DETECTING WRONG WAY DRIVERS. Lynne Randolph Southwest Research Institute (210)

Transcription

1 DETECTING WRONG WAY DRIVERS Lynne Randolph Southwest Research Institute (210)

2 BACKGROUND 2

3 WIDESPREAD ISSUE ACROSS MULTIPLE STATES 3

4 WHAT ARE THE CAUSES? Impaired driving ability DUI/DWI (Majority of cases) Elderly/confused Distracted Problematic intersections Access from frontage roads! Turns onto ramps Unclear signage and road markings 4

5 CURRENT DETECTION METHODS Doppler or microwave radar detectors False positives occur too frequently to rely on detections Video imaging Can also provide snapshots (low light means the car cannot be easily identified) Can be used in conjunction with Doppler or radar detectors for confirmation May not be best in low light situations, which is when most events occur Thermal sensors Detections do not always occur In-pavement sensors (inductive or magnetic) Expensive to install and maintain Detections often require vehicle to remain in lane 5

6 COST-EFFECTIVE PREVENTATIVE MEASURES Improvements to wrong way signs Adding more signs, especially on both sides of ramps Lowering the heights of signs to improve visibility Enhanced, larger signs with reflective tape and LED lighting Enhanced pavement markings for entrance and exit ramps Modifying traffic signals (straight arrow discouraging turns on exit ramps) Changes to intersections such as removal of obstructions, channels in roadway, etc. 6

7 WRONG WAY SIGNS 7

8 ENHANCED SIGNS AND PAVEMENT MARKINGS 8

9 VEHICLE MANUFACTURERS Nissan, Toyota Using internal data, alerts the wrong way driver Limitations: GPS, relies on mapping data which may change Mercedes-Benz Adds camera sensor recognition of wrong way signs to the internal data Limitations: Obscured signs, other visibility issues in addition to GPS/map data issues Both types only warn the wrong way driver 9

10 EXAMPLE IN-VEHICLE WARNING 10

11 ENTERPRISE POOLED FUND STUDY Share information between the states What has been deployed What works What still needs more work No one solution Improved signage helps the driver self correct Still need better detection and notification to the traffic management center 11

12 TXDOT WWD ACTIVITIES 12

13 SOLUTIONS TO ALERT AND NOTIFY TxDOT wants wrong way detection to the traffic management center Many solutions want to provide their own notifications Must first go to the vendor s website Subject to network problems TxDOT does NOT want this type of solution May use during initial trial period, but not a long term option TxDOT s Lonestar software supports multiple wrong way detection devices Provides alerts and alarms to operators Sends and text notifications 13

14 LONESTAR ALERTS, ALARMS, REPORTS Josephine Josephine Josephine Josephine Josephine Josephine 14

15 RADAR DETECTION Added support to Lonestar for detection, alerting, reporting Wavetronix HD Used on main lanes to detect wrong way Reported too many false positives, even after Wavetronix provided a firmware update TAPCO (single detection) Used on ramps to detect wrong way Reported too many false positives 15

16 TAPCO DUAL RADAR AND CAMERA TAPCO revised their device to add another radar detector and a camera Radar: one inbound and one outbound directed Camera: detects wrong way driver and confirms both radars When triggered, the camera can provide snapshots both before and after the trigger time 16

17 TAPCO EXAMPLE SNAPSHOTS Without Illuminator With Illuminator 17

18 TAPCO: WHAT S NEW TAPCO Wrong Way Logic Module TAPCO Control By Web Illuminator for low light pictures 18

19 TAPCO PROS AND CONS Advantages Triple detection and TAPCO logic unit result in lower false positives Receive snapshots when alert is triggered Cost includes TAPCO configuring the unit for each location s specific needs Disadvantages Camera detection cannot be included over 40 MPH False positive rate unproven in the field, will be testing in the Fort Worth district 19

20 TRAFFICVISION Not just WWD, includes incident detection Installing in Fort Worth for a pilot test Setup early Jan 2017 Trial starts Jan 15 th and will last through Mar 15 th Hoping to get incident detections from ice during this time During trial, cameras will be on a web page and flash when incident is detected Houston district did a pilot test earlier in the year 20

21 TRAFFICALM Uses multiple radar units with optional camera San Antonio planning to install and test Arizona DOT has installed and is pleased with the results Advantages Cheaper Mounts on existing poles Will initially test with Trafficalm alerts without integrating with Lonestar 21

22 CONNECTED VEHICLE Connected Vehicle WWD Detection and Management System under development First phase completed Concept of operations Functional requirements High level system design Second phase under way Test corridor identified Will use connected vehicle pods for testing Will also be testing with the TAPCO devices 22

23 FDOT WWD ACTIVITIES 23

24 SUNGUIDE WWD ALARMS Quickly alerts operator of WWD event Cameras move to presets automatically Text and notifications Operator can create an event to manage 24

25 SUNGUIDE WWD EVENT OPTIONS Automatically created Automatically created and DMS messages activated Alarm which can be turned into an event 25

26 DEVICE TESTING RESULTS Click512 module Used with Wavetronix HD Provides immediate alerts False positive rate too high for automating public messaging TAPCO Initial device showed similar results to TxDOT Have not tried the newer units yet 26

27 FDOT CONNECTED VEHICLE DEMO Vehicle to Infrastructure (V2I) Connected vehicle reports location Infrastructure determines vehicle is going wrong way Notification is sent to the TMC Messages to vehicles sent from TMC Wrong way driver receives message Other affected drivers receive warning messages 27

28 ROADSIDE UNIT Installed at mast arm intersection Communicates with vehicles and FDOT SunGuide software Performs local processing to facilitate applications (i.e. wrong way detection) 28

29 VEHICLE ONBOARD UNIT Portable units used in vehicles Contains the communication equipment and local processing unit Displays information in the vehicle Eventually, vehicle manufacturers will include their own displays or other types of feedback 29

30 DEMO VIDEO 32

31 QUESTIONS? Lynne Randolph Staff Engineer Southwest Research Institute (210)