WELCOME. Scott Provost Water Resources Specialist - WDNR Wisconsin Rapids, WI

Transcription

1 WELCOME Scott Provost Water Resources Specialist - WDNR Wisconsin Rapids, WI

2 Water Level Flux to Control AIS and Restore Impoundments

3 WHY? Restore natural ebb and flow Restore natural rhythm of ecosystem Evolution of plants and animals Allows a system to heal Increase diversity Good health management of lake. Can control some AIS (EWM) It s a good thing

4 Oops Area

5 Water Level Cycling in Natural Lakes The Ordinary Year Lake levels determined by rain and snow

6 Water Level Cycling in Natural Lakes The Low Year Emergent plants expand excess nutrients used Littoral Zone (may be found deeper)

7 Water Level Cycling in Natural Lakes Return to Ordinary Year Expanded emergent plants become aquatic habitat Littoral Zone (usually rises)

8 Example Low Year: Expansion of lake sedge Montello Lake, WI

9 Example Low Year: Expansion of three-square bulrush Wood Lake, WI Scirpus americanus (Three-square bulrush)

10 Example Low Year: Expansion of Fassett s Locoweed Plainfield Lake, WI OHWM

11 Return to normal water level

12 Example: Flooded vegetation following low Lake Pucaway, WI

13 Example: Flooded vegetation following low year McDill Pond

14 Understanding and Using the Tool Mimic Mother Nature. Used Nationally - USGS (Great Lakes Science Center) Used in Wisconsin - NER, WCR

15 Dessication: How does this work?

16 Aeration: How does this work? O 2 CO 2

17 Freezing: How does this work?

18 # of INTOLERANT (Emergents) # of TOLERANT (submergents) Benefit of Alternation Drawdown tolerant vs drawdown intolerant Water Level Flux Practices Sustained artificial levels DIVERSITY (emergents and submergents)

19 Case Studies McDill Pond Marion Millpond Montello Lake Alpine Lake Lake Thoma (in progress)

20 Percen Frequency (%) Ceratophyllum demersum Myriophyllum spicatum Najas flexilis Elodea canadensis Nitella spp. McDill - pre-dd, post +1yr, post +2yr Potamogeton epihydrus Myriophyllum sibiricum filamentous algae Potamogeton praelongus Nymphaea odorata Potamogeton richardsonii Stuckenia pectinata Chara Utricularia vulgaris Lemna minor Myriophyllum heterophyllum Sagittaria sp. Spirodeta polyrhiza Carex camosa Heteranthera dubia Iris versicolor Nuphar variegata Phalaris arnudinacea Potamogeton natans Potamogeton pusillus Potamogeton zosterfromis Schoenoplectus tabernaemonani Sparganium eurycarpum Wolfia columbiana Zannichellia palustris Pre and Post Drawdown Aquatic Plant Frequency, McDill Pond Pre Post yr 2 Species

21 FQI McDill Change in FQI McDIll FQI pre-dd, post +1, post FQI n FQI n FQI n FQI 20 n Year

22 Partial Winter Drawdown Marion Millpond, WI September though April

23 Percent Frequency Pre/Post Winter Drawdowon at Marion Millpond submergent species Eurasian water-milfoil Coontail, hornwort Curly-leaf pondweed Northern Watermilfoil Flat-stem pondweed Muskgrasses Elodea Sago pondweed Floating Leaf Pondweed White-Stem Pondweed Wild celery Water stargrass Water Moss Long Leaf Pondweed Small pondweed Bushy Pondweed Common Bladderwort Large-leaf Pondweed Clasping-leaf Pondweed Species Jun-2005 frequency Jul-2005 frequency Aug-2007 frequency Aug-2008 frequency

24 FQI Following Winter DD Marion Millpond, WI Floristic Quality Index of Marion Millpond Pre and Post Winter Water Flux pre June 2005 pre July 2005 post August 2007 Aug-2008

25 Percent Frequency Emergent Species Pre/Post Winter Drawdown at Marion Millpond Broad-leaved cattail Softstem bulrush Common arrowhead Arum Leaved Arrowhead Rice Cutgrass Wild Rice Beggarticks Common burreed Species Jun-2005 frequency Jul-2005 frequency Aug-2007 frequency Aug-2008 frequency

26 Partial Winter Drawdown Alpine Lake, WI September though April

27

28 Using the Tool for AIS Control Used Internationally Czech Republic, et al. Used Nationally TVA, WA, OR, NY, CN, WI, MN, Used in Wisconsin NER, WCR Paul Skawinski Paul Skawinski Climates capable of freezing; southern states less control

29 EWM Control McDill Millpond Pre DD EWM frequency 55.1% Post DD EWM frequency *% Post DD EWM frequency % * 0% observed at the time of survey but found later in August

30 EWM Control Marion Millpond Pre DD EWM frequency 73.9% Post DD EWM frequency 5.0%

31 EWM Control Alpine Lake Pre DD EWM frequency 69.7% Post DD EWM frequency 9.2%

32 Partial Winter Drawdown Montello Lake, WI September though April

33 EWM Control Montello Lake Pre DD EWM frequency ~80* % Post DD EWM frequency ~ 6* % * Different survey methods

34 Sounds great, but. Short-term fishery Impacts - flow is key Physical constraints dam capabilities Economic impacts tourism, fisheries, industrial, hydro power Social concerns history, emotions Frame it correctly! That s why..

35 Know how to proceed Good Plan (not just a plan) Identify objectives Simultaneous 2-prong approach science socio-economic I and E history dictates amount You Need a Plan!

36 2 Prong Approach Science Recent plant data mapped with bathymetry Fisheries and WQ data, T/E/SC/Anthro, AA Identify responsible parties use MILESTONE Cooperation and transparency Socio-Economic Contingency Contingency Fuse Verify feasibility Summarized survey data, economic impacts, ownership, wells Cooperation and transparency I and E until it hurts (tell em what you told them and then tall em again)

37 2 Prong Approach Plan/Action Holistic Plan, with public input, specific to objective Permit process started early (4-6 months before start) Ready for survey work (AP and public? survey) Contingency plan ready Your changing the lake to this, be ready!

38 Almost Done! In Summary! Water level flux has been successfully employed in Wisconsin for AIS and restoration Solid plan needed (objectives, pre and post) More long-term monitoring needed I and E needed for society Frame it correctly you re fighting this image

39 QUESTIONS Thank You! Where s McLennan!?!