Monday 7 April 2014 Hearing Day 1 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale. Opening Statements

Transcription

1 / Party Reference 9:30 a.m. Hōkai Nuku Pōwhiri Break as part of the powhiri Board of Inquiry Introduction Board NZ Transport Agency Applicant Paula Brosnahan Project Introduction Applicant Flyover presentation NZ Transport Agency Applicant Paula Brosnahan Opening Statement Applicant Opening 1:15 p.m. Lunch NZ Transport Agency Applicant Paula Brosnahan Opening Statement (Continu) Applicant Opening The National Trading Company of New Zealand (NTC) Douglas Allan Opening Statement Support in full Opening 0:10 David Mason David Mason Opening Statement Support in part Opening Teall Crossen Opening Statement Oppose in part Opening 1:30 Draft Hearing Schule - Ara Tūhono - Pūhoi to Wellsford Road of National Significance: Pūhoi to Warkworth Section Please note: 1) The draft hearing schule is subject to change, due to the length of presentations, cross examination, witness availability and/or other questions. 2) A specific day or time cannot be guarante. Parties may ne to wait for the prior presenter to finish and/or you may ne to be available the day before or after the day schul. 3) If you have an next to your name you will be to be at the venue by 10am. 4) If you have a next to your name you will be to be at the venue by 1:45pm. 5) Please advise the EPA of any periods of unavailability as soon as possible Call , or puhoi@epa.govt.nz 6) Unless otherwise advis, hearing times are from 10.00am to 5.00pm with a lunch break from pm. Monday 7 April 2014 Hearing Day 1 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Opening Statements Tuesday 8 April Hearing Day 2 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Evidence Overview (from the applicant) and Consultation by the Applicant Print Date: 11:28 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Tommy Parker Evidence overview Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Tommy Parker Applicant Ferat Farmers 0:25 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Tommy Parker Applicant Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Tommy Parker Applicant Roger Williams 0:25 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Patrick Kelly Evidence - Consultation Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Patrick Kelly Applicant 0:05 Page 1

2 / Party Reference Alternatives and Design and Traffic and Transport NZ Transport Agency Applicant Mark Edmonds Evidence - Alternatives And Design Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Mark Edmonds Applicant Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Mark Edmonds Applicant p.m. Lunch NZ Transport Agency Applicant Mark Edmonds Applicant Civil Farm, DIG Partnership, Southway, Puriri NZ Transport Agency Applicant Mark Edmonds Applicant June Turner 0:05 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Andrew Bell Evidence - Construction Traffic Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Andrew Bell Evidence - Operational Traffic Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Andrew Bell Applicant Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Andrew Bell Applicant Christophersen Wnesday 9 April Hearing Day 3 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Alternatives and Design and Traffic and Transport (continu) NZ Transport Agency Applicant Andrew Bell Applicant Jen Vella 0:20 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Andrew Bell Applicant Roger Williams 0:25 Roger Williams Roger Williams and June Turner Evidence - Traffic and transport Oppose in part Evidence Roger Williams Roger Williams and June Turner Oppose in part NZTA Lay Evidence and - Alternatives and Design and Traffic and Transport The Campaign for Better Transport Cameron Pitches Oppose in full The Campaign for Better Transport Cameron Pitches Evidence - Traffic and transport Oppose in full Evidence The Campaign for Better Transport Cameron Pitches Oppose in full NZTA NZ Heavy Haulage Association Jonathan Bhana- Thomson Support in part Generation Zero Luke Christensen Oppose in full p.m. Lunch Alternatives and Design and Traffic and Transport (continu) Auckland Transport Gerald Lanning Evidence - Traffic and transport Support in full Legal Submission Page 2

3 / Party Reference Auckland Transport Peter Clark Evidence - Traffic and transport Support in full Evidence Auckland Transport Peter Clark Support in full NZTA 0:05 Asia Pacific International Group New Zealand Limit Asia Pacific International Group New Zealand Limit Asia Pacific International Group New Zealand Limit Ross Dillon Range of views Legal Submission Xian (Sandra) Shen General Range of views Evidence Xian (Sandra) Shen General Range of views NZTA NZ Transport Agency Applicant Robert Pryor Evidence - Landscape And Visual Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Robert Pryor Applicant Warkworth Estate NZ Transport Agency Applicant Robert Pryor Applicant Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Rebecca Skidmore Evidence - Urban Design Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Rebecca Skidmore Applicant Thelma Wilson Evidence - Ecology - Moirs Hill walkway Oppose in part Evidence Thelma Wilson Oppose in part NZTA Lay Evidence and - General (out of order due to availibility) Landscape And Visual Thursday 10 April Hearing Day 4 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Noise and Vibration NZ Transport Agency Applicant Siiri Wilkening Evidence - Construction Noise Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Siiri Wilkening Evidence - Operational Noise Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Siiri Wilkening Applicant Warkworth Estate 0:25 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Siiri Wilkening Applicant Mel Woodley 0:25 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Siiri Wilkening Applicant Christophersen 0:20 NZ Transport Agency Applicant James Whitlock Evidence - Vibration Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant James Whitlock Applicant Christophersen Hydrogeology NZ Transport Agency Applicant Jonathan Williamson Evidence - Hydrogeology Applicant Evidence p.m. Friday 11 April Non-sitting day Monday 14 April Hearing Day 5 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Page 3

4 / Party Reference Stormwater and Siment NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graeme Ridley Evidence - Construction Water Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graeme Ridley Applicant National Trading 0:10 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graeme Ridley Applicant NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graeme Ridley Applicant NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Tim Fisher Evidence - Operational Water Applicant Evidence p.m. Lunch NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Tim Fisher Applicant National Trading Civil Farms, DIG 0:10 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Tim Fisher Applicant Partnership, 0:10 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Tim Fisher Applicant Southway, Puriri Auckland Council Matthew Byrne Evidence - Consent conditions Support in part Evidence Auckland Council Matthew Byrne Support in part NZTA Auckland Council Matthew Byrne Support in part 0:45 Tuesday 15 April Hearing Day 6 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Stormwater and Siment (continu) Brian Handyside Evidence - Erosion and siment Oppose in part Evidence Brian Handyside Oppose in part Auckland Council Brian Handyside Oppose in part NZTA Brian Handyside (continu) Oppose in part NZTA 1:30 p.m. Lunch Ecology - Freshwater NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Wayne Donovan Evidence - Ecology - Freshwater Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Wayne Donovan Applicant Auckland Council NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Wayne Donovan Applicant 0:20 Auckland Council Dr Martin Neale Evidence - Ecology - Freshwater Support in part Evidence Auckland Council Dr Martin Neale Support in part NZTA Page 4

5 / Party Reference Auckland Council Dr Martin Neale Support in part 0:20 Auckland Council Graham Surrey Evidence - Ecology - Freshwater Support in part Evidence Auckland Council Graham Surrey Support in part NZTA Auckland Council Graham Surrey Support in part 0: Dr Michael Pingram Evidence - Ecology - Freshwater Oppose in part Evidence Dr Michael Pingram Oppose in part NZTA NZ Transport Agency Applicant (Rebuttal) Dr Vaughan Keesing Evidence - Ecology - Freshwater Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant (Rebuttal) Dr Vaughan Keesing Applicant Auckland Council NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Sharon De Luca Evidence - Ecology - Marine Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Sharon De Luca Applicant Kristina Hillock Evidence - Ecology - Marine Oppose in part Evidence p.m. Lunch Kristina Hillock Oppose in part NZTA Wnesday 16 April Hearing Day 7 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Civil Farm Partnership, DIG Partnership, Southway, The Puriri Springs Trust Civil Farm Partnership, DIG Partnership, Southway, The Puriri Springs Trust , , , , , , Ecology - Freshwater (continu) Ecology - Marine Lay Evidence and - General Dr Denise Civil Range of views Dr Denise Civil General Range of views Evidence Civil Farm Partnership, DIG Partnership, Southway, The Puriri Springs Trust , , , Dr Denise Civil General Range of views NZTA David Mason David Mason Support in part David Mason David Mason General Support in part NZTA s Page 5

6 / Party Reference New Zealand Historic Places Trust: Pouhere Taonga Duncan McKenzie Neutral Auckland Council Christian Brown Support in part Legal Submission s (tabl representation) Straka Family Trust Julie Straka Neutral (Tabl) 0:05 Thursday 17 April Hearing Day 8 - Northridge Country Lodge, 379 Wainui Road, Silverdale Lay Evidence and Puhoi Motorway Access Retention Society Incorporation Russell Bartlett Support in part Legal Submission (PuMARSI) Puhoi Motorway Access Retention Society Incorporation Vaughan Smith Evidence Support in part Evidence (PuMARSI) Janet Christophersen Jeremy Brabant Range of views Legal Submission 0:45 Janet Christophersen Janet Christophersen General Range of views Evidence Janet Christophersen Janet Christophersen General Range of views NZTA s Ian Gordon and Hua Yu Ian Gordon and Hua Yu Oppose in part Laifu Trust Ian Gordon Oppose in part p.m. Lunch Puhoi Landcare Rodney Straka Neutral Hugh Chapman Hugh Chapman Support in full Centre for Urban and Transport Studies David Willmott Support in full Michelle Leigh Michelle Leigh Support in full National Road Carriers (Inc) Paula Rodgers Support in part Andrew Pickering Andrew Pickering Oppose in part Mahurangi Action Incorporat (establish 1974 as Friends of the Mahurangi) Cimino Cole Oppose in full Hōkai Nuku Karakia Page 6

7 / Party Reference Friday 18 April Good Friday Monday 21 April Easter Monday Tuesday 22 April Non-sitting day Wnesday 23 April Non-sitting day Thursday 24 April Non-sitting day Friday 25 April ANZAC Day Monday 28 April Non-sitting day 10:00 a.m. Hōkai Nuku Karakia Board of Inquiry Introduction Board 0:10 NZ Transport Agency Gena Moses-Te Kani Evidence - Cultural Support Evidence NZ Transport Agency Gena Moses-Te Kani Support Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Rodney Clough Evidence - heritage Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Dr Rodney Clough Applicant Asia Pacific New Zealand Historic Places Trust: Pouhere Taonga Beverley Parslow Evidence - heritage Neutral Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graham Don Evidence - Ecology - Terrestrial Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graham Don Applicant Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graham Don Applicant Asia Pacific NZ Transport Agency Applicant Graham Don Applicant 0:45 p.m. Lunch Auckland Council Nicholas Waipara Evidence - Ecology - Kauri die-back Support in part Evidence Auckland Council Nicholas Waipara Support in part NZTA Auckland Council Nicholas Waipara Support in part Dr Anthony Beauchamp Evidence - Ecology - Terrestrial (including Kauri die-back) Oppose in part Evidence Dr Anthony Beauchamp Oppose in part Auckland Council Dr Anthony Beauchamp Oppose in part NZTA Tuesday 29 April Hearing Day 9 - Ascension Vineyard, 480 Matakana Rd, Matakana Cultural Heritage Ecology - Terrestrial Page 7

8 / Party Reference Andrew Townsend Evidence - Ecology - Terrestrial Oppose in part Evidence Andrew Townsend Oppose in part NZTA Warkworth Estate Ltd William Endean Range of views Ewald Thaller Ewald Thaller Range of views Northland Regional Council Regional Transport Committee John Bain Support in full Whangarei District Council Mark Simpson Support in full Northland Regional Council Bill Shepherd Support in full New Zealand Council for Stephen Selwood and Infrustructure Development Hamish Glenn Support in full Ferat Farmers of New Zealand (Auckland Province) Inc Richard Gardner Support in full Legal Submission p.m. Lunch Robert Scott Robert Scott Oppose in full John Gowing John Gowing Oppose in full Melvyn Woodley Melvyn Woodley Oppose in full Paula Anderson Paula Anderson Oppose in full 0:25 Joseph Anderson Joseph Anderson Oppose in full Wnesday 30 April Hearing Day 10 - Ascension Vineyard, 480 Matakana Rd, Matakana Mahurangi East Residents and Ratepayers Association Inc Ecology - Terrestrial (continu) s Thursday 1 May Hearing Day 11 - Ascension Vineyard, 480 Matakana Rd, Matakana s Bruce Scoggins Range of views Matakana Coast Wine Country, Omaha Beach Community, Matakana Village Businesses and Residents Associations, Warkworth Business Association Martin Dancy Support in full Archer Furniture Group Ltd Lionel Don Support in full Warwick Robertson Warwick Robertson Support in full June Turner June Turner Support in full Page 8

9 / Party Reference Southern Paprika Ltd Hamish Alexander Support in full Graeme Garner Graeme Garner Support in full Vision Wellsford Lionel Foster Support in full Jason Beaumont Jason Beaumont Support in full Dennis Brown Dennis Brown Support in part p.m. Lunch Lee Family Trust Keith Lee Support in part Auckland Business Forum Tony Garnier Support in part Fernbrook farm Jody Pike Oppose in part Paul White Paul White Oppose in part Verity Rowsell-Starkey Verity Rowsell-Starkey Oppose in full Geoffrey & Angela Still Geoffrey & Angela Still Oppose in full Mark Dudley Mark Dudley Oppose in full Max Donnellan Max Donnellan Oppose in full Oliver Hoffmann Oliver Hoffmann Oppose in full Friday 2 May Non-sitting Day Monday 5 May Hearing Day 12 - Ascension Vineyard, 480 Matakana Rd, Matakana Planning Robert B Scott Evidence - Planning Oppose in part Evidence Robert B Scott Oppose in part NZTA Robert B Scott Oppose in part Auckland Council Auckland Council Christopher Turbott Evidence - Planning Support in part Evidence Auckland Council Christopher Turbott Support in part NZTA p.m. Lunch Auckland Council Christopher Turbott Support in part NZ Transport Agency Applicant Karyn Sinclair Evidence - Planning Applicant Evidence NZ Transport Agency Applicant Karyn Sinclair Applicant National Trading 0:10 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Karyn Sinclair Applicant Ferat Farmers 0:25 NZ Transport Agency Applicant Karyn Sinclair Applicant Auckland Council NZ Transport Agency Applicant Karyn Sinclair Applicant Page 9

10 / Party Reference Tuesday 6 May Hearing Day 13 - Ascension Vineyard, 480 Matakana Rd, Matakana Planning (continu) Board of Inquiry BOI Richard Jenkins Board NZTA Board of Inquiry BOI Richard Jenkins Board Auckland Council Board of Inquiry BOI Richard Jenkins Board Closing submissions Teall Crossen Closing submission Oppose in part Closing p.m. Lunch Teall Crossen Closing submission Oppose in part Closing David Mason David Mason Closing statement Support in part Closing 3:00 p.m. Wnesday 7 May Hearing Day 14 - Ascension Vineyard, 480 Matakana Rd, Matakana Closing submissions (continu) NZTA Applicant Paula Brosnahan Closing submission Applicant Closing 1:15 NZTA Applicant Paula Brosnahan Closing submission Applicant Closing 1:30 p.m. Lunch NZTA Applicant Paula Brosnahan Closing submission Applicant Closing 1:15 Hōkai Nuku Karakia 3:00 p.m. Page 10