Kaufland Supermarkets

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Kaufland Supermarkets"

Vivien Stevens
5 years ago
Views:

1 Application for Review Statement of evidence for photomontage preparation prepared by Craig Czarny of Hansen Partnership Pty Ltd. November 2018 urban planning I urban design I landscape architecture I

3 Application for review contents 1 Preamble Technical methodology for photomontage preparation... 2 appendices Appendix A: Appendix B: Appendix C: images Curriculum vitae for Stephen Schutt Survey control point photographs urban planning urban design landscape architecture

4 Application for review 1 Preamble 1. My name is Craig Czarny and I am a director of Hansen Partnership. I have over 30 years experience in urban design and landscape projects in Australia and overseas. I hold a Bachelor degree in Urban Planning and a Masters degree in Landscape Architecture and have provided urban design, streetscape, public domain and landscape planning advice on a number of important development projects of varying scale. Projects that I have managed have received awards from the Planning Institute of Australia (PIA) and Australian Institute of Landscape Architects (AILA). I have also served as a sessional lecturer at Melbourne University, a sessional member of Planning Panels Victoria and judge of local and international design projects. I am recipient of the 2008 Victoria Medal for Landscape Architecture and a Fellow of the Planning Institute of Australia. 2. I have been engaged by Kaufland Australia to consider a proposal for freestanding signage at 03 Kaufland supermarket development sites at: a) High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076; b) 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116, and c) 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175; and prepare photomontage images of the proposal from a number of vantage points on: High Street, Epping; Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park; and Princes Highway, Dandenong 3. A team comprising urban designer, photographer and surveyors visited the site on 19/11/2018. In preparing the photomontage images, the following information was relied upon: Architectural drawings prepared by Leffler Simes Architects, dated 08/11/2018; Survey data obtained on site by Mr Ken Toleman, a licensed surveyor and Director of Geocomp International Pty Ltd, and Digital photographs taken on site by Mr Sang Han. 4. The photomontage images were prepared by Mr Sang Han, a qualified architect employed in my office. I did not personally prepare the photomontages, however in my capacity as a Director at Hansen Partnership, these documents were prepared under my supervision and direction. I reviewed the documents and approved them. 5. I declare that I have no relationship with my client other than an agreement to prepare this evidence statement. urban planning urban design landscape architecture

5 Application for review 2 Technical methodology for photomontage preparation 6. The photomontage process undertaken utilised the following software programmes: Autocad LT 2019; for compilation of site survey information and cadastral information including topography and property boundary data, referenced to both Australian height datum and Australian Map Grid data. 3ds Max 2019 (3D modeller); for construction of a threedimensional model of the proposed development by Hansen Partnership Pty Ltd based on the architectural drawings prepared by Leffler Smies Architects, dated 01/11/2018. Positioning and alignment of the threedimensional model of the proposed development is based on photo locations and reference points obtained on site by Geocomp Consulting Pty Ltd, referenced to both Australian Height Datum and Australian Map Grid data. VRay (rendering software); for applying textures to the model of the proposed development to replicate the architects proposed treatments and finishes, and applying light settings to replicate the existing conditions of the day the photos were taken. Adobe Photoshop CC2018; for rendering views from the dimensional modelled cameras. Locations are superimposed into the photograph without any distortion or manipulation, except for necessary changes to provide a true representation of the proposal within its context. Adobe Illustrator and Indesign CC2018; for sheet layout and text compilation. 7. The 3 Dimensional model of the proposed development was prepared by Hansen Partnership Pty Ltd. The positioning of the model in 3ds Max 2019 (3D modeller) is based on information referred to in paragraph 3 of this evidence statement. 8. The model utilises photo locations and reference points obtained on site by Geocomp Consulting Pty Ltd, referenced to both Australian Height Datum and Australian Map Grid data. Overlaid on these reference points was a threedimensional representation of the proposed development. Those reference points are included in survey data provided by Geocomp Consulting and identified graphically in the survey control point photographs provided in Appendix C. 9. The photos used in the photomontages were taken using a Digital SLR camera (Canon EOS 5Ds) with a lens. 10. The positioning of the camera was set upon a spirit levelled tripod oriented towards the proposed development and taken at a height of 1.6m above ground level. The camera was not tilted but rather set as horizontal. The photographs were taken on the 19/11/2018 between 10.30am and 01.30pm. urban planning urban design landscape architecture

6 Application for review Craig Czarny BTRP M L Arch RLA Director Hansen Partnership Pty Ltd. 27/11/2018 urban planning urban design landscape architecture

7 Application for review Appendix A Images urban planning urban design landscape architecture

8 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 1 from corner of Kimberly Drive and Maroondah Highway, facing Southeast towards proposed sign Existing view 12.06pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: SE VIA001

9 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 1 from corner of Kimberly Drive and Maroondah Highway, facing Southeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign 12.06pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: SE VIA002

10 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 1 from corner of Kimberly Drive and Maroondah Highway, facing Southeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 16m height 12.06pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: SE VIA003

266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 1 from corner of Kimberly Drive and Maroondah Highway, facing Southeast towards proposed sign View of

11 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 1 from corner of Kimberly Drive and Maroondah Highway, facing Southeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 15m height 12.06pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: SE VIA004

12 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 2 from Maroondah Highway, facing East towards proposed sign Existing view 12.15pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA005

13 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 2 from Maroondah Highway, facing East towards proposed sign View of proposed sign 12.15pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA006

14 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 2 from Maroondah Highway, facing East towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 16m height 12.15pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA007

266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 2 from Maroondah Highway, facing East towards proposed sign View of proposed sign

15 266 Maroondah Highway, Chirnside Park, Victoria, 3116 View location 2 from Maroondah Highway, facing East towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 15m height 12.15pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA008

16 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 1 from Princes Highway, facing North towards proposed sign Existing view 11.14pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE N VIA009

17 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 1 from Princes Highway, facing North towards proposed sign View of proposed sign 11.14pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE N VIA010

18 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 1 from Princes Highway, facing North towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 18m height 11.14pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE N VIA011

15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 1 from Princes Highway, facing North towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced

19 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 1 from Princes Highway, facing North towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 15m height 11.14pm on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE N VIA012

20 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 2 from coner of Jones Road and Princes Highway, facing Northeast towards proposed sign Existing view 01.20pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA013

21 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 2 from coner of Jones Road and Princes Highway, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign 01.20pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA014

15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 2 from coner of Jones Road and Princes Highway, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed

22 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 2 from coner of Jones Road and Princes Highway, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 18m height 01.20pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA015

23 15 Gladstone Road, Dandenong, Victoria, 3175 View location 2 from coner of Jones Road and Princes Highway, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 15m height 01.20pm on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA016

592694 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 1 from High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign Existing view 10.

24 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 1 from High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign Existing view 10.28am on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA017

25 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 1 from High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign 10.28am on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA018

26 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 1 from High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 18m height 10.28am on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA019

27 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 1 from High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 15m height 10.28am on the 19/11/18 View location 1: e: n: rl: created by: NE E VIA020

28 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 2 from corner of Cooper Street and High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign Existing view 10.41am on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: SE S VIA021

592694 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 2 from corner of Cooper Street and High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of

29 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 2 from corner of Cooper Street and High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign 10.41am on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: SE S VIA022

30 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 2 from corner of Cooper Street and High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 18m height 10.41am on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: SE S VIA023

31 High Street, Epping Victoria, 3076 View location 2 from corner of Cooper Street and High Street, facing Northeast towards proposed sign View of proposed sign reduced to 15m height 10.41am on the 19/11/18 View location 2: e: n: rl: created by: SE S VIA024

32 Application for review Appendix B Curriculum vitae for Craig Czarny urban planning urban design landscape architecture

Craig Czarny Director email cczarny@hansenpartnership.com.

33 Craig Czarny Director I phone I mobile Summary of Experience Craig is a leading urban design and landscape architect with over 26 years experience across design practice and research, and has an outstanding array of local and international project experience. Craig is a highly regarded contributor to the urban design and landscape debate in Melbourne and overseas through regular project work, publication and conference presentations and is engaged by both government and private sectors to give advice on urban design, landscape and environmental matters. Craig s project work addresses the spectrum of critical design matters facing cities, spaces and places today. He is a strong advocate of strategic design processes and is regularly involved in broad scale land management and city planning initiatives. His expertise in built form analysis and master planning extends to the more intricate design of urban and landscape spaces. This has been demonstrated in considerable project work within both Australia and SouthEast Asia and in North and South America and Great Britain. In addition to his project work, Craig is also an active contributor to research, having served as a sessional lecturer at the University of Melbourne and a regular juror for both local and international urban design and landscape architectural project awards. Current Director Hansen Partnership June 2002 present Experience Context Conybeare Morrison, Sydney and Melbourne, Australia Associate director James Cunning Young, Glasgow and Edinburgh, Scotland Senior designer Qualifications Master of Landscape Architecture, Melbourne University (1991) Bachelor of Town and Regional Planning, Melbourne University (1986) Affiliations Planning Institute of Australia (PIA) fellow Registered Landscape Architect (RLA) Australian Institute of Landscape Architects (AILA) member Victorian Planning and Environmental Law Association (VPELA) member Wilson Sayer Core, Melbourne, Australia Urban designer Specialisations Urban design master planning Town centre planning Design development and documentation of urban design and public projects Townscape and streetscape design assessment Transit city design and TOD master planning Landscape architecture Scenic and landscape assessment Urban design education and training urban planning I urban design I landscape architecture I

Key Project Experience Site Redevelopments Ballarat University Lydiard Street Master Plan (2012) Old Plenty Road, South Morang Development Plan (2012) Saint Andrews Township Urban Design Guidelines

34 Key Project Experience Site Redevelopments Ballarat University Lydiard Street Master Plan (2012) Old Plenty Road, South Morang Development Plan (2012) Saint Andrews Township Urban Design Guidelines (2012) Tooronga Village Development Plan (2005) Knox Strategic Sites: Urban Design Review (2004) Bonbeach TAFE Site Redevelopment (2003) Horsham Tech Park: Urban Design Plan (2003) Mordialloc Built Form Review (2002) Wodonga Technology Park Master plan (2002) Victoria Park Housing Urban Design Master plan (1999) Town Centre/ Transit City Design Hampton East Structure Plan (2013) Bendigo Hospital Precinct Structure Plan (2013) Chapel Revision Structure Plan (2012) Eltham and Diamond Creek Major Activity Centre Guidelines (2012) Korumburra Town Centre Framework Plan (2012) Tally Ho Major Activity Centre Urban & Landscape Design Guidelines (2012) Bayside Housing Strategy (2011) Essendon Station Activity Centre (2011) Heathmont Neighbourhood Activity Centre Structure Plan (2011) Ringwood East Neighbourhood Activity Centre Structure Plan (2011) Traralgon Activity Centre Plan (2009) Hamilton Structure Plan (2009) Airport West Structure Plan (2007) Kilmore Town Structure Plan (2007) Moonee Ponds Town Centre Plan (2007) Melbourne Laneways Study (2006) Ringwood Town Centre Design Master Plan (2005) Knox Central Urban Design Framework (2004) Oakleigh Urban Design Framework (2002) Geelong Western Wedge: Design Framework (2002) Darling Harbour East Concept Design (1997) Community Planning and Design City of Hume Urban Design Training (2013) Eel Hole Creek Pavilion Design (2012) Moonee Valley City Council Councillor Training (2012) Laverton Urban Design and Community Plan (2005) Sydney Olympics Look of the Games (1998) MacQuarie Fields Improvement Master Plan (1997) Riverwood Housing Improvement Master Plan (1996) Townscape Projects Rosebud Urban Design Master Plan (2007) Endeavour Hills Urban Design Plan (2006) Mildura/ Irymple Townscape Study (2006) Sydenham Transit City (2005) Queen Victoria Market Built Form Review (2002) Victoria Street Richmond UDF (2002) Hastings Urban Design Framework (2000) Bayside Height Control/ Urban Design Study (1999) Queenscliffe Urban Character Study (1999) Paddington Townscape Study (1998) Transport and Infrastructure Eltham MAC Precinct 1 Pedestrian Audit (2013) Bridge Street Business Area Pedestrian Audit (2013) Chapel Street Infrastructure Master Plan (2012) Nunawading Activity Centre Urban Realm (2009) Jackass Flat New Development Area Plan (2007) Punt Road Hoddle Street Urban Design Vision (2000) Darling Quays Master Plan(1998) Sydney Light Rail Urban Design (1996) Glebe Island Arterial (1996) Sydney Airport Master Plan(1997) Webb Dock Master Plan (1992) urban planning I urban design I landscape architecture I

35 International Projects Con Dao Precinct Master Plan, BRVT Province Peoples Committee (2013) Xining Transit Oriented Development and Pedestrian Oriented Design (2012) Hai Phong Transit Corridor (2011) Long Than International Aerotropolis Master Plan, Vietnam (2009) Hoa Lac High Tech Park Town Centre, Vietnam (2008) Phan Thiet Urban Leisure & Entertainment City, Vietnam (2008) Ho Chi Minh City Centre Competition, Vietnam (20067) Viengxay Town Master Plan, Lao PDR (20067) Orchard Road Streetscape Upgrade, Singapore (1998) Lok Kawi Seaside Resort, Kota Kinabalu, Borneo (1997) Kota Kinabalu Parliamentary Master Plan, Kota Kinabalu, Borneo Malacca Waterfront Master Plan, Malaysia (1996) Pacific All Seasons Resort, Chulamar, Gautemala (1995) Glasgow Townhead Improvement, Scotland (19935) Livingston RC School, Sterling, Scotland (19935) Niddrie Mains Regeneration Master Plan, Scotland (19935) Ferguslie Park Regeneration Master Plan, Scotland (19935) Marolt Ranch Resort, Aspen Colorado USA (198990) Design Review/ Negotiation Amendment C190 ArdenMacaulay Structure Plan (2013) Amendment C196 City North Structure Plan (2013) Amendment C130 Epping Central (2012) Crystal Ice Precinct, Bendigo (2011) Bay Road, Sandringham Mixed Use (2010) Dennington Town Centre, Warrnambool (2010) The Capitol Development, Chapel Street (2009) Nagambi Mixed Use Site (2009) Caroline Springs Town Centre (2008) Woodgrove Shopping Centre (2008) Bell Station Redevelopment, Preston (2007) Camberwell Junction: The Well (2005) Eastland Expansion Plan (2004) Jacques Site, Richmond (2004) urban planning I urban design I landscape architecture I

36 Application for review Appendix C Survey control point photographs urban planning urban design landscape architecture

Figure 2: Chirnside Park site View location 2 survey

37 Application for review Figure 1: Chirnside Park site View location 1 survey control points. Figure 2: Chirnside Park site View location 2 survey control points. urban planning urban design landscape architecture

38 Application for review Figure 3: Dandenong site View location 1 survey control points. Figure 4: Dandenong site View location 2 survey control points. urban planning urban design landscape architecture

39 Application for review Figure 5: Epping site View location 1 survey control points. Figure 6: Epping site View location 2 survey control points. urban planning urban design landscape architecture

Contents. Appendices. 1 Introduction The site and context Existing design controls Proposal Urban Design Assessment...

Contents. Appendices. 1 Introduction The site and context Existing design controls Proposal Urban Design Assessment... Cover Page Contents 1 Introduction... 1 2 The site and context... 2 3 Existing design controls... 4 4 Proposal... 5 5 Urban Design Assessment... 6 Appendices Appendix A Craig Czarny, Curriculum Vitae Appendix