PERSPECTIVE ON SHAPING THE PLAN A range of solutions is possible UCSF is seeking flexibility to be responsive to changing and unknown conditions Building conditions are still under study, results in March Preferred Alternative assumes that some larger buildings on campus may be replaced Parnassus Heights continues to be the seat of the four professional schools and the Graduate Division, prioritizes improving the patient experience and improving select areas of advanced research What We Heard UCSF project priorities: Enhance patient and visitor experience Contemporize research space Be bold! Engage philanthropic community 17
FLEXIBLE OPPORTUNITIES CPHP proposed renovations / improvements New build opportunity sites CPHP proposed demolitions Millberry ACC Library UC Hall CSB MSB Moffitt Long Dolby HSW HSE PSB Assumption for Preferred Alternative: Existing programs in buildings to be demolished would remain on campus. 18
COMMUNITY IDEAS Campus Design Public Realm Connection with Nature Multi-Modal Mobility Housing Neighborhood Programs and Amenities 19
CAMPUS DESIGN Overall Site Design ACADEMIC + RESEARCH COMMONS Create convergence between research, education and clinical uses; design new connections; create the campus heart. NORTH SIDE GATEWAY Orient patients and visitors with improved arrival and strategically locate programs to integrate with the neighborhood (learning, wellness, food, hospitality). CLINICAL EAST END Focus clinical activities, improve wayfinding, access and logistics. ALDEA Update and increase housing stock to better meet student and trainee housing demand. WEST SIDE Extend the campus. Include new park-to-peak connections and access routes. Explore options for housing and research programs. SERVICE CORRIDOR Improve functionality, emergency access, long-term resilience, service and distribution.
CAMPUS DESIGN Existing San Francisco Height Limits 40 feet (3 Stories) 65 feet (5 Stories) 80 feet (6 Stories) 130 feet (8 Stories) 220 feet (15 Stories Max) RH-2 (residential) zoning Established in 1972, based on building heights at the time 21 City of San Francisco Zoning and Height Map
CAMPUS DESIGN Zoning and Heights (40 ) 3 Stories (65 ) 5 Stories (80 ) 6 Stories (130 ) 8 Stories (220 ) 15 Stories RH-2 (residential) zoning Flexibility will allow for rejuvenated Irving St. and future arrival. Transition zone to neighborhood Transition zone potential for student housing, extended campus programs. Opportunity sites against hillside HSIR 15 stories New hospital opportunity site 22
CAMPUS DESIGN Topography and Scale Propose a new campus image with Millberry Garage and MSB façade reskinning Position taller buildings to rear along the hillside Maintain visual connection to Mount Sutro by preserving building sites and scale DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION New build opportunity within existing envelope Taller buildings closer to hillside Reskinned garages and buildings 23
CAMPUS DESIGN Welcoming Environment Make public access areas more comprehensible Improve sightlines, clarify reception areas with generous lobbies Strategically locate active uses to ground floor spaces (retail, food services, event spaces) HOSPITAL SITE PUBLIC ARRIVAL SCHOOLS RECEPTION + ADMINISTRATION UCSF RESEARCH FRONT DOOR UCSF STAFF/FACULTY ARRIVAL PUBLIC ARRIVAL PUBLIC ZONE 24
PUBLIC REALM Enhance Arrival at Irving Street, Connecting to Parnassus Avenue MILLBERRY GARAGE Ambulatory Care Center LIBRARY PARNASSUS Moffitt 25
PUBLIC REALM Arrival at Irving Street, Connecting to Parnassus Avenue MILLBERRY GARAGE LIBRARY Ambulatory Care Center RESEARCH PARNASSUS AVE Moffitt 26
PUBLIC REALM Arrival at Irving Street DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION Reskinned garage facades Better transit integration Welcoming entrance for improved wayfinding Increased drop-off opportunities with better curb space 27
PUBLIC REALM Millberry Garage Roof Today Food court blocks views to Parnassus Ave. Opportunity for views and gathering space currently used for parking 28
PUBLIC REALM Potential Millberry Terrace DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION MSB front door Transparent ground levels with retail Improved connection to Parnassus Ave. Indoor/outdoor gathering spaces with views 29
PUBLIC REALM 5 th and Parnassus Today Faculty housing, historic homes PARNASSUS AVE 5 th AVE. 4-story building scale Difficult to discern campus arrival
PUBLIC REALM Potential Arrival at 5 th and Parnassus Western arrival at Parnassus Avenue and 5 th Avenue Enhance street presence, create a comprehensible campus DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION New campus presence on Parnassus Ave. Opportunity for new entry signage 31 Opportunity for streetscape improvements
PUBLIC REALM 5 th and Kirkham Today Opportunity site Opportunity site 32
PUBLIC REALM Potential 5 th and Kirkham DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION Opportunity for taller buildings along the hillside 4Th AVE Opportunity for housing KIRKHAM AVE 5 th AVE Opportunity for new, expanded child care 33
MULTI-MODAL MOBILITY Access Improvements Renew option for 4 th Avenue to serve west campus Address need to expand passenger drop-off and ride hail Implement the Parnassus Avenue Streetscape Plan Streetscape improvement Opportunity sites for additional drop-off areas New fire access New 4 th Ave. connection Locations for additional drop-off areas and the impact on circulation is under study. A future of mobility assessment helps future-proof solutions. 34
MULTI-MODAL MOBILITY Logistics, Delivery, Fire Access Upgrade emergency access Modernize delivery systems Expand existing capacity at docks in coordination with future buildings Support resilience and sustainability goals with infrastructure and utility upgrades Long-term plan for new pedestrian park-to-peak link Future service/delivery route with connection into new 4 th Avenue New fire access Utility Loop Security checkpoint 35
MULTI-MODAL MOBILITY Pedestrian and Patient Safety Improve access between acute care and ambulatory care to avoid unnecessary vehicle trips and need to cross Parnassus Avenue Improve patient and visitor safety Support research and clinical collaborations for UCSF workforce Clarify path from visitor arrival to hospital entry Support resilience and sustainability goals with Utility Loop completion Unified lobby extends from Irving St. to Parnassus Ave. Back-of-house logistics link Bridge/tunnel across Parnassus Ave. 36
CONNECTION WITH NATURE Park to Peak Improve access to Mount Sutro Open Space Reserve with new Sunset Trail (Park to Peak) Create clear routes through campus Bring Mount Sutro into campus with landscape and outdoor terraces
NATURE CONNECTIVITY Park to Peak Extend Saunders Court towards the west Potential for new park on the west side of campus Opportunity to expand Saunders Ct. New open space at Millberry Terrace Westside connections to Mount Sutro
CONNECTION WITH NATURE Design for Climate Design indoor/outdoor spaces that are usable year-round and protect visitors from weather elements Strategically locate campus public space to enhance views and comfort Account for site challenges (prevailing winds, topography, fog) and site opportunities (views, exposure, nature proximity) 39
HOUSING Preferred Alternative Approaches Explore housing expansion in coordination with planned new housing projects Residential city zoning Sites under study for patient family hotel Housing to remain Housing to remain Explore opportunity for student housing and/or multifamily on west side Explore increasing capacity at Aldea to better meet 2025 student/trainee demand 40
NEIGHBORHOOD PROGRAMS Wellness and the Patient /Visitor Journey 1. Hospitality lounge space within new hospital 2. Front door to outpatient services, lounge and marketplace 3. Wellness: outdoor spaces, healthy food, physical therapy, gym 4. Community-facing program spaces allow for teaching, learning and seminar support spaces 5. Collaboration and convening on-campus Clinical Support / Campus Community Research Public Open Space 41
Community Working Group Discussion 42
Environmental Review 43
Environmental Impact Report (EIR) Timeline Draft EIR Publication Spring 2020 Public Review and Hearing Spring 2020 Reponses to Comments Summer 2020 Final EIR Certification by Regents Fall 2020 44
Public Comment 45
Next Steps 46
Next Steps Next meeting date - Thursday, April 25, 2019 Millberry Union 6:30 p.m. Community Open House #2 - Wednesday, March 20, 2019 Millberry Union 6:30 p.m. 47